Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 22 · 1 June 1906
10printed page
scan 6 of 18
Facsimile · scan 6 of 18
Scan of p. 10
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 10 — "Die Welt" — No. 22

(continued from page 9)

…the naturalisation of the Jews the dissolution of Judaism would follow.

Once the public educational institutions in Russia are thrown open to the Jews, there will grow up for us in twenty years a wholly denationalised youth, which will no longer think and feel as Jews, but as Russians. Jewish national life will thereby be cut off. Certainly the great, poorer mass will not be able to follow; it will remain behind in the Ghetto, even when this shall have been abolished by law. Then conditions will simply develop in Russia such as we cannot sufficiently deplore in Galicia. The mass will remain national, but, as the rich and intelligent Jews detach themselves from it, it will then be far worse off than now.

That is the natural development of things, if we close our eyes to the danger or let ourselves be put off with cheap consolations. For me there is no doubt that the political liberation of the Russian Jews will not come about in the near future, and it will probably never be complete. But the mere prospect of civil rights, and the more so if even a tiny portion should be granted them, will already suffice to destroy the feeling of solidarity among them and to ruin Jewish national life. The upper strata will assimilate within a generation and seek the satisfaction of their ambition elsewhere. From the mass, further, the organised proletarians will detach themselves, whose hatred of the Jewish bourgeois is boundless. There will remain the poorer and religiously minded strata, in which national feelings certainly exist; but poor and ignorant people cannot furnish the material for a healthy national movement.

I should not wish my gloomy prophecy to be fulfilled. Rather do I wish and hope that the Zionists will become conscious of the danger of the moment and direct their gaze to the future. Let them leave the dance round the political calf to others and devote their forces exclusively to national preservation. What we may now lose we shall never recover. Russian Jewry has hitherto formed our reserves in the national respect. Let us be mindful of sparing and preserving them.


CORRESPONDENCE

On the Tactics of the Zionist Party

Dr. Jakob Thon (Berlin) writes to us:

Jewry finds itself at present in one of the most important historic moments through which it has ever passed. The fate of Zionism, too, naturally depends on the shaping of this moment. With universal expectant suspense we follow events. What turn they will take is hardly quite clear to anyone. The contradictory prophecies, born of hopes and fears, are least of all built upon an unimpeachable judgment of all the factors. In reality it is a great perplexity that we feel in face of the present situation. The fear of assimilation as the necessary consequence of emancipation appears to be wholly groundless. It is beyond doubt that in the states of many nationalities, Russia and Austria, in which the rights of the several peoples will come into force, the Jews, as an alien element, will have to hold themselves more apart than hitherto, when tacit assimilation prevailed. Assimilation as a programme is now, in view of the uniformly homogeneous Jewish mass in Russia and Galicia and of the already strongly developed national consciousness, a positively insane undertaking. The leaders of the former assimilationist generation, who have suddenly grown energetic again, are surely exerting their strength for the last time. From that side no danger threatens. Rather may a positive strengthening of the Jewish nation be expected from the coming development. Whether this development, too, leads to our Palestino-Zionist programme cannot be answered so offhand.

How natural was the transformation that has taken place in the Zionist party in the last two years is now quite plainly revealed. Never has so strong an urge towards Palestine manifested itself among the Zionists as now. It seems as if the longing of the Jewish people for Zion would thus prove itself a truth. How, then, will this Palestino-petal force be influenced by the nationally developed life of the main body of the Jewish mass in its present places of residence? Will national feeling increase in its development to such a degree that, for complete national satisfaction, we shall feel the want of a land of our own all the more intensely? Or will it soon appear that only a very small part of the national aspirations can find satisfaction in the Diaspora at all, and thus Jewish home-sickness will soon grow only stronger? These possibilities seem to lie near at hand. But perhaps it will also be the reverse: the newly created possibilities will suffice for living out national life to the full, and since no economic upswing is to be expected from the new shaping of things and from freedom either, the longing for another home will be weakened! Who knows?

Nevertheless the final working-out, the decision of this question, lies a good way off. For the near future both factors must still be reckoned with equally: the ardent wish of a large part of the Jewish people to take firm root in Palestine as soon as possible, and the life of the Jewish mass developing in national forms. Perhaps these are the conditions necessary for the realisation of Achad-Haam's ideal, the "spiritual centre" in Palestine: in Palestine the "pioneers," drawn from the strongest and best among us — and in the Diaspora the proper sounding-board.

To be sure, events are far too overwhelming for us to be able to master them. Yet it surely behoves our party leadership now to be equal to the significance of the moment, to stand at the height of its tasks. It must rightly trace out the tendency of development and turn it to account. The Zionist party, the strongest in Jewry and the only one with a positive programme for Jewry, must not permit a new epoch to begin for our people without its decisive co-operation.

This is a task of the tactics of our party leadership. Tactics must be well distinguished from propaganda. The difference is not merely a nominal one, but touches the substance. The right tactics can proceed only from the centralised party leadership. It must remain in the most intimate connection with the whole life of the party. It must be directed from the point from which the whole terrain is surveyed. While the necessary measure of autonomy for the several national organisations is fully maintained, yet in moments so momentous as the present, action must not be taken in Russia and Austria without agreement with the party as a whole, without the participation of the central leadership. The right tactics of the party are its policy, internal and external. They mean the right use of every opportunity offered for strengthening our position, for attaining our goal. Towards