"Die Welt" — No. 9 — Page 2.
(continued from page 1)
...nution of this equality of rights does occur, through the never wholly vanishing Jew-hatred, which leads the executive authorities to take up quite a different attitude towards the Jews than towards the other full citizens; but the law rests upon complete equality. A Constitution and anti-Jewish exceptional laws — until now one could not conceive of the two united; it was until now, so to speak, a contradictio in adjecto. When Roumania felt the desire, after the proclamation of the Constitution forced upon it from without, to apply exceptional laws against the Roumanian Jews, it saw itself compelled to take refuge in a certain political trick: it actually granted full civil rights to a few Roumanian Jews, while declaring all the other Jews, settled in Roumania for centuries, to be "aliens" without rights. But a constitutional country — however imperfect its Constitution may be, — that grants no equality of rights to Jews it has recognised as "natives," — that was until now something unheard of. Should the Russian Government succeed in postponing the decision of the Imperial Duma on the Jewish question, or even in having it decided in a sense agreeable to it (that is, to the Government), then, as has been said, the Russian Jews and the Russian non-Jews of all nations will gradually reconcile themselves to the idea that a Constitution and Jewish equality of rights are two entirely different things, in other words: that "the law was not written for the Jews." . . . And such a notion of Jewish rights will, under a constitutional order, bear the very worst fruits: outlawry is far more dangerous under a comparatively free regime than under one that oppresses everything. And, what is worst of all: the bondage into which Russian Jewry will then fall will be the more terrible, the more glaringly it stands in contradiction to the freedom of all the other nations of Russia.
For an earnest and deeper-thinking man it is at times sad and ludicrous at once to behold how certain Zionists and the Bundists vie with one another in fabricating fantastic and wholly impracticable programmes of Jewish autonomy in Russia. The one party as well as the other speaks in the most earnest tone of a "Jewish Diet," which is to be a real institution of the state and would possess both the powers and the functions of the German and Austrian Diets; they differ merely in that the Bundists, far more utopian in this respect, regard the formal sanction of the all-Russian state for this "Jewish Diet" ("Jewrejsky Sejm") as necessary and attainable, while the far more sober Zionists content themselves with the "notification" of this national institution to the higher Government . . . And a fierce struggle has arisen between the one and the other as to whether the "Jewish Diet" is to represent merely the cultural interests of the Jewish people, as the Bundists wish, thereby becoming untrue to their strict Marxism, or the political-economic interests as well, as the Zionists demand, thereby stretching their Zionism somewhat too far . . . A Jewish national curia, the Judaeo-German Jargon as a language of state (some Zionists even demand state recognition of Hebrew and of the Jargon together . . .), specially Jewish judges, Jewish universities and other Jewish institutions of higher learning in which Hebrew or Jargon is to be the language of instruction, — all this is regarded as a specifically Jewish demand, which is in all seriousness to be laid before the future constitutional Government of Russia in the name of the Jewish people . . . A deep sorrow comes over one when one looks on and sees how an earnest, sorely tried and eminently practical people such as the Jewish, which perhaps was able to exist even in the most frightful circumstances only because it never lost touch with reality, — how this people now positively revels in illusions and phantoms, whereby it may perhaps neglect that which under present conditions is the most indispensable and the only thing attainable. A Jewish Diet without a Jewish land! A Jewish autonomy with a national-Jewish supreme organ of state at its head, while the Jews everywhere, in all the Russian provinces, form a minority! — Should this "Jewish Diet," as the Bundists conceive it, wholly neglecting, as has been said, their "Marxism" (merely in order to be able to deny the importance of the territorial factor), occupy itself only with the intellectual and cultural questions of Russian Jewry, then it does not deserve this well-sounding name, for in that case it is by no means an institution of the state of great importance. Should it, however, concern itself with Jewish political affairs as well, then the peoples of Russia that have become autonomous (for only on this condition is its coming into being conceivable), among whom the Jews dwell, will surely make war upon it and persecute it; more than this: they will make its coming into being impossible, or at the least prevent its sanction. —
It is the same with the Jewish national curia. In Austria the question of a Jewish electoral curia is truly a burning one, a vital question for the Austrian Jews. For there the Government itself is already in a manner planning to create national curiae for the Poles and Ruthenians; and the Jews must not and shall not be crushed between hammer and anvil. Moreover, the Austrian Jews have equality of rights, at least on paper. It is otherwise in Russia, where there has so far been no talk of national curiae for other peoples, apart from the Jews, and where a hard struggle for our most primitive rights of man still lies before us. As regards Jewish judges, Jewish universities and the recognition of a Jewish language by the state, we would recommend to the Bundists, as well as to many an over-zealous Zionist, that they look at the new Prussian School Law, under which the most harmless autonomy of the quite unpretentious Jewish schools of Prussia is trampled underfoot; and Russia will truly not possess for a long while yet a better and more just constitutional order than the Prussians. And altogether it is more than strange that Russian Jewry, which has not even got so far as to wring from the Russian Government any concessions whatever in respect of the rights of man, should be busied just now with building castles in the air. At times there ring out