DIE WELT — 6 — No. 30
Monsieur Narcisse Leven declared:
"We can now affirm the success of the Argentine colonisation, after a long series of difficulties, failures and disappointments. In this country, where the climate is temperate, the soil fertile, and the population not in proportion to the extent of the territory, we have succeeded in settling as colonists, on a territory of 463716 hectares, 1251 families consisting of 9227 persons, not counting a population of agricultural labourers numbering 2195 souls, and in bringing pedlars, small traders and workers of every kind to agricultural pursuits. These improvised husbandmen not only work well, but have also set about their self-government with success. They take part in the direction of the public affairs of the settlement, in the building of the roads, in the regulation of sanitary conditions, of the hospitals, of the co-operative system, of the schools and of public worship; we are striving more and more to give them complete self-government. The economic success of the settlers is most clearly proved by the fact that they have begun to repay the loans which the Association granted for their first establishment. In the year 1905 the colonists paid the total sum of 639000 francs . . ."
Let us briefly examine what is said and supported by figures, and look to see what is not said and not supported. The Ica, then, succeeded in establishing 1251 families in a period of about 15 years; that makes roughly 80 families a year, while the Ica's costs of installation amount annually to about 2000000 francs, so that the establishment of one colonist family comes to about 25000 francs. If, at this unheard-of outlay, these colonists had at least become independent, it would be an unexampled extravagance, but still, it would be something like a result. But the Ica itself admits that the colonists have only begun to pay off their debts to the Ica, and that the Ica is only "striving" to give them self-government (namely, for their own households; the "self-government" of public affairs by over-indebted and wholly dependent colonists is, after all, trifling by comparison). But how stands the vaunted repayment on the part of the colonists? As late as the year 1902, 54.5 per cent of the colonists were wholly in arrears with the yearly instalments, 29.5 per cent had paid less than the first annual quota, 16 per cent had paid off from one to three annual quotas. And even the present figure of repayment represents hardly a third of what the colonists ought properly to pay each year. And withal they have only "begun to repay."
That is the one side of the matter which is not documented in the report. But there is yet another thing that the report withholds from us: the explanation of what the figure of 1251 installed families really signifies. One must know that already in the year 1895 there were no fewer than 1197 colonist families, but that by 1899 their number had fallen again to 779! That is, the Ica did indeed install so and so many families every year, — but in return families already settled were continually leaving the colonies. If to-day 1251 families live in the colonies, one must know that almost twice as many, that is, over 2000, have moved away from the colonies again.
There is a good illustration of Mr. Leven's remarks when we read in an Argentine newspaper written in the Spanish language:
"Colony Max Nordau." It has now become a fact. Forty families, who were until now the slaves of the arbitrary rule of the Ica administration of Moisesville, have left the "field of philanthropy" and acquired lands on favourable terms in the neighbourhood of Baradero. The colony will bear the name of the famous Zionist leader. The total value of the land purchased amounts to 400 000 pesos. In view of the conditions under which the colonists are establishing themselves, with their own capital and under the direction of the able and honourable Mr. Epstein, there is no doubt that the colony will have a rapid and sure development to record. Other colonists of Moisesville, too, are establishing themselves in various districts of Argentina which have been placed at their disposal by the government.
The Minister of Agriculture has made over to 350 Russian-Jewish families, furnished with their own means, the land of the Valdez peninsula in the south of the Republic. Each family will receive 200—250 hectares.
Everything proves the complete fiasco of philanthropic colonisation as the Ica practised it, and the prosperity of every settlement made with its own means and with independent self-government by the colonists. . ."
Now one may certainly not assert that, in these abuses, the Ica is the only guilty party and the colonists the only sufferers. That does not touch the heart of the matter at all. The fault lay in the Ica's system of colonisation, which consisted in placing people, often without previous knowledge of agriculture, in a holding over-richly and over-comfortably equipped, in leaving them dependent on a more or less clumsy administration, and in stifling from the outset all self-reliant activity, and with it the sense of responsibility, in the colonists. With this began demoralisation above and below, a history of constant decay and rebuilding. And this will go on until the germ of the disease is removed: the philanthropic system.
The special report of the Ica on Argentina indicates that it has itself — even if it does not admit it — come to recognise the great mistakes formerly committed. It has now begun — while unfortunately, on the other hand, it has not yet wholly given up the old system of colonisation — to assist independent groups who also install themselves, and moreover to lay weight on the colonists' being familiar with work on the land and with the conditions of the country. That will undoubtedly bring forth better results. The proof of it is that a whole number of colonists have established themselves even without the help of the Ica and are prospering very well.
But the old system, carried on for 15 years at an enormous expenditure of capital, has gone completely bankrupt. Perhaps Monsieur Narcisse Leven knows this as well as we do. In his address, at any rate, he does not betray it. And he has preferred to leave it to others to explain the language of his figures.
We Zionists can learn even more from the study of the Argentine colonisation than from that of the Rothschild colonisation in Palestine. Expert direction, assistance in the choice of land and in the purchase of land for the colonists —, that is the task of the colonisers; their own initiative in installing themselves and in working the holding, independence and responsibility of their own, — that is the only sound foundation for the colonist.
Who creates the pogrom panic? The "Government Messenger," the official organ of the Russian government, surprised the public on 19 July with a revelation about the true causes of the pogrom panic that has prevailed among the Jews since the massacre of Bjelostok. It enumerates particular towns where this panic prevailed, and that usually in connection with impending religious processions. But — so the paper says — it has turned out, "according to the reports of the local administration," that the Jews themselves, especially the Jewish revolutionaries, spread such rumours in order to slander the police (!) The Kherson police report that "the members of the Jewish "Bund" are making preparations for disturbances, and that even the lists of the houses discovered