No. 30 — DIE WELT — 5
POLITICAL REVIEW
The Conference in London
As we reported in our last number, Mr. Oskar Straus, on the occasion of his stay in London, of his own accord took up once more the attempt, inaugurated in its day by the Zionists through the convening of the Brussels Conference, to bring about united action by the Jewish organisations towards a solution of the Jewish problem on a large scale. We may say at once that this renewed attempt has not succeeded either, although, from the fact that only a few personalities had been invited to the conference, and these not as official representatives of their organisations, many points of friction had been removed from the outset. Naturally, however, the persons invited did not hide their programmes in their pockets, and one may therefore say with good right that it was much more than a private conference. Even so, to be sure, only a rump conference. Leading men, among others the London representatives of the Ica, who had been invited to this conference, had not responded to the invitation, and Mr. Stettauer, member of the Russo Jewish Committee, voted against all the resolutions laid before it. There remained, then, apart from Mr. Oskar Straus and Mr. Elkan Adler, really only the Zionists and the Itoists. The contest between the two last could, of course, be clearly foreseen. The Zionists have their programme for the solution of the Jewish question, whose authentic interpretation is given by the last resolutions of the Congress, and they have neither the right nor the slightest occasion to depart from this programme in the least degree. The aim of the Zionists can therefore — so far as the great, the Jewish problem is concerned — lie only in drawing all the active Jewish organisations into co-operation in the interest of Jewry as a whole, at least for that minimum of the Zionist plan for which a certain receptiveness may now be presumed even among some non-Zionists. This minimum apparently lies, in the first place, in the recognition — in view of the distress of the Jews of Europe, from the economic and political standpoint — of the necessity of founding a home in Palestine (whereas the programme of the Zionists, as is self-evident to our adherents, proceeds besides from the positive national, historical and cultural standpoint). The necessity of founding a commonwealth — or, as the resolutions put it, a colony with the possibility of self-government — was recognised by the conference, but nothing more. For now followed the second resolution of the Zionists: this commonwealth is to be founded in Palestine. For this unconditional form the Itoists would not yet decide. Their counter-proposition, "Anywhere, Palestine not excluded," was of no interest to the Zionists. And there the matter rested. Proposition against proposition, — in a word: without result.
The Zionists may therefore content themselves with thanking Mr. Oskar Straus heartily for his efforts and, for the rest, trusting in their own strength and undeterred by all the currents and side-currents of the day, with going on their way.
In concluding this brief consideration, however, it appears necessary, in view of some false interpretations which this London conference has met with in a part of the Jewish press, to reject decisively that fantastic construction which, for example, the organ of Mr. Lucien Wolf, the "Jewish World," believes itself able to put upon it. The "Jewish World" thinks — one does not know how — that it can draw from the resolutions of the conference the conclusion that a rapprochement in programme has taken place between Zionists and Ito, in the sense that whichever of the two, Zionists or Itoists, is first in a position to put forward a practical project of colonisation may count on the support of the other party. So far as the "Jewish World" applies this to the Zionists, the esteemed paper is thoroughly in error, and we do not hesitate to brand it quite unambiguously as such. For here there is no artificial twisting of words. The programme of the Zionists is and remains: Palestine and its neighbouring lands. Alternatives do not come into consideration.
There is therefore no question of a "rapprochement" in programme. As we have said, we have no occasion for one.
Of the Ica
The Jewish public has ceased to grow excited about the Ica. Only a few years ago it was the object of the most violent attacks on every occasion when a serious treatment of the Jewish question was under discussion. In proletarian circles above all, people were indignant at this board of administration, which, instead of making the inheritance bequeathed to the Jewish people serviceable to it, squandered or withheld it according to the good pleasure of gentlemen remote from the people and infallibly authoritative. Much has been written, and still more spoken, against the Ica; demands were made, threats were uttered from meetings of proletarians, — it died away without effect. One remembers, too, Zangwill's campaign against the Ica, conducted a few years ago with much temperament and mostly with good arguments. Zangwill has fallen silent. He has abandoned the feud. And elsewhere, too, it has grown quiet. . . Most have reconciled themselves to the thought that the Hirsch inheritance — as a means to be employed by the people for the people — must be given up for lost. The unhappy statutes place all rights in the hands of a few trustees, who are in fact responsible only to themselves, and who are from the outset persons that, standing wholly aloof from the life of the Jewish people, and themselves in the most secure and comfortable positions, view the whole Jewish problem through the spectacles of the assimilationist Jewish magnates of Western Europe. And instead of first taking up a laborious and doubtful struggle against these persons and their principle, most think it more practical to awaken the elemental, healthy forces of the people to act for themselves, — forces against which even such a capital of millions is a vanishingly small factor. To be sure, if made serviceable to the productive forces of the people, the Hirsch fortune could become a source of undreamt-of blessing. . .
But — why repeat what has often been said? Everything in the end depends on the good will of the trustees. Will they perhaps, by a peaceful development of their own, rise to other and better principles, which the struggle from without could not wrest from them?
So far there is unfortunately not too much hope of this. The last general meeting proves it, at which seven gentlemen were present, while four gentlemen excused their absence on this occasion, which recurs but once a year. The terrible situation in Russia gave no occasion whatever for prolonging the debates. Address of the President. — New elections (read: re-elections). — Thanks to the President. — Close of the meeting. All of it business that — as the technical phrase goes — is concluded within itself.
It would be very interesting for us to go more closely into the report of the "Ica" on its activities, — but for to-day we will impose restraint upon ourselves and take only a sample. We pick out the chapter on colonisation in Argentina.
2
