"Die Welt" — Page 18 — No. 25
(continued from page 17)
…modern epistemology the law of causality has been called into question even in the domain of natural science. And I need only point to Stammler, who in this respect has subjected the materialist philosophy of history to a sharp criticism.
The ideologists of "political" Zionism now wish to transfer the whole train of thought of Marxism to Zionism as well. But is the transfer even permissible? Are the fields of phenomena, then, identical?
Say what one will, Zionism has so far not let itself be brought into a strict scientific system. One can ground Zionism either on the distress of the Jews and on antisemitism — and that is unscientific, because, first, one infers from the present to a future that may be of a different kind, and secondly, because one reckons with motives of will. Or else Zionism must be grounded "psychologically" — and then the grounding is likewise unscientific, because the chief levers of the movement are imponderables. What, then, are the words to mean: "The tendency of development of the Jewish Question?" Whence do we know this tendency? We will it, we create it, but of an objective tendency of development we know nothing whatever.
It is equally unclear how one can arrive at the construction of the theory of the "unconditionally necessary success" of Zionism, which must come about without our doing anything. Why must it? What inner causality, supposing such a thing, will force world politics in this direction that we desire? And who guarantees us that at the "suitable moment" other, stronger political factors will not take possession of Palestine? Our politicians say that this is out of the question by reason of the international combinations; they assert that it is precisely by reason of this combination that we must attain our goal. Possibly — but where is the inner necessity of these combinations? Many a thing has been combined before now that afterwards vanished into thin air.
It would not be difficult to pursue the ideology of the "political" Zionists — at least as it is set forth in Mr. E.'s article — theoretically to the point of its self-negation. I believe the theoreticians of "political" Zionism ought to look about for another theory, one corresponding to the nature of Zionism and above all fruitful. And then they will probably stand in our ranks. Cor.
CORRESPONDENCE
With reference to the article "Present and Future" by Dr. Simon Bernfeld, which appeared in the number of the 1st June of this year, we receive the following remarks from Rzeszow:
Dear Sir,
The honoured author of the article "Present and Future" draws into the circle of his reflections the conditions as they have taken shape in Austria-Hungary, and especially in Galicia, since the Emancipation, and from them draws the scarcely encouraging conclusions as to the further development of affairs in Russia in the event of a turn of conditions there favourable to our people. In so doing he starts from a wholly false premise — and must therefore also arrive at false conclusions. The assertion that in Galicia smaller sections, namely the rich and educated Jews, detached themselves from the mass, and that the mass was thereby robbed of its leadership — rests upon an optical illusion, upon a misreading of the springs of human action, and upon an ignorance of the relevant conditions in particular. Never was the broad mass of the people in Galicia robbed of its leaders — the educated circles here were never so heartless and soulless as to "detach themselves" from the people and leave it leaderless to itself. It would also mean despairing of the genius of our people, were one to assume with the author that our educated circles had the inclination, having gained culture and political equality, to shake off their nationality and to go under among the alien nations.
It is positively a physiological axiom that the strongest activity of the individual lies in working for the common weal; it is therefore obvious that the stronger natures arising within our people, too, if only in order in some measure to "live themselves out," were bound to look about for a corresponding field of activity, and in the existing state of affairs could find it only in work for their own people. Nor have we lacked leading spirits to whom the spiritual and material elevation of the Jewish people was a sacred cause, to which they sacrificed all their longing and striving. But the intoxication of assimilation, which seized the whole of Jewish society in the second half of the past century, brought it about
that they saw the ideal worth striving for on behalf of the Jewish people in its transformation into a complementary part, belonging to the Mosaic confession, of the Polish nation, and sacrificed their life's work to this end. In their eyes it was eminently Jewish and at the same time "patriotic" work, which, under the notions and views then prevailing, was approved by educated Jewish and Polish circles alike and held up as a model worthy of imitation to the young and to the aspiring classes. To this current the society "Agudas Achim" in Lemberg owed its origin, as did the whole propaganda for purposes of Polonisation carried on in speech and in writing by the educated circles. The confusion of ideas caused by the catchword "assimilation" — psychologically not altogether incomprehensible — and the lack of a national consciousness of their own led them optima fide to enter upon the road which must logically lead to the dissolution of Judaism — and made of the paradox of a "Polish people of the Mosaic confession" a truth of necessity for them.
Only the upheaval of ideas called forth by the Jewish renaissance movement, and the consequent revaluation of all the values of assimilation, the awakened national consciousness of the Jewish masses, have shown the educated circles too the direction they must take in order not to come into contradiction with the feeling of the people.
We in Austria especially have already made the observation among the other peoples that the upper strata, laying claim to leadership, everywhere allow themselves to be carried along by a mighty popular current, so as not to be wholly uprooted and lose the ground beneath their feet — or else the people brings new individualities to the surface, who take over the leadership of the broad masses in place of the lukewarm elements, lacking vitality and the capacity to adapt. Thus there suddenly arose for the Bohemian people, reawakened about the middle of the past century, its high nobility and its educated middle class glowing with the national spirit — the same is happening before our eyes in the midst of the Ruthenian people in Galicia. Beginnings of such a develop-
