No. 7 — "Die Welt" — 7.
One of the most interesting features of this trial is the constitution of the so-called Committee of Justice. An antisemitic agitator, an editor of the "Deutsches Volksblatt" in Vienna, appeared in Polna and, with the support of the burgomaster, the police commissary and other municipal functionaries, opened a formal subsidiary inquiry of his own. A great number of persons were examined and their statements taken down; their number is given now as 80, now as 180. The testimony of the witnesses was prepared by this Committee of Justice for the main hearing, and where it departed from the statements made before the Committee, the latter were held up to the witness by the counsel for the private party; indeed, one of the chief witnesses for the prosecution was even furnished by the Committee with the means to carry on the lawsuits in which he had become entangled through his part in the Hilsner trial. The mischief of the Committee of Justice was tolerated, probably "on account of the disquiet among the broader strata of the people." —
Austrian justice suffered unheard-of abuse of the judges of Kuttenberg, and indeed of the then head of the Imperial-Royal Ministry of Justice, Ignaz Edler von Ruber, to pass unanswered. The sodden antisemitic "representative of the people" Schneider said in the Lower Austrian Diet on 5th November 1904: "He had not given way to the Jews, and had made it impossible for Minister Ruber to hush up the Polna ritual murder and other ritual murders." The Minister quietly swallowed these and still coarser insults from the antisemite and made no response. Perhaps he had his reasons. Perhaps he feared the parliamentary hooligan. But had he the right to deliver up a human being, to abandon him to the fury and barbarity of the mob — nay, more, to create a grave precedent? This was no simple, "common" murder. Ritual murder — so ran the charge. That is no longer a charge against an individual, but against an entire people. How much blood has this most stupid and most cruel of all blood-fables not already cost us! Before Polna, Xanten and Tisza-Eszlar; after Polna, Konitz. Popes have long since issued bulls against this blood-fable, governments have published stern edicts. But the people knew that all of them, State and Church alike, did not mean it so seriously and were not so particular where the Jews were concerned. The people is always brutal, believes the most impossible things, and can make the most fantastic statements under solemn oath. The Polna trial is a treasure-house for such criminal-psychological observations. But our interest is not confined to that. We are not in the comfortable position of the observer, the onlooker. Prof. Franz Liszt draws rather melancholy conclusions from the trial concerning the psychology of testimony and its trustworthiness. Dr. Karl Krall, Imperial-Royal President of the Superior Provincial Court, retired, writes of it in the "Neue Freie Presse":
"We stand here before convictions which awaken the gravest misgivings, and one must surely put the question whether the provisions of our Code of Criminal Procedure suffice to prevent the recurrence of such cases, and what was the conduct of our public functionaries who made it possible for convictions to be pronounced on the basis of circumstantial indications which can truly not be regarded as a reassuring foundation for a verdict of guilty."
He takes his stand on this question from the standpoint of the jurist who advocates the reform of criminal procedure. But we, we who are the injured party, we who suffer under the injustice of a whole world, must regard the question from another point of view. We must say to ourselves: "We are a little band, and the enemies are hosts." And our enemies are stupidity and malice and Jew-hatred. Every social ill, every historically inherited ulcer, also takes on the forms of antisemitism, infects us, affects us. The old hopes of the Liberals were dashed to pieces upon the rock of real life. What can we hope for? Yesterday it was Polna, then came Konitz, soon Kishineff was upon us. Even revolutions have an antisemitic facet.
We look upon the Polna trial with the eyes of the slandered man who all but despairs of himself, and seeks within himself a hold and courage. And we say with Achad-Haam:
"Is it then possible that the whole world is wrong and the Jews alone are right? Assuredly it is possible, and the blood-lie is the proof. Here the Jews are as pure as the angels of heaven. A Jew and blood? Are there then two greater opposites than these? And yet!" .. A half consolation — a feeble consolation. The lamb consoles itself that the wolf which devours it is unjust, but devoured it is nevertheless! And yet . . . — there are Jews who content themselves even with the "half consolation"!
The Initials. To the many designations and epithets of the Jewish people one more epithet might be added: "A people of initials." No people on earth has been so fond of using abbreviations and initials as the Jewish. In the whole of Greek literature one finds perhaps a few abbreviations, and these too were of an unimportant kind. With the Jews the matter stood otherwise. They never pronounced the most important words and ideas in full. They abbreviated the name of God and pronounced only the initials. And when the belief in angels and devils was incorporated into the Jewish faith, they abbreviated these new appellations as well. The Talmud, the Zohar, the whole of mediaeval literature bristle with abbreviations and initials (or Rosche-Tewos, Notrikon, as they were called in the Hebrew-Aramaic idiom). The Jew had too quick, too restless a mind; he had too little time to pronounce everything in full with leisure and ease. He had much to conceal, and hid himself behind "initials." Whereas the German, in his ponderous way, always called his great men by their full, long-winded names, the Jew strove to abbreviate and compress the names of his own as much as possible. Of Rabbi Mosche ben Maimon he made Rambam, of Moses Mendelsohn — Rambaman, of S. D. Luzzatto — Schadal, and so forth. It is of course a metaphor, but it has a kernel of truth: the whole of Jewish life is an abbreviation. Nowhere a full living-out of oneself, a calm, easy, leisurely tempo. It would be an interesting task to set forth the part and the significance of all the initials that have held a place in Jewish life. It would perhaps be a history of the culture of Judaism.
With the new age, new watchwords came into Jewish life — new initials. A Jewish writer, a witty head and well-known satirist, Mr. A. L. Lewinsky, has written in a humorous article in the Jewish daily "Der Weg" some fine and clever remarks on this theme, which we should like to reproduce here.
He writes: "We still remember how differently people thought about the matter after the pogroms of the eighties. They did not rely on strangers, did not count on 'S. D.' (Social Democrats), 'S. R.' (Social Revolutionaries), 'K. D.' (Constitutional Democrats) and other 'initials.' They understood well that help lies in ourselves alone. Therefore they created the society 'Bilu' [initials of Bes Jakow L'chu w'nelchu], whose goal was Erez-Isral, whose endeavour was to find a way for the Jewish people, a way to the old fatherland. At that time a second society was founded, 'Alu' [initials of "Am olom l'chu w'nelchu], to create new homesteads for Jews in America. You see