DIE WELT
COLOGNE ON THE RHINE, UBIERRING 23 — APPEARS EVERY FRIDAY
CENTRAL ORGAN OF THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT
Xth YEAR. COLOGNE, 15th June 1906 כ"ב סיון א"תתלו לחורבן No. 24.
AFTERWORD TO THE TENTH DELEGATES' CONFERENCE OF THE GERMAN ZIONISTS
It is strange that since Moses Hess no theorist has arisen for Zionism in Germany. Strange, because the very great example that Hess offered might well have invited an extension and deepening of his system; strange also because the German Zionists live in a land where theory stands at the beginning of things, and where the Jews are wont to be strongly influenced by the peoples surrounding them. It would lead us too far were we to inquire why in Germany — with the exception, perhaps, of a few Palestine specialists — there is a want of theorists. The fact is that the most important watchwords of Zionism are carried into Germany, not issued from Germany. Ever since the German Zionists, after a brief resistance on the part of the Chowewe Zionism which at first prevailed, and especially in Berlin — an interesting historical reminiscence, by the way — joined the political Zionism inaugurated by Theodor Herzl, the "jurare in verba magistri" was not merely cultivated among them as a party virtue, but held good, so to speak, as doctrine. For years the German Zionists were literal-minded believers in the abstract political-diplomatic Zionism as it was set down in Herzl's "Judenstaat." That was their theory, and they held fast to it, untroubled that Zionist life and Zionist men in other lands had gradually carried new problems, new disputes, new theories into Zionism. In practice, however, their organisation developed into the most disciplined element. It did not occur to them to cavil at the decisions of the Congress, to criticise them, or in any way to make a Fronde. For that reason their Delegates' Conferences, too, were right down to the most recent time (until 1904), in their whole character, "order" conferences, which occupied themselves with the best possible shaping of the conditions of organisation and propaganda and were burdened by no inner — or, to keep to the word, theoretical — questions whatever. Criticism, to be sure, had here and there already found a voice in Germany.
Questions of the formation of factions had arisen; the cultural problem was raised by a small community; protests against a one-sidedly diplomatic treatment of the Zionist question, against a method of agitation that made strong use of the philanthropic motive, against a too forced display of German citizenship and German culture and a thrusting-back of the purely national, sought ever more loudly and energetically to make themselves heard. But the German organisation warded off all influences disturbing its unity of thought. One may now call it short-sightedness, injustice, dogmatic conservatism; one may trace many of the harms of to-day back to the deaf ears of yesterday — in any case it must be stated that until about three years ago the strength of the German Zionist organisation lay in the solidarity with which it stifled every criticism in the bud — and the criticism of that time seems to us to-day infinitely tame — and pressed down the minorities, inconsiderable in number. The critical ones were regarded, were also called "grumblers," "ideologists"; more was said and done still — but that is of secondary importance to-day.
For since then everything has changed, and perhaps no one to-day will regret many a former sin against the right of free criticism as the vital principle of a movement more than those who once, in the best of faith, made themselves guilty of these sins.
* * *
Since the East Africa plan arose, German Zionism, once so dogmatic and immovable, has been filled with "criticism" and — if one will — with theory, whirling up and down. And it is strange enough that precisely the most steadfast "anti-critics" of former days stop at nothing, hold back no ultimate conclusions, even when the foundations of the Zionist edifice of thought begin to tremble...
When the East Africa project stood before the Sixth Congress, by far the majority of the German delegates assented to the dispatch of the Commission.