No. 28. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
HERZL AND PARTY DISCIPLINE
Recollections by ALEXANDER MARMOREK
Our leader made great demands upon his faithful followers. It is true that seldom have such strong individualities attached themselves to the creator of a new movement as here. Men who otherwise knew well enough how to go their own way rather stubbornly, and who knew how to defend their personal views at all times and against all comers, became his "following." They became so for love of the idea and of the man. The two made a rarely beautiful blend. A Jewish statesman! None of them had known such a thing, for even the Englishmen among us had had no relations with Beaconsfield. A Jewish and at the same time a thoroughly modern leader of the people, gifted with a rare personal charm; and besides, an acknowledged writer of importance, who knew how to wield the pen as deftly and elegantly as the spoken word, which he handled as keenly as a Damascus blade. All in all, an uncommon human being and every inch a man.
The outsiders, who regarded with some envy the bonds of friendship among his derisively mocked "Mamelukes," did not understand this relation, or misunderstood it. Nor did they suspect that Herzl's most faithful followers formed the sharpest — and also the only influential — opposition in the movement, the counterweight to his heaven-storming designs, the brake upon this ever-moving mechanism. They were, moreover, a disciplined troop, but they also taught the leader party discipline. To all of them the movement counted for more than the individual, more even than the friend and the admired leader. To it one had to make sacrifices, all of us without exception, he too. That was the axiom which every man acknowledged. How often Herzl said to me, when we spoke of the successes of other German writers: What great and important things might I not have created as a man of the pen, had I not become a Zionist! Since he made this sacrifice, for him an immense one, it was only natural to him to demand the like of others as well, and at times a sacrifice of conviction and of vanity too — so long as it was absolutely necessary for the prosperity of the whole. He was right: a historically great work can only be brought about and can only triumph if all its adherents, for its sake, do the hardest thing of all: put their self-love aside. — That is why some men, otherwise good Jews and even enthusiastic Zionists, stepped aside when they felt that the movement demanded even this of them.
A small recollection from that great, beautiful and, alas, vanished time, of how he too was the good soldier who knew how to bow, may be mentioned today.
It was before one of the first Congresses. I arrived in Basle late in the evening from Paris, and heard at the hotel, where I found my brothers Oskar and the now, alas, mourned Isidor, together with the other friends, that Herzl, who had likewise arrived from Vienna the same day, was already asleep. Among other things I was told that he had finished the opening speech of the Congress and had read it to some friends even before the session of the Actions Committee, and also that a discussion for and against had already arisen over it. I went to Herzl to greet him. "We shall discuss all the particulars tomorrow," I said to him, "and then I shall also hear the speech, which is said not to be good." The remark angered him, and he replied with a bitter smile: "Did you wake me to tell me that?"
"Yes, indeed. And to wish you good night."
Next morning, session of the Actions Committee.
Herzl reads his opening speech, in which a number of points did not satisfy us — not even in style, when we considered that it was intended for the widest public. When he had read the manuscript to the end, Herzl further defended his position that as leader he had the right to deliver the speech in his own fashion, and was subject to no control in this respect.
I rose and first contested his thesis of the leader's irresponsibility, spoke of the impossibility of common work unless he too knew how to bow to the view of the majority, and then began the criticism of the speech, which I conducted without mercy. The vote proved me right. And the speech was delivered in another form than he had originally conceived it. But after the solemn opening session he said to me shortly: And people assert that I am an autocrat, and yet I, a German writer, have let you smash my fine speech to pieces! —
Theodor Herzl at the age of 6.
2