Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 39 · 28 September 1906
30printed page
scan 28 of 32

Page 30. — "Die Welt" — No. 39.

(continued from page 29)

…this opinion was later altered only through an insistence upon the enlarged resolution concerning the purposes at the VI. Congress, a resolution regarding which I have already proved that it is of no binding force, and which ought no more to have influenced the judgment of Counsel than it will influence our own judgment here.

In support of this view I appeal to the reproduction of the first expression of opinion which is contained in the later expression of opinion of Mr. Armitstead, dated 11 May of this year (Document IX), and reads as follows:

"The original proposal, according to which the purposes of the Fund would be confined to the purchase of land in Palestine for the benefit of the Jews and to other purposes closely connected therewith, could without doubt be embodied in a Trust Deed, because the purposes of the Trust would then be much less far-reaching than those contained in the Memorandum of Association, and all the purposes would be charitable. A considerable disadvantage of this plan, however, is that the operations of the Trust would be greatly restricted and the scope of the resolutions of the Sixth Congress considerably diminished."

Is it not clear that, apart from this error regarding the basis, we should have had no further differences of opinion concerning the facts, at least so far as the English jurists are concerned, and that with regard to the constitution of the Fund in the form of a Trust, as this is stated in the original expression of opinion. The only objection of importance which has been raised against the plan of a Trust Deed is that this plan is an impractical one, because of the danger "that a part of the purposes of the Trust would probably not be regarded as charitable, and that in that case the Trust Deed, so far as the property in England is concerned, would be void" (Opinion of Mr. Armitstead, May 1906); but this objection that has been raised is to be ascribed to the emergence of the invalid resolution concerning the purposes at the VI. Congress, and all the later expressions of opinion have been founded either upon that or upon the still more misleading statement of the purposes, precisely because they have been enlarged, as contained in the draft statutes, wherein it is intended to carry the agreed resolutions into effect in the form of a Limited Cy.

No such danger is scented in the earlier expressions of opinion, which were probably founded upon the original plan and upon the statement of the purposes as approved by the Congress.

It emerges clearly from the last expression of opinion of Mr. Armitstead (May 1906) "that the purchase of land in Palestine for the benefit of the Jews and other purposes closely connected therewith" (which are the true purposes of the National Fund) would bring no such risk with them, because these would all be "charitable" purposes in the legal sense. It is also necessary to explain here that by English law public purposes are, in the legal sense, charitable undertakings, and that these undertakings might perhaps more aptly be designated "social purposes".

The Morte-Main Act of 1888 contained an enumeration of purposes (taken from an earlier Act which is over 300 years old) which are deemed "charitable", and these include such things as, for example, "the repair of bridges, havens, causeways, churches, sea-banks and highways", "the relief or redemption of prisoners or captives", besides a number of other purposes which would ordinarily not be regarded as charitable undertakings. The correct conception of this matter is of the highest importance, because, if the purposes of the National Fund were confined (as was originally the case with them) to purposes which are truly charitable in the legal sense, the great advantage would be gained that the possibility offered by English law of making the Trust a perpetual one would thereby be given, and the maintenance of the constitution and orderly administration of the Trust Deed would be secured by the control exercised by the Charity Commissioners; and in this way the intention of the A. C. would be fulfilled in the fullest possible measure, to the effect that "the possibility of an alteration of the statutes and purposes be excluded once and for all".

The importance of keeping to the original purposes, which plainly had a "charitable character" in the legal sense, is attested in the joint opinion of Counsel (contained in Document III, page 6 of the supplement), where conditions are set out for the exemption of the income of the National Fund from this taxation, namely: "In so far as such income is applicable to charitable purposes only under the respective provisions of the company, and is in fact applied to charitable purposes only." It is the enlarged purposes, brought into the matter by the invalid resolution at the VI. Congress, which have aroused doubts in Counsel as to whether this exemption can be claimed, "because we are not satisfied that the company will exist for charitable purposes only". It is the unquestionable duty of this Conference to see to it that such doubts are removed and that no unsuitable character be imparted to this national undertaking, for this is a constant danger to which the whole income of the Fund would be exposed, should the possibility be afforded of departing from the original "charitable purposes".

The alternative form of legalisation which has been put before us, and whose adoption is also being pressed upon us, and all this resting upon the authority of Dr. Bodenheimer, is that of a Limited Liability Cy. The real difference between the two proposals is that the one makes restrictions possible, while the other favours the enlargement of the purposes; and it is a question for the Conference which of these proposals is not only the right step for the future, but the correct standpoint in relation to the actual National Fund, with regard to its origin and its earlier history. In my opinion the idea of a National Fund with limited liability is a veritable monstrosity. This is not only a misuse of a designation, but a misuse of legal form. The incorporation of such a fund as a trading company is an offence against the whole spirit of the institution, and gives a wholly false impression as to the purposes and intentions of the original founders, subscribers and actual interested parties. At this point I should like to cite the objections which were already raised at the V. Congress by a prominent delegate (Dr. Byck):

"It was proposed that a company should be founded. But it is not a question of a company, but of a fund, of a property devoted to a purpose; neither of a joint-stock company, nor of a co-operative society, nor of an association, but of a property which exists for a definite purpose, and of the administration of this property under legal protection. In my judgment this is possible only in the form of a foundation. The foundation corresponds completely to what we wish to attain, while the proposal that we should found a joint-stock company is a downright mockery of the truth. It will not do for our great ethical movement to begin with an untruth." (Minutes, page 275.)

Now there is also an important and well-considered pronouncement from another quarter regarding this phase of the matter. A pronouncement which is, or ought to be, of a decisive nature for this Conference, apart from all questions of prejudice. It comes from no less an authority than Dr. Bodenheimer himself, and consists of two parts:

a) a letter from Dr. Bodenheimer to Dr. Farbstein regarding a plan for a co-operative society drafted by the latter, which is cited on page 77 of the Report of the National Fund Commission (1902) and begins as follows: "For your draft statutes for the National Fund I offer you my best thanks. You have sought in a thoroughly ingenious manner to make the impossible possible, namely to press a property devoted to a purpose into the form of a co-operative society, of an association. But, my dear sir. You have here expended a wealth of intellect in a wrong direction, since I see no reasons whatever for not framing the National Fund in the form of a foundation, which is the form naturally called for in its case. . . . . That the National Fund pursues an economic purpose is at the very least doubtful; it has rather a general social character.

b) Introductory remarks to a statute drafted for the J. N. F. in the form of a foundation by Advocate Dr. Bodenheimer of Cologne, set out in the same Report, page 89, as follows: "By the whole nature of the N. F. it has not an 'economic' but a 'social' purpose; it is, however, the purpose alone that is decisive for the character of an undertaking, not the manner of administration. That the administration must have an economic character is self-evident, and there exist countless foundations which undertake the most magnificent business transactions and industrial enterprises with their property, without the character of a foundation serving social or religious purposes being thereby affected . . . . .