10 — "Die Welt" — No. 20
(continued from page 9)
...munity to help build. And even should the Duma be driven asunder, and should the blind bureaucracy, in defiance of the country and the age, restore its devastating activity for a while, we know — the Russian Empire has spoken, the Russian Jews are pariahs no longer. — We can look into the future with a certain confidence, and we shall not let our view of our task be clouded by certain apprehensions such as, for example, Dr. S. Bernfeld has expressed in our paper. Dr. Bernfeld fears that Judaism will perish of the freedom of the Jews. We do not believe it. A people that exists only because it suffers does not deserve to exist. It is to despair of the whole people to ascribe to it this monstrous lust for assimilation. A social group cannot perish. One must bear in mind — for a collective being the proposition does not hold: Cogito — ergo sum, or, as some among us think in regard to the Jewish people: I suffer — therefore I am — but rather "sum, ergo sum." Either the Jewish people has a content of life, and then it will live and also fulfil its historic task, or it has none, and then it is dead, then it must perish. We believe in the former.
The Expulsion Debate in the Prussian Landtag
(Extract from the stenographic record)
There is read the interpellation of the two Liberal parties: "Are the measures ordered known to the Royal Government, and what does it intend to do to oppose an arbitrary exercise of the power of expulsion attended by hardships and inequities?" Deputy Träger speaks in support of the interpellation, whereupon the Minister of the Interior, v. Bethmann-Hollweg, takes the floor: "I beg leave to keep strictly to the interpellation. In the course of the Russian disturbances some 3000 Russians, apart from persons passing through, have come into the Berlin police district, belonging for the most part to the lower and impecunious classes and for the greatest percentage Israelites. I stress this not out of any confessional considerations, but because I believe that he who shuts his eyes to the part which the Jews play, actively or passively, in the Russian revolution is to be counted among the blind. (Quite right.) The motive for the emigration is to be sought partly in the persecutions to which the strangers were exposed in their homeland; in part, participation in the revolutionary machinations may have been a contributing cause of the emigration. (Assent on the right.) Now the Government is of the unanimous opinion that the influx of great masses of foreigners, insecure in their existence, partly without papers, or in some way entangled in the revolutionary machinations of the neighbouring empire, is to be tolerated neither economically nor politically. (Lively assent on the right.) From this general standpoint, which I hope will find the assent of the majority of this House, I have ordered that persons without a secure economic existence, without papers, or politically suspect, be expelled forthwith. (Applause on the right.) Further, those persons in whom these conditions are likewise present, but in whom they have not come out so sharply, and whose permanent stay among us is not admissible on account of the state interests mentioned, are to be informed that they cannot count on a permanent stay here and should therefore look about for another place of residence, so that it may not later have to take the harsher measure of expulsion. The Jewish Relief Committee stands at our side with counsel and deed, and I have given orders that this relief action is to be supported by the police. All those are to be spared from every measure in whose case none of the objective or subjective grounds mentioned stands in the way of a longer stay. Now Deputy Träger has cited numerous individual cases in which manifestly unjust expulsions are said to have been decreed or carried out. As regards first the case of Police Commissary Schöne, it is in fact untrue, according to the inquiries I at once instituted, that the Russian merchant concerned was to be put into a predicament by the threat of expulsion in order to incline him to the crime of treason. That was asserted in those words in the Reichstag. I reject this insinuation as untrue in fact. (Applause on the right.) The Russian merchant has received the notification that he could not count on a permanent permission to remain here, and that he should therefore look about for another place of residence. He was not expelled forthwith. In this, of course, no ulterior purpose prevailed; he received the notification solely for the same purpose as all other persons in the same case. The Russian merchant thereupon tried to obtain permission to stay permanently among us, and for this purpose turned to a private person who has never performed services for the police. The Russian merchant has set out on a long-planned business journey to Russia and has not yet been able to be examined on the matter. This third person, it seems, induced the Russian merchant, in order to obtain permission for a longer stay, to make on his part an offer of certain services to Police Commissary Schöne. (Hear, hear!) He was in no way led into such an offer by Police Commissary Schöne. (Hear, hear!) A short time afterwards the Russian merchant changed his mind, and he commissioned a lawyer to pursue his application for a longer stay here by the regular course of complaint. Thereupon the affair found its way into the parliamentary publicity of the Reichstag. In so far and inasmuch as officials subordinate to me have erred, I shall see to the necessary remedy. As regards the other cases, I must to my regret admit that in a number of the cases mentioned the procedure has not corresponded to my intentions. They concern in many instances persons who were politically and economically quite unexceptionable, some of whom had come long before the beginning of the Russian disturbances, and whose stay gave no occasion for any misgiving. In all such cases that have come to my cognisance I have withdrawn the expulsion. I regret that these mistakes have occurred, but I beg you to consider that the cases are not after all so numerous as they may perhaps appear, because they have been repeated once in the Reichstag, ten times in the press and for the eleventh time here. (Great merriment on the right.) Oversights occur here as in all human affairs. Deputy Träger has used precisely these individual cases, with in part comic embellishments, cases in which I must admit that the procedure ran contrary to intentions, as proof that the whole measure is wrong. That I cannot consider admissible. But I must nevertheless emphasise that in these cases too my officers have let themselves be guided solely by their official duty in this difficult, toilsome and for no one agreeable business, and that there can be no talk of an arbitrary exercise of the right of expulsion. (Very true! on the right.) You will no doubt spare me going into the particulars of all the individual cases. I sum up: I have had to admit that in individual cases the procedure has not accorded with my orders; I have not admitted that in any respect there has been arbitrary procedure. The orders I have given I have communicated to you with full frankness; I shall strive with all my strength that there be no departure from these principles either in the one direction or in the other. (Lively applause on the right.)
On the motion of Deputy Keruth (Liberal People's Party) a discussion of the interpellation is resolved upon.
Deputy v. Brandenstein (Conservative): The right of expulsion has not been disputed to the Government by the interpellation today. The principles which the Government has laid down for its exercise are by no means too harsh for us. (Very good! on the right.) In considering the individual cases, there drop out first of all those in which the Minister has admitted mistakes. Further, the Schöne case drops out, in which it does not seem improbable to me that irregularities have occurred (hear! hear! on the left), but for which the Minister has promised a remedy. In any event the whole case has not the least to do with expulsion. The
