Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 44 · 2 November 1906
10printed page
scan 8 of 22

Page 10. — "Die Welt" — No. 44.

(continued from page 9)

…yields in the way of means of power, these means of power undergoing in Palestine a considerable increase through the possibility of bringing the nascent economic unit nearer to the realisation of Socialism by co-operative measures, especially in the agrarian field.

Proceeding from these principles, the "Jewish Socialist Labour Party Poale-Zion" of Austria declares:

I. We stand upon the ground of socialist doctrine and strive for the socialisation of all the means of production and the transformation of the production of commodities into socialist production, carried on for and by society.

II. The most important point of the minimum programme of the Poale-Zion party, which in all its other demands agrees with the programmes of the Social Democratic parties, is the territorial solution of the Jewish Question in Palestine.

III. Until this point of the programme is realised, the party strives, in States of many nationalities, for the full equality of rights of the Jewish people on the basis of national autonomy, without seeing in the attainment of Jewish national chambers, autonomous in economic, political and cultural questions, for the parts of the Jewish people living in the lands of the Golus, a solution of the Jewish Question or a precondition of its territorial solution.

S. Kaplansky-Kaplan. The principles and ideas of the draft programme which I have the honour to lay before you are the result of a development that took place in two camps which influenced each other: Social Democratic Jews, who belonged to all manner of socialist parties of other nationalities, became Jewish Social Democrats, and the Zionist proletarians developed into proletarian Zionism. The socialist ideal, laying hold of the Jewish masses, is influenced by them and takes up more and more elements of the national life — Jewish Socialism comes into being. The Jewish Question, once raised, does not vanish from the agenda of the Jewish labour parties; the Jewish proletariat does not shrink from the most decided, most radical consequences. And it has drawn these consequences! This draft is to furnish a justification and a summary of the results gained from the objective study of the Jewish Question of the Jewish proletariat.

The keynote of the draft is the analysis of Jewish reality guided by economic points of view. Whether historical materialists or not, we are all agreed that the economic conditions of life turn the scale in all social transformations.

The present economic development of our people stands under the sign of capitalism. Its effects upon Jewry¹) are not, however, to be judged by a pattern, for we have here to reckon with phenomena of our economic life whose peculiarity is unmistakable. The Jews form no closed economic whole, normally articulated in itself; since the loss of their soil they have always been only a part of other economic units. — As you know, we hold the view that nations and peoples are also economically independent (not isolated!) phenomena. Our opponents smile at this. They have read in the text-books of national, or more correctly State, economies, and of a world economy. But of a national economy! Well, they commit a small error of thought. In asserting that the economic development of the Jews proceeds just as with all peoples rooted in their soil, it is they who regard the Jewish people as an economic unit. It is they, properly speaking, who talk of a Jewish national economy. We, on the contrary, speak of the lack of a Jewish national economy. For our development is determined by the development of the whole to which we attach ourselves. That is the cause of our migration from countries where we had an economic function and in the end had played ourselves out, to countries which had need of us and in which we could still take up an economic function. But that is also the cause of our economic mutilation and crippling. In the course of the time of the Golus we have lost the peasantry, that is, the stratum from which the most important classes, such as the industrial proletariat, arise; and the majority of our people belongs to those middle strata which are condemned to be crushed by capitalism. It is this economic abnormality, too, which made a complete adaptation of the Jews to the peoples whose "hospitality" they enjoyed impossible. The peculiarities of our economic position and development also kept the national individuality alive. Economic absorption would surely have drawn after it

spiritual dissolution as well. This phenomenon we observe in the development of the Jewish upper bourgeoisie, which has not merely joined the ruling classes economically, but strives to merge itself in them culturally as well. — The economic process which led to the formation of this bourgeoisie did not take place within Jewish economic life. The Jewish bourgeoisie is a result of the capitalist development of the country concerned; its rise and development exercise no other influence upon the shaping of economic conditions within Jewry than the growth of capitalism and the strengthening of the bourgeoisie of the country in general, of which the Jewish capitalists are a component part. I sum it up briefly by saying: the rise of the Jewish upper bourgeoisie does not entail a Jewish industrial proletariat of equal worth and equal rank. That part of the Jewish workers which has been drawn into industry belongs, as you know, to the dwarfishly developed classes of our people; in its development it by no means keeps pace with the rapid growth of the proletariat of the countries we dwell in, be it even a backward country like Galicia. Numerically weak, the Jewish proletariat is chained to a technically undeveloped industry worked with hand machines, and finds no access to modern large-scale enterprise. But this industrial proletariat forms an insignificant part of the Jewish workers, the overwhelming majority of whom are still at the mercy of the basest exploitation in petty handicraft and home industry, in the most technically backward dwarf enterprises, in which the number of masters exceeds that of the journeymen. It is also a characteristic of the Jewish proletariat that it is herded together in only a limited number of branches of production. I will not weary you with statistical tables, and cite only the fact that more than 66% (that is, ²/₃) of all the Jews employed in industry (more correctly, in handicraft) are concentrated in the three branches of industry — the clothing industry, the food industry, and the beverage and luxury-goods industry — whereas in Austria as a whole these industries embrace only 29% of all proletarians. I cite Austria deliberately, because in this country the political pressure that weighs upon Russia is absent, to whose baneful effects our opponents would gladly ascribe all the peculiarities of our economic development.

The fact that the Jewish proletariat is kept away from large-scale industry, from modern large-scale enterprise, is, moreover, now generally admitted. Only our opponents believe that they must trace this phenomenon of immense import to transient causes, such as the political conditions in Russia. It is forgotten in this that the fact holds good for constitutional Austria just as for absolutist Russia. Those who would have our future bound to the lands of the Golus forget, moreover, that our economic development is imperiously determined by the economic transformations of these countries. And this benefits first of all the expropriated masses torn from the soil; it is a phenomenon grounded in the very nature of the capitalist development of the countries we dwell in, that these proletarianised masses of the rural population are led into the modern mode of production and strive to secure and maintain the economic positions they have reached. Thus our proletarianised masses, become destitute of property and of work, are pushed aside, even if no series of unfavourable factors of a secondary nature were added. Certainly the non-Jewish middle strata, too, are heavily struck by this development; but only we count some 80% of our people among these sinking middle classes, given over to impoverishment and declassing. — Is this abnormal economic articulation and development, which does not fail of its effect upon the Jewish proletariat too, of no account for the class struggle of our proletariat and for the tasks of the Jewish labour parties that wish to lead this class struggle? A Bundist spokesman has, to be sure, cited the peculiarity of social conditions in Jewry and the unique class differentiation as proof of the necessity of an independent Jewish proletarian organisation.¹) But is the Jewish Question then put out of the world for the Jewish proletariat by an alteration of the rules of organisation? We maintain that a Jewish socialist party has also quite special tasks to fulfil and to accomplish.

Let us dwell somewhat longer upon this: the fable has been trumpeted abroad that we, the Poale-Zion, deny the existence of a Jewish "proletariat." That is just what it is, a fable. It would be foolish to assert that the hundreds of thousands of exploited Jewish workers, creators of surplus value, form no proletariat. They form


¹) The word is here always used as synonymous with "Jewish people." ¹) Liber at the 2nd Party Congress of Russian Social Democracy.