Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 41.
(continued from page 5)
…of 17 years, Marie Juhasz, in service. Suddenly she had disappeared. The peasants of the neighbourhood knew at once, of course, what had happened. "The Jews have slaughtered her." A lively agitation began. The girl was soon found. Not far from Zenta her body was drawn out of the Theiss. But now it was claimed that marks of strangling had been seen on the neck. Of course the Jews had done it! And armed with axes, scythes and flails the peasant band of avengers marched before the cantor's house, smashed the windows and threatened the Jews of the place with their lives, until gendarmes arrived, who at length restored order.
One sees that Hungary no longer needs to learn much from Russia. The first great pogrom of recent years in Russia, that of Kishineff, likewise began with first threatening a pogrom, then devising cunning ritual-murder fables, — until one day the passions of the people were ripe for the bloody deed.
Jewish Colonisation Society in Vienna
Elsewhere in our paper we print the appeal of the Vienna Jewish Colonisation Society. With just satisfaction one may record this first instance in which the leading Jews of Vienna of all party tendencies — even of those otherwise in bitter feud with one another, — in which Zionists, Nationalists, Liberals and Orthodox have found a common ground for an action directed towards further aims. Still more gratifying is it that the uniting programme lies in the founding of Jewish colonies in Palestine.
There is, of course, no doubt that the motives from which the members of the committee approach the matter are not of one kind. For the Zionists on the committee the founding of colonies is naturally only a beginning; for most of the others it is an end in itself. But even to these — if we interpret the words of the appeal rightly — the Colonisation Society means more than a merely philanthropic undertaking. Philanthropy could have confined itself to the long-accustomed form of alms. The plan of founding homesteads with a view to the Jewish distress in Russia has about it a larger trait, if not of national, then at least of social policy. And even if we do not wish to overrate this advance, we are glad to establish and acknowledge it.
Vienna has in recent years — apart from the heightened Zionist activity and that of internal Jewish politics — been more or less shut out of the complex of manifold Western European activities which the storms in Russia had set in motion. The centres for these were London and Berlin. And yet this great Jewish community, if its leaders succeeded in breaking the well-known Viennese inclination to ease, could accomplish an extraordinary deal for the movement of Jewry as a whole. This much is certain — judging by the names of the members of the committee alone — that in the Colonisation Society good preconditions for comprehensive work have been created. May good fruits ripen from these good beginnings!
STORM-COMRADE VOGELSTEIN *)
By SAMMY GRONEMANN (Hanover)
(Conclusion.)
Zionism has, as Dr. Vogelstein does not fail to recognise, in many cases "had an enlivening and stimulating effect" in hitherto indifferent circles "and instilled in them an interest in Jewish affairs". — Therein, in the Rabbi's opinion, lies the first danger for Jewry as a whole. For: the "illusions" will vanish, the interest will evaporate, and as sediment there will remain a downright hostile disposition towards everything Jewish. — Not bad! — We too believe that we must expect many a danger for Jewry as a whole from the side of the indifferent. The danger lies precisely in their indifferentism, — which of course, as Dr. Vogelstein points out with no mean satire against the readers of his prayer-book, is by no means identical with Liberalism. — These indifferent Jews avoid everything Jewish, wish as far as possible to make it forgotten that they are Jews, — in short, they really do display a hostile disposition towards everything Jewish. Hitherto little success has been attainable in the struggle against indifferentism; the host of the indifferent grows from year to year, especially where Liberalism has pitched its camp. That it is recruited precisely from the circles of the Liberals, that the boundary-lines between Liberalism and indifferentism are blurred past recognition, is best proved by the humorous remark of the Rabbi just quoted. So he too sees with pain the growth of indifferentism. Now come the Zionists and achieve what has been impossible for him, for all his professional colleagues and those who share his views, and bring back hosts from the hostile camp into ours. — Dr. Vogelstein will not have these returning ones, for perhaps, — perhaps a reaction will one day set in, and then — well, then it will be just as it is now, and at all events no worse! — Dr. Vogelstein wants guarantees, — the sure pledge that the new interest in Judaism will never flag. What, now, if the disciples of the Liberal messengers of salvation were to say to them: "You strike out our old commandments, take from us our old customs, our old Bible, — all things with which we have made shift for some thousands of years, — and you give us in exchange nothing but new, untried things; guarantee us that upon the first enthusiasm for the pretty things there will not follow a reaction, — a slackening of all interest, a downright hostile disposition towards everything Jewish!" — The gentlemen would have no answer, for they would lack the possibility of pointing to history, to facts, as we can. History would sorely disavow them! For short as the reign of Liberalism in its little domain has been, — already to-day the great Liberal prophet and prayer-book poet must warn against confusing Liberalism with indifferentism! — We, however, create no new illusions, as Dr. Vogelstein seems to assume. We rest upon the fact of the existence of the Jewish people,
*) We gave the first part of the essay the title "Protestrabbiner redivivus". In a letter to us the author repudiates this heading, which did not originate with him, pointing out in particular that he by no means wishes to dispose of Dr. Vogelstein with the word "Protestrabbiner", which has become a generic label. The author considers that an injustice is done to Dr. Vogelstein by his designation as a Protestrabbiner, since in this way he is lumped together with a number of gentlemen whose one-sided resistance to Zionism perhaps does not rest upon such absolutely ideal motives as undoubtedly exist in Dr. Vogelstein. —
On this occasion we also correct that in the first part of the essay, p. 13, column 2, lines 8 and 9, instead of "two weeks" it should read "two years".