No. 49 — "Die Welt" — 13
(continued from page 12)
…point of Jewish teaching, which above all demands purity of mind and upright conduct, is in the highest degree reprehensible and abominable. With reference to the trial of Nuchem Schapira, whose name, moreover, I no more mentioned than that of any of his co-defendants, I further set forth that the ugly phenomena coming to light in it have their cause chiefly in the sad economic and cultural conditions of the poor Jewish population in Galicia. I therefore closed my address with a warm appeal to all nobly-minded co-religionists to promote most zealously all endeavours directed towards the cultural and economic uplifting of the distressed classes of the Galician Jews.
This true state of affairs I had already set forth on the 8th and 9th inst. in the most widely read Vienna daily papers, among them the "Neue Freie Presse" (No. 15164) and the "Zeit" (No. 1483), in a declaration confirmed by the President of the Jewish Community here, Dr. Alfred Stern; and in consequence of it Breiter, Member of the Reichstag, at once withdrew, in the most loyal manner, in the papers named and in others, the accusations raised against me in his interpellation of the 5th inst."
Editorial postscript. We loyally give space to this correction, but remark that we took our grounds from the concurring reports of Vienna Jewish papers, which devoted great attention to the affair. The impression which Dr. David's remarks made upon a part of his hearers was in any case this: that by generalising from a single case he had grievously wronged the Galician Jews. This, indeed, led to excited protest meetings and to the dispatch of a deputation to the President of the Jewish Community. If, however, Rabbi Dr. David was really understood otherwise (and this fact is not open to correction) than he wished to be understood, according to his statements above, then our comments would of course fall away as groundless. We do not hesitate to regard his present declaration as sufficient to clear up the matter, which herewith appears to be satisfactorily settled.
Nuances or Differences?
"In my view the way to true and sound reconciliation everywhere leads only through the harsh and bitter recognition of the whole sharpness and the deep earnestness of the actual oppositions . . . . . ., whereas I hold a sham reconciliation by hushing up and papering over to be not only untenable and worthless, but worse than the open strife and honest struggle of the parties." (Ed. v. Hartmann. Preface to the 2nd ed. of "Das Judentum in Gegenwart und Zukunft.")
Ever since the VIIth Congress with its storms was over, the fiction has again and again been spread in Zionist circles that oppositions no longer exist. The right synthesis of political and practical Zionism, it is said, has been found in the resolutions of the Congress, and henceforth there could only be various nuances of conception, which are blown up into differences by fault-finders; or else it is merely a matter of misunderstandings, kept up and deepened by people who are moved in this only by the vain wish to play a part or to shine with their dialectic. "The crisis is over!" it was decreed, and those who decreed it doubtless believed it themselves; and when, soon after the Congress, deeply shaken by the sharpness of the oppositions that had come to light at Basle, I ventured to write: "No, the crisis is only beginning!" I was scolded as a seeker of quarrels and a fanatic of dogma. "The crisis is over!" one has heard asserted again and again since then, and for a time it might almost have seemed so, since for a year past no fault-finding man of the opposition has been given a hearing in the official organs. Nevertheless, at all the larger gatherings of the party the spectacle is repeated that the interest is filled almost exclusively by the discussion of the disputed problems, and only the close of such meetings, or the official report, brings once more the reassuring assurance that a clarification and a peaceful understanding have at last been reached. And with all this there can be no doubt that points of difference of an incisive nature persist, and that these will also stand at the centre of the VIIIth Congress.
No tactics of silence and appeasement will change that. Or will anyone perhaps wish to assert that such loyal and moderate men as Alexander Marmorek and Kreme-
netzky are "beaters of the drum of phrases," inclined to "absurd exaggerations and mere fantastic dreams," whose utterances could only be understood as the product of a "spirit of coterie"? Unhappily, since the VIIth Congress these are the only two of the old spokesmen who have raised their voices. Many others, from whom one formerly so gladly heard a vigorous word, have "with downcast gaze" withdrawn into the land of mute resignation, wrap themselves in bitter silence, or have turned to other interests. A sultry stillness, as it were, lies over the whole movement, and only a thunderstorm that clears the air can lead to new and fruitful life and activity. Under all circumstances it is better to give voice to the oppositions and fight them out than to deny them or to kill them with silence.
Mr. Sokolow ("Welt" No. 46) asserts that fundamental differences of opinion do not exist at all, that the tendencies towards practical small colonisation and the political-ideal direction not only do not contradict one another, but actually complement each other. This assertion is refuted by the simple fact that for more than 3 years the debates on the questions concerned have surged to and fro and cannot come to rest, although one must unreservedly grant all concerned the honest will to arrive at peace and union. It is surely not mere young hotspurs, to whom strife means a sport and a pleasure, who are fighting out these battles of opinion; on the contrary, it was precisely mature and even aged men who stood in the forefront on both sides, men who see the rift in our ranks with bleeding hearts and would gladly make sacrifices to help close it, if it were really a matter only of misunderstandings and shadings, and not rather of the fundamental principles of the movement. To be sure, if with Mr. Sokolow one abhors all dogmatics for our movement, then there can be no more differences; they are banished from the world with ease. Certainly, an eternal idea is open to many changes in its practical shaping; but if a state firmly knit in its organisation rests securely only upon the brazen foundation of the constitution, of the fundamental laws of the state, and protects itself against their displacement by quite special safeguards, then all the more must a political movement, and one so young besides as the Zionist Organisation, hold fast to principles and protect itself by dogmatic fixation against all manner of incalculable currents which might undermine it and seriously shake it. Therefore no ordered movement can exist without dogma, not even the socialist, although it has inscribed the shattering of old dogmas upon its banner; and such dogmas may be altered only when fundamental changes in the external conditions irresistibly compel it.
Our movement started from the condemnation of the old Chovevei-Zionist "colonial policy," and postulated above all security under public law as the basis of a Jewish State; and Herzl's word: "The one thing to be held to inviolably is this: the basis can only be a condition of right and not of toleration" — this word ought to remain an authoritative dogma for us, which no sophistry, but only a revolutionary change of external circumstances, can banish from the world. The VIIth Congress no longer saw the man who until then had guaranteed the continuity of principles; all the more scrupulously ought one to have taken care not to shake the principles he had laid down and held to so tenaciously and with so much success. Instead, this very Congress brought to the surface currents which tend to detach our movement more and more from its political foundations and to slip beneath it once more the Chovevei-Zionist foundations long since recognised as useless. (Mr. Sokolow will again complain of the use of catchwords; but not for nothing are catchwords in use everywhere, not only in politics but in science as well, precisely because they bring whole complexes of ideas into the light at a single stroke.) Until 2 years ago, at any rate, the enormous majority of Zionists were agreed that in Palestine one could perform only technical and scientific preparatory work and promote cultural endeavours; that land might be purchased at most for scientific-technical institutes, but never for colonising purposes; that the immigration of new elements before the creation of legal foundations was not desirable and in no case deserving of encouragement. To-day the Zionist Organisation, or rather the Palestine Commission, is occupied exclusively with buying land; small colonisation and immigration, to which the Second Congress put an end, are once more in full bloom. The unorganised influx of elements without means and without energy, in great part undisciplined and otherwise unsuitable as well, is, as in the Bilu era, emphatically celebrated and enthusiastically promoted, although even Mr. Sokolow a certain dread not