Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 23 · 8 June 1906
4printed page
scan 4 of 24

4 — "Die Welt" — No. 23

(continued from page 3)

...ded, that in the only political Jewish union, that for "full rights", Zionist influence was able to maintain itself by a majority — these are surely not proofs of the Zangwillian assertion. Zionism in Russia, it is true, may have lost perhaps 2000 adherents of late, but only to see them soon turn up elsewhere, — namely in Palestine. (Lively applause.) The speaker believes he ought further to emphasise in particular the good development of Austrian Zionism, which he knows from long personal experience and which, under the new leadership, has of late received a considerable increase in impetus, organising capacity and importance in internal politics. On the other hand he has the impression that in Germany Zionism, although, thanks to the excellently good organisation, it has perhaps made small progress, nevertheless contains no strong element driving it forward; what, in his opinion, is the cause of this he will explain at the close.

The speaker then dwells at length on the inner, programmatic development of Zionism. Briefly summarised, he declares: the catastrophes, the penetration of Zionism into young and proletarian circles, and the competition of other Jewish currents have brought the social and economic element into the foreground. Since at the same time the extension of the Zionist land programme to the countries neighbouring Palestine has taken place, due account has thereby been taken of the predominant principle. The national-cultural element, into which the speaker does not intend on this occasion to enter at length, has unfortunately, by contrast, receded in more than one respect and has of late come to expression only in smaller kindred currents, directed, however, solely towards the Golus lands, which culminate in the demands for Jewish cultural autonomies, for example in Austria and Russia. The reporter would by no means overestimate the extent and content of the attainable cultural possibilities in the Golus lands, sympathetic as they are to him; just as little can he associate himself with the view that the political autonomies demanded will, in a material respect, satisfy the too highly strung expectations. In both cases the moral values are for the nation the greater chance of gain as against the material ones, and it is from these moral points of view, from the strengthening of national consciousness to be expected, that the endeavours for full rights are above all to be welcomed. The speaker finally brings out a particular characteristic of present-day Zionism: the heightened personal connection of many Zionists with Palestine, and devotes warm words to the Palestine pioneers, the workers and entrepreneurs who have of late gone to Palestine. He wishes, however, that arrangements be made which will come to the aid, with advice and information, especially of private initiative that wishes to employ capital in Palestine....

In conclusion the reporter turns to the special Zionist conditions of Germany. The German Zionists, he says, have a hard position in their agitation. The national uniformity of Germany, as against the national multiformity of, say, Russia and Austria, makes the bringing forward of the national-Jewish element more difficult. Economically the German Jews are for the most part satisfactorily placed, and there is therefore lacking the strong impulse which in other countries springs from the oppressed, specifically Jewish, economic situation. Culturally the German Jews are estranged from national Jewry, its language, literature, etc., and the overwhelming German culture holds them captive. All attempts made from the Zionist side to work against this can have only a relative success, and this mostly only in respect of the younger generation. These are the reasons which ought above all to induce the German Zionists to seek and to create for themselves a special sphere of work in Zionism, which in the speaker's opinion (apart from the political) lies in the field of the financial strengthening of the movement and of the building up of the organisation on the economic side. The contributions of the German Zionists to the funds of the movement do not yet correspond to the actual possibilities. Moreover they differ, for example, from the Eastern Zionists by the complete absence of any private initiative in Palestine, for which, after all, by their means they would be extraordinarily well fitted. The objection which some make to this, that they regard Zionism precisely as a merely political movement, is not in place. For what a man as an individual will give to Palestine, or what he will personally risk, depends solely on himself alone and is no risk for the movement, the wish to spare which from experiments might at most still pass as a standpoint. The speaker closes with an appeal to the German Zionists to turn resolutely to the field of activity he has recommended, and with the summarising statement that the general shaping of the situation of Zionism since the last Congress gives occasion for many good hopes. (Lively applause.)

The reports are followed immediately by the

Discussion:

Dr. Jeremias, Posen, declares it a good right, indeed a duty, to take up a position at the Delegates' Day towards the activity of the A. C. He criticises above all that resolutions have been passed which commit the Zionist movement to land purchase and colonisation. The improvement in the political prospects of Zionism assumed by Herr Feiwel is an illusion; the communications of Vambéry set this in a clear light. All the less reason has one to abandon the Herzlian principles, all the less ought one to further the cause of the Palestine pioneers, since one can offer them no security whatever for life and property. That is the business of the Palestine societies. Our task is not practical Palestine work at any price and without any legal basis; we are not in the first place a land movement but a national movement. Therefore we must still be mindful of the extension of the movement as well as of its intensity. Our criticism is directed not against the achievements of Zionism, but against these political achievements being taken from us by the ruling majority. (Applause on the right).

Dr. Israel Auerbach, Berlin, first rejects various pro-Ito remarks of Dr. Jeremias, and states that the Ito in fact neither represents a public opinion of Jewry, which it usurps for itself in its voices in the press and on the platform, nor reveals in its actual manifestations of life the importance claimed for it. The speaker then criticises the work of the Zionist party executive, which in his opinion has at times intervened too late in the public Jewish affairs that presented themselves. In the action for the Russian Jews, for example, the A. C. appeared belatedly. If the Zionist movement has nevertheless made progress in the last year, favourable external circumstances have in many cases been the cause rather than positive work from the centre. The speaker points to the interesting fact that the successes lie precisely in those countries where the democratic currents have advanced, especially in Russia, Austria and England. This progress would have been considerably greater if the party executive had displayed more initiative in a democratic direction and less consideration and timidity towards the ruling powers. Above all, a change of party tactics in this direction is necessary in Germany. We must agitate more in socially lower circles, and point out to the German Jews their own unworthy position as Jews in Germany. The real personal sense of independence of the German Jews must be more awakened, and the desire for greater personal and national freedom thereby aroused. Thus Zionism will take hold in new and larger circles of the German Jews, and will be thoroughly personal and national, not philanthropic. (Lively applause on the left.)

Dr. Citron, Berlin (who was the first among the German Zionists to express his sympathy for the "Ito"), takes from the outset the standpoint that Itoism has nothing to do with German Zionism; there exists no Ito in Germany. He attaches a special significance to the 10th Delegates' Day particularly because it is the first Delegates' Day after the 7th Congress, which is said to have brought about a complete change in the path of Zionist work. The 7th Congress, he says, really produced no positive resolutions, but only rejected valuable projects. He characterises the situation after the 7th Congress as the bringing out of the idea of petty colonisation. There is surely no purpose in "throwing" as many Jews as possible "into" Palestine and buying up as much land as possible there; rather, Zionism strives for a home for the Jewish people on a basis of national freedom. This buying of land and throwing in appears to him a wrong way, but the old Herzlian way, too, is no longer the right one today. It was right so long as the leader of genius stood at the head and there was behind him a united, faithful following. Through his death, however, the inner situation has been shattered and the way has become impassable.

The present situation of Zionism permits no activity whatever. Either we should have to declare Zionism bankrupt (laughter), which we do not wish to do, chiefly for reasons of sentiment. But the hope which we cherished has come to nothing. So what could we do? Only preserve our organisation and strengthen ourselves financially. We must explore the land and educate the people for this task. For if we were to receive the land today, we should be, since the genius of a Herzl does not stand at the head, and