Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 29 · 20 July 1906
14printed page
scan 12 of 20

Page 14. — "Die Welt" — No. 29.

(continued from page 13)

...correct plan, of preparing the children as early as possible for their probable or desirable new home, seemed to me not yet sufficiently carried out here. In that case I regretted every hour of Roumanian instruction, every day in Roumanian surroundings. Once it had been recognized that there was no future for the children in Roumania, it would surely have been more to the purpose to bring them up at once in the land of their future, which, to be sure, in that case had not yet been fixed.

For this reason nothing seems to me to lie nearer to hand for a movement such as ours than to provide, even in ordinary times, for the placing (in Palestine, of course) of as many orphans of the emigration countries as possible. It goes without saying that the family circumstances of each individual case will have to be carefully considered. For a "pogrom orphan" who can find a second home with well-to-do near relatives in Russia there is less occasion for removal to Palestine than for an orphan child of ordinary times who, for want of other care, falls as a burden upon the community. It is also to be considered that the care of orphans in the great cities of Europe costs much more than in Palestine.

Even if, then, the occasion for this discussion has arisen out of the present catastrophe, there is no reason whatever to confine the matter itself to the present occasion! I will try to show a way by which, on the basis of the present relief action, a highly important work of permanent duration may be founded.

In my opinion it is not a question of helping a small number as amply as possible, but of offering to as large a number as possible, besides a suitable education, the barest necessities. I am therefore not thinking of a brilliant "installation." A child who on leaving school could call a few thousand francs his own would in this respect be incomparably better placed than the vast majority of the others. It must suffice us to give the children now in question an education excellently suited to the purpose. Beyond that, however, it is not necessary to reserve for them more than a few hundred francs out of the fund now destined for their education. There are too many pogrom orphans and too little money for us to be permitted to proceed otherwise. Nevertheless it will be shown in what follows that the future of these children too can be secured by another way.

I would therefore propose to provide for fifty children with the moneys available. For the sake of greater economy it is advisable to take in children of about the same age — say between 11 1/2 and 12 1/2 years — for whom on the average three years' instruction (between 2 1/2 and 3 1/2 years) is to be provided. According to the experience with the Kishineff children, this period has been fully and even more than sufficient. The elder pupils were only two years in the school, and although they were much older than is assumed above for the present case — although, that is, they could much more readily be "re-educated" — the two years sufficed, in spite of all the difficulties under which the school had to work at first, to Hebraize and Palestinize them completely. Those now coming would, in connection with Belkind's school, also have it much easier in so far as they would come into a so to speak ready-made "Hebrew Palestine milieu," which in the first case had still to be created!

Through the equality of age a simplification of the curriculum, and through the slight differences of age a division of the leaving date into three roughly equal groups, could be

brought about. The "choice" among the orphans available is unhappily large enough to find only too many applicants, even with a far greater restriction.

To keep fifty children in school for three years, in association with the existing Belkind institution, costs 75,000 francs (50 x 3 x 500 francs yearly). The remaining 25,000 francs gives a grant towards installation of 500 francs a head. From the interest on the sum, which is not, after all, to be spent all at once, the necessary buildings can be obtained, and possibly also an increase in the installation grant. In the way of buildings, a few dormitories attached to an existing school establishment will suffice, which for 50 children will require no greater building costs than can be made to come out of the interest. For those who may be afraid even of this — that something permanent might be created out of the interest of this relief sum — a way will be shown further on.

Let us suppose, then, that the children have been educated for three years with as good success as the Kishineff orphans. What would then have to happen? I think that the National Fund, which has at its disposal the Jewish land near Lydda, should acquire the purchasable lands in the neighbourhood and thereby make it possible for the national school — or the "national orphanage" — to become the centre of a National Fund colony. The school would then retain control over the discharged pupils, and indeed the further connection between these and the institution is indispensable. I had at first thought that after completing the school the pupils should first take work somewhere, since at 15 they are after all not yet independent enough. But Herr Belkind says very rightly that in Palestine to-day neither sufficient nor sufficiently lasting work is to be found, and that under present conditions there is by no means everywhere in the colonies a guarantee that the young people will continue to be influenced in the spirit of the institution. Indeed, it might happen that in some colonies they would be laughed at for their Hebrew, and that they would come into colonies, or among colonists, where the average contentment of common humanity wears an anti-Palestinian — indeed sometimes even a pro-Ugandist — fool's cap.

If the spirit of the school is to remain effective, there is only the one means: gradual settlement beside the school, under the control, at least at first, of capable farmers, who would have to give the agricultural instruction in the school and to administer the school land.

Now I must again meet from the very outset the inevitable objection of the National Fund zealots, who scent nothing but dangers everywhere for "this sacred institution"! But I hold that if it is not even to be expected that the pogrom orphans, brought up as Jewish and Palestinian patriots par excellence, will respect the rights of the National Fund and their duties towards the property of the people, then it is to be expected of no one, and one should in consistency draw two thick strokes, one under the National Fund and one under Zionism — and close the accounts.

The National Fund does not give, — it leases. The discharged pupils would each be allotted some 100 to 150 dunams of land. For every 4 or 5 a little house would at first be fitted up, which after 2 to 3 years is to be inhabited by only 2 or 3 of the young people. The training of the young people enables them to build their little houses themselves, or at least, by supplying the dressed stones, (the material is found

View of Lydda View of Lydda