Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 36 · 7 September 1906
8printed page
scan 6 of 20
Facsimile · scan 6 of 20
Scan of p. 8
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 36.

(continued from page 7)

…work gradually become, so to speak, a bugbear. . . . I tell you, whatever progress Zionism may make, if it counts for nothing in Russia, it is worth nothing. And it is precisely there that Zionism might perish, if you will not soon strike out on another road, the direct road to Palestine. But you are afraid of catchwords. Dr. Hantke too is afraid of "Chowewe-Zionism." That is to say: he has been made afraid of it. For years it has been said and written what a terrible thing "Chowewe-Zionism" is, and now, naturally, you are afraid of it. Do you know at all what it means? Chibath Zion — do you know what that means, that you are so afraid of it? And now the consequences: do you know that we should today have 500 wealthy families in Palestine if provision had been made in good time? And do you know how much further on the country would then already be? Do you know what the Russian Jews could have accomplished for Palestine? If we placed ourselves at the head, we could soon have millions together for Palestine. We have done far too little in Palestine, and if we do not begin our work now, it might be too late — for Palestine, but also for Zionism.

Dr. Tschlenow protests against Marmorek's remarks that the Russian gentlemen and the speaker bow before Ussischkin. We always follow our conviction, and will also vote against Ussischkin when his views do not seem right to us.

President Wolffsohn: I learn this moment that Dr. Weizmann, at the evening sitting — which I was prevented from attending by taking part in a meeting of the directors of the A. P. C. — spoke of a passive resistance to practical work in Palestine within the E. A. C. I declare that no such resistance exists at all. On the contrary, we have granted much more than was good, and it is also not correct when it is said that we were found willing only with difficulty. Every truly practical motion concerning work in Palestine has been granted, and without long debate. What we could do, we have done.

Cowen: When I joined the movement, I was of the opinion that it was a political movement; I believed that "Chowewe-Zionism" was dead. We were told that this thing need no longer be reckoned with at all. The gentlemen, however, seem not to have given up their "Chowewe-Zionism." All attempts at small colonisation have failed. If we do something practical, then we must do it well. As regards politics, however, the question that Dr. Weizmann has raised here is a justified one, and I am by no means satisfied with Greenberg's answer. There is a general dissatisfaction that too little is done politically. This debate was, in my opinion, a very useful and good one. In great political questions we must always go hand in hand with the great Jewish corporations.

Ussischkin: I am grateful to Dr. Marmorek for what he has brought forward here. He has said everything that he thought. As regards my personal relations to Zionism, I declare that I was personally apostrophised, that they were never a secret, but on the contrary lie open and clear to view. In our party there are very many who are of the same opinion as I. As regards my election to the Inner A. C., Dr. Marmorek is in error, as has already been pointed out. Recall the mood that prevailed at the VII. Congress, and you will find that it was not you, Dr. Marmorek, but we who triumphed. This was not, however, because I am perhaps a better organiser than Dr. Marmorek, but because the whole mood of the VII. Congress was for the views which I too represented. And such too will be the mood of the VIII. Congress. You may count with certainty on our obtaining our majority again. I desire no conflict, because I hold you to be good Zionists and cannot believe that you are no longer what you were. Therefore I say to you: you must reconcile yourselves to the fact that the general mood in Zionism is now for work in Palestine. If you sit here at the green table and do not look about you out in the world, you will conjure up a great danger. Passing to the reproach that I am against political actions, I call upon my colleagues of the E. A. C. to name me a single fact where I have turned against any political resolution. I have voted against something only once, and that was against the Brussels Conference. The facts have proved me right. I receive letters from America, South Africa, etc., in which my efforts and those of others directed towards direct work in Palestine are praised, and the inactivity in the Inner A. C. is censured. I have never failed on such occasions to point

out that political work is being done in the A. C. and that important things are being prepared. What, then, is the point of the reproach? . . . But I ask you: what have we accomplished in practical matters up to now? Ask Prof. Warburg whether he has received the endowment voted by the Congress. The branch in Beirut was decided upon in November 1905 and opened only in August 1906. Where, then, are the practical labours? At the first sitting of the E. A. C. I said that we must go to Palestine by every road. Zionism without catchwords, without calling it political or Chowewe-Zionism — that is my programme, which I shall always defend. If you propose something really good in the political line, I shall never hinder you and shall always be for it. But when we come with something good, then you too should not set yourselves against us so. Have confidence in us, and we shall certainly have confidence in you. But if you should needlessly seek a conflict, you would have to come off the worse, for in the end those would triumph who wish to create something positive in Palestine, because they rest upon a programme.

Dr. Alexander Marmorek: The word "political" is an inseparable part of our movement. But Herr Ussischkin has never wished to know anything of it. When he stood up for political resolutions, it was done in such a manner that one could read without difficulty that he was not in it with his whole heart. But after all we have not entered into such a marriage with one another that we are bound to follow all the fancies of the other. Not I, but you have picked a quarrel. This night is the consequence of the VII. Congress. You say that you triumphed there, but do you know why? Because we gave way there! But do not believe that we shall give way to you if you demand of us the giving-up of the "political."

Dr. Sapir: When we left home, we were charged to bring back from here something positive for further agitation. But if we return from here without results, we shall meet only with failures. Give us, then, a positive programme for our masses. And this positive programme we expect from your attitude to the question of work in Palestine.

Messrs. Scheinkin, Moser, Dr. Hantke and others also spoke repeatedly.

Close of the sitting at half-past five in the morning.

Friday, 31 August 1906.

The closing sitting began at 1 o'clock midday.

At the Friday sitting the motions brought in on the report of the Palestine Commission were first put to the vote, on which a lengthy debate ensues.

Ussischkin's Motion I is adopted.

Ussischkin's Motion II is withdrawn.

In place of Ussischkin's Motion III the following resolution, which the E. A. C. had passed at its last sitting in May, is confirmed:

It is resolved to purchase, jointly with the Odessa Committee, land to the value of 40 000 francs from the lands of the A. P. C. at Fedsche near Pethach Tikwah or elsewhere, 20 000 francs to be borne by the National Fund and the remaining 20 000 francs by the Odessa Committee. This land is to be used for the settling of Jewish workmen who have immigrated into Palestine. The carrying out of the matter is entrusted to a committee which is to consist of Messrs. Director Levontin, Dr. Kohan-Jaffa and the Palestinian representative of the Odessa Committee.

Ussischkin's Motion IV is adopted in the following modified form:

It is resolved to purchase land in Lydda out of the moneys of the National Fund and to lease it to the former pupils of the Kiriath Sefer (the orphans of Kishineff).

In place of Warburg's motion, which was withdrawn, the following compromise motion of Oskar Marmorek is adopted:

The Annual Conference requests the E. A. C. to examine the question of an Agrarian Fund and to lay proposals concerning it before the next sitting of the Greater A. C.

Further, on the motion of Oskar Marmorek, it is unanimously resolved without debate to erect a tombstone to the late Dr. Kokesch on the anniversary of his death, and to arrange a collection through the "Welt" to meet the cost.

There follows the discussion of the following resolution brought in by Herr Greenberg:

Preparations are to be made as quickly as possible for a committee permanently resident in Palestine to