Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 11 · 16 March 1906
4printed page
scan 2 of 24

4 — "Die Welt" — No. 11

Unhappily, however, we lack faith in the redeeming activity of the Imperial Duma in general, and in its more humane attitude towards the Jewish question in particular. For from whom are the Jews to obtain their rights as men? Of the conservative parties there is not a word to be lost; for these have already shown themselves clearly and plainly to be antisemites of the purest water. Hatred of the Jews is even an important point of their political programme and is constantly emphasised. Among the moderate liberals there are non-antisemites as well; the majority of them are tinged with antisemitism. There remain, then, the Constitutional Democrats, the Social Revolutionaries and the Social Democrats. The first of these, too, now quite certainly take a standpoint friendly to the Jews, and for the present they will surely advocate the equal rights of the Jews. Should the Jewish question come up for debate immediately after the first assembling of the Imperial Duma (on 27 April — 10 May), the Constitutional Democrats would without doubt vote for the equality of the Jews before the law. For in the first period of its existence this party, which is persecuted by both extremes, will be really liberal and really democratic. The pressure from without and the young progressive zeal within will see to that.

But the Jewish question will certainly not be debated in the first session of the Imperial Duma; Durnovo and his associates will see to that. And with time the progressive zeal of the Constitutional Democratic party will cool, just as the pressure now weighing upon it will slacken. And then either it will become altogether "Judaized", and as such will no longer possess the desired influence, or else it will keep itself as far as possible from the Jews and stand coldly aloof from Jewish interests, so as not to be exposed to the reproach of "Judaization". Exactly so it fared with the National Liberal party in Germany and with the democratic parties in other countries of Western Europe. For in truth the liberal and even the democratic parties in a constitutional country occupy the same place that the conservatives hold in an autocratic one; especially when there exist beside them far more extreme parties, revolutionary and social-democratic. The very existence of these more extreme parties of itself makes the liberal and democratic ones much tamer and much more conservative. For those of really radical and revolutionary mind gradually join these extreme parties, so that in the ranks of the less extreme only half-radicals and half-conservatives remain. Exactly so will it fare with the Russian Constitutional Democratic party too. Let it be ever so honest in its democratism now, — it will not remain so for long. The really radical-democratic elements will gradually go over to the Social Revolutionaries and Social Democrats, and the Constitutional Democratic party will unawares, perhaps even unconsciously, be compelled to become a moderate-liberal party. Even now, indeed, it is not in the least revolutionary, but merely oppositional. And such a party can never combat antisemitism resolutely and with all its strength. It is too little radical for that. In order to combat unsparingly so deep-rooted, one might almost say — inborn, a sentiment as antisemitism is, in order to tear hatred of the Jews out by the root at least in its own midst, a party must be ruled by a truly radical, revolutionary spirit, which the Constitutional Democratic party neither possesses nor can possess. It will — so we will hope — never come forward as avowedly antisemitic; nor, so far, does the German National Liberal party do so. But to sacrifice, out of a riding of principles, the interests of the party, which are always injured by the cry of "Judaization", to the protection of the Jews — that would be too much even for a democratic party. For even the revolutionary parties are not readily prepared to make such sacrifices . . .

The example of the Western European Jews, who for decades together set all their hopes upon the National Liberal and democratic parties and were so bitterly disappointed, should serve as a warning sign to the Russian Jews. To be exposed to the danger of the most frightful pogroms in order to follow the Constitutional Democratic party into the election contest, — that would be for sorely tried Russian Jewry too high a price for too slight political values.

The revolutionary parties of Russia have resolved to boycott the Imperial Duma, and hitherto they have in fact not merely taken no part in the elections themselves, but have even disturbed them by force. They therefore do not come into consideration at all for the first Russian elections. But even should they now, at the eleventh hour, change their resolution and take part in the elections, we could — we must carry our heresy through to the end — not rely upon them overmuch. We do not wish either to cast suspicion on their zeal for equality or to accuse them of antisemitism. (We are by no means of those who scent antisemitism everywhere and found Zionism upon the eternity and omnipresence of hatred of the Jews.) The Social Democrats and Social Revolutionaries are not antisemites. But what makes them unfit defenders of the Jewish rights of men and of the people is the following circumstance: they do not see, and do not wish to see, that the Jewish question is something peculiar, something exceptional, for which reason a specific, exceptional attitude towards it and towards its consequences is required. For this reason — not, say, out of antisemitism — they accepted the pogroms as they ought not to have accepted a phenomenon so unique and so specific in its frightful kind. The phrase "counter-revolution" sufficed them, although anti-Jewish pogroms have occurred also in times and countries quite untouched by revolutions, and although counter-revolutions have nothing to do with harmless women and old men and with children two years old. It sufficed them to proclaim that the Jews would obtain full freedom and equality with all the other nationalities of Russia, although they ought surely to see that, whereas all the other nationalities of Russia were even hitherto fairly equal among themselves in their rights or in their rightlessness, the Jewish people has hitherto stood in a wholly exceptional state, in respect of its rights or rightlessness, in the midst of all these peoples. This explains, too, their comparative indifferentism during the pogroms and after them. The Odessa organ-