Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 39 · 28 September 1906
29printed page
scan 27 of 32

No. 39. — "Die Welt" — Page 29.

(continued from page 28)

…carrying-out of this resolution, to collaborate, and I gladly accepted this invitation, in the hope of bringing the Tohu Wabohu of the National Fund problem to a speedy conclusion.

At the end of January 1906 a meeting of the Commission was called in Brussels, at the same time as the Special Conference was taking place, and I attended this meeting, which, however, passed without result, since the matter was referred to the Inner A. C. On 4 February, however, I received an official communication from the President, which reads: "The A. C. has resolved, for the legalisation of the National Fund, to refrain from the establishment of a Limited Company and to prefer the form of a Trust Deed."

The matter was then handed over to Solicitors, who were to carry the above instructions into effect by making the necessary drafts; but new difficulties then arose, and an exchange of opinions took place, which is reproduced in the appendix of Documents IX to XIII.

After full consideration of this expression of opinion on the part of the Inner A. C., the following resolution was finally passed on 23 May and then officially communicated to me: "The Inner A. C. was of the opinion that it lay in the interest of the National Fund if even the mere possibility of an alteration of its statutes and purposes were excluded once and for all, and therefore declared itself at this sitting also in favour of the establishment of a foundation (Trust Deed)."

Unfortunately this resolution was not communicated to the Solicitors, and they therefore proceeded to lay new questions before Counsel, which were founded upon wholly erroneous views concerning the facts and the wishes of the responsible body (the Inner A. K.), as these had found expression in the repeatedly and clearly considered decisions.

The result was the situation into which the matter was brought, whereby, in consequence of a misunderstanding as to the true standpoint of Dr. Bodenheimer in this matter (acknowledged and abandoned by him in the last Document No. XVIa, which is appended to the supplement), instructions for the draft of a kind of constitution (Limited Liability Company) to which the assent of the A. C., or of the Commission which had been entrusted by the A. C. with the work of legalisation, was never given.

This Conference can no more recognise as authentic the draft statutes laid before it, which is after all the result of a misunderstanding, than the Congress would deem of binding force the resolution concerning the purposes which was passed at the night sitting of 27 August 1903 under similar informal conditions.

I turn from the historical summary, which had become necessary because of the imperfect nature of the documents in the supplement, to the alternative forms of legalisation.

It is true that I was the very first to set forth, in a compound form, the character of the Trust proposition with reference to the National Fund, which proposition had the assent of the late Dr. Herzl in 1902, and which the A. C. has sought to revise by its resolutions this year.

At the VI. Congress this was explained by my highly esteemed colleague and helper, the late Dr. Isidor Marmorek, in the following manner:

"Mr. Bentwich has brought the matter into a relation, in the sense of the law of obligations, with the Colonial Bank. Never shall the property of the National Fund be devoted to the Colonial Bank or merged with it, and the Colonial Bank thereby receive any advancement. The relationship was conceived as a 'fiduciary relationship', such as exists when someone hands over a particular endowment to a quite particular, already existing juristic person, as when, for example, someone wishes to found a hospital and says to a city, for example Basle: I hand over to you this property for the founding of a hospital. In this case the city of Basle is the owner of the property, but by this dedication the disposal of the property is at the same time withdrawn from it. This construction would have the advantage that we should overcome all those difficulties which are occasioned by the diversity of legislation in the various countries, and that each succeeding Congress would still have a handle by which to give directions regarding this endowed property."

I take the liberty here of adding the following ideas to this short citation:

This important fund, which the confidence of the people has placed in the hands of the Executive, is of all foundations the most sacred. Why, then, should it not be placed upon a legal basis that would correspond to its nature?

Why should it not be declared to be what it in truth is, a Trust, a foundation of confidence? The National Fund is no competitor of the Jewish Colonial Bank and ought not to be one. It exists solely to support or to supplement it. In Herzl's "Judenstaat" the creation of a financial instrument for national purposes is provided for; this instrument is the Jewish Colonial Bank. The Bank is the juristic person which represents, or ought to represent, the Jewish national party in all its business relations with other "persons", whether individuals or governments. The creation of another juristic person in the name of the Jewish National Fund was never intended as an interference with these functions, but was solely designed to support the Fund and to secure the carrying-out of its special tasks, if need be through the intervention of the courts. It is apparently overlooked that this was already provided for in the original constitution of the Bank, which contemplated the creation of special funds and trusts to be administered by the Bank. Indeed, even the Congress resolutions provided that the Bank should act as the depository of the National Fund.

A special control over the Fund would be as easy to effect under the constitution of the Bank as if a new and independent company were founded to represent it. Companies, after all, consist only of individuals and are administered by them. It is therefore just as easy to separate the personnel of the board of administration of the National Fund under the Jewish Colonial Bank from the supervisory board or the other functionaries of the latter as to call into being anew a directorate or a board of administration in a separate company. Further, there is no difficulty whatever in securing, by means of the deed of foundation which is to set forth the constitution of the National Fund, complete independence from the Bank as regards supervision and administration. It would then be open to the contributors to the National Fund to elect their own directorate or their own board of administration, and in this way actually to keep the conduct of affairs in their own hands. The Bank would then be the juristic person through whose agency the responsible representatives of the National Fund would conduct its business, while the shareholders of the Bank would have no claim whatever to participation or interference in the affairs of the National Fund.

There is, I take it, general agreement that it is desirable to place the National Fund under the protection of English law, as Baron Hirsch did with his great foundations. The procedure here proposed would thus be in exact agreement with that precedent. For the share capital of the I. C. A. was merely the smallest part of the sums which Baron Hirsch had destined for his great plan. By far the greatest amounts came in addition in subsequent special endowments.

Concentration, not dispersion, of forces is the innermost core of our undertaking. If the "financial instrument of Zionism" is to accomplish things of national importance, then it must be strengthened in every possible way with all legally admissible means. Not the least advantage that will result from the union of the National Fund with the Jewish Colonial Bank will be the greater security which the introduction of new supervisory elements will bring with it; and then a renewal of the former enthusiasm for the enlargement of the financial resources of our movement will not fail to follow.

The National Fund has been called the "key of the Colonial Bank", and it has even been said of it: "If we did not have the National Fund, we should have no benefit from the Colonial Bank either." Let the two institutions work together, the one to acquire land and the other to help in its development; then they would run no danger of the one hampering the other's development, but on the contrary they would assist one another in development and together create a perfected financial instrument of Zionism.

We must beware of the multiplication of institutions; we should never forget the maxim that "a single bullet carries further than a handful of shot".

I will not here repeat the technical arguments in favour of the Trust form of legalisation, as these are set forth in the documents of the supplement; I refer particularly to my remark (in Document No. X., page 23). — It suffices for me to rest upon the original expression of opinion of Mr. Armitstead (Document II), in which both of the alternative ways and means are recommended which are admissible for the founding of such a foundation (Trust), and further to point out that