No. 37 — "Die Welt" — Page 11.
(continued from page 10)
…justified complaints about the decline of practical Zionist work, it can likewise be stated that Zionist feeling is growing ever stronger.
We know that new, young parties have differentiated themselves out of the general Zionist organisation, as for example the S. S. (Zionist-Socialists), the Wosroschdenzer (Autonomists with the programme of a National Assembly), etc. etc., whereby a fairly considerable number of young forces have left our organisation. These latter interpret the national question from their own standpoint, one approaching the Marxist, subordinating it to the class and economic struggle; but in the end these parties, which are based upon nationalism and are at bottom saturated with Zionist elements, by no means grow solely at the expense of the Zionist organisation alone, but in the same measure, if not in a still more considerable one, at the expense also of those quite strong parties which stand in opposition to us on principle. The Jewish press, too, may serve as a clear sign of the growth of Zionist feeling in Russia; with a few exceptions it is either purely Zionist or at least friendly disposed towards Zionism.
As regards the Zionist organisation in Russia, it is surely clear to everyone that at the present moment it is passing through a grave crisis. True, even formerly there resounded at every congress and gathering continual complaints about the insufficient firmness of the organisation and the feeble functioning of the life of the societies; but of late this situation has grown considerably worse under the influence of events in Russia.
The unforgettable creator of the Zionist organisation grasped the great truth that the only guarantee for the realisation of the Zionist ideal is the will of the people. But unfortunately nothing has been done to work out and develop this will in the people in earnest. The expression of will is usually a consequence of awakening self-consciousness; but the will grows and thrives only upon the soil of concrete activity, upon the soil of the realisation of the ideal and of a gradual approach towards it, slow perhaps, but steady and perceptible. The abstract ideal is accessible to few. And in this respect very little has been done. However essential and and valuable practical Zionist work may be, — such as the sale of shekels, bank shares, National Fund stamps, etc., — it is not exhaustive; it has no gripping, inspiring character, and for that reason it does not educate either. When, then, a feeling of dissatisfaction grew powerful in the organisation, the urge to activity degenerated into the opposite extreme: men threw themselves with burning zeal upon "present-day work," and everything that stood in even the remotest relation to general Jewish reality, such as trade unions, fire brigades and the like, was designated "Zionist" work. Between the so-called "present-day work" and the ultimate Zionist ideal, however, there was no logical connection.
To these inner causes which led the Zionist organisation into its present crisis were added still other important factors of general Russo-Jewish life, such as the general political disorders in the country and the terrors of the pogroms in all the Jewish communities of Russia.
The horrors of the pogroms have only proved what had long been clear enough to many, namely, that the short-sighted quasi-Zionist doctrine, "the worse the situation of the Jews, the better for Zionism," is false and untenable from the ground up.
A few words more on the part the revolution has played in the momentary disturbance of the development of the Zionist organisation in Russia. On all sides one now hears the opinion voiced that the whole of the Jewish youth has left the Zionist camp; and just as a few years ago the leaders of our organisation thought that the whole centre of gravity of Russian Jewry was concentrated in its conservative-clerical strata, and directed all their forces towards disposing the "Misrachists" favourably and keeping them in our camp, so now too they have formed such a view of the youth and arranged their tactics accordingly.
The prevailing opinion that the youth is turning its back on the Zionist organisation is, to be sure, greatly exaggerated, but it is nevertheless partly true; and the chief cause of the withdrawal of the youth from the general Zionist organisation, which coincides with the moment of the outbreak of the revolution in Russia, lies by no means in the conception of Zionism accepted by the general Zionist organisation, but in this, that the form and content of that organisation simply cannot satisfy the youth. Youth, and above all a youth so restless and nervous as the Jewish, seeks an opportunity of finding an outlet for its seething forces and of putting itself to work. The merit and at the same time the fault of the Jewish youth consists in this, that it is often unclear about its aims and possesses no right measure for the practical application of its abounding strength. When Zionism arose, the youth entered the organisation and sought activity there. But it remained unsatisfied and dispersed: it was seized and swept away by the wave of the revolution. There, above all, it was dazzled by concrete work, and, what is more important still, by organised work, whose power of attraction lies in the consciousness that one does not stand alone, but forms a power. Certainly it would be unjust and false to see in this the sole cause of the absorption of the youth into the various revolutionary parties; there are, rather, other and deeper causes as well. Besides enthusiasm for socialist theory, the chief part is played by the indignation and bitterness, accumulated in men's souls for decades, against the hated régime which forces Russian Jewry down into misery and want.
Happily Zionism holds a great many healthy germs, so that in its irresistible forward movement it breaks for itself the right path, upon which the leaders of the movement ought properly to guide it; and upon this path it will succeed anew in drawing the great masses of the people to it lastingly.
We in Russia now stand evidently upon the threshold of that national "present-day policy" which binds us in the closest manner to the more or less distant future. We speak here, namely, of the creation of a Jewish national party in Russia, which is to inscribe upon its banner the demand for the emancipation of the Jewish people in Russia, and that not only in the sense of civil liberties, but also of national equality of rights. It is clear that in this undoubtedly hard struggle with external opponents, and no less with internal ones, the national self-consciousness of Russian Jewry will increase in strength and development. This struggle will have only this consequence, that all that is unconscious and dimly felt, stirring and moving in the masses of the people, will be transformed into conscious wishes and will pass from the realm of presentiments into that of demands. It is clear, further, that precisely the favourable issue of this struggle will show everyone that a full actual realisation of all our rights, national and civil, is impossible in the Diaspora. Such a "present-day policy," which however is by no means to be confused with the "Ssejm system" (Ssejm — National Assembly) of the proletarian-Zionist parties, is not only not alien to the nature of Zionism, but even forms an integral part of it. And in fact we see that the idea of the creation
