No. 5 — "Die Welt" — Page 17
(continued from page 16)
…reasons I consider it imperative, in order to prevent immeasurable misery, to adopt the following resolution, to which I need hardly prefix the assurance that no one in this hall hears this motion with heavier concern than I feel in submitting it to you:
"The Conference gives expression to its deep sorrow that the emigration of persons without means,
- because the considerable means required are lacking;
- because at present no countries of immigration are available for this category of emigrants;
- because a further influx of larger masses into the existing countries of immigration must be attended with dangers for those already settled there
is not possible at present nor in the foreseeable future, and therefore sees itself compelled to give earnest warning against an aimless and planless emigration of persons without means."
Felice Ravenna-Ferrara: Brings a cordial manifestation of sympathy from the Zionist Federation of Italy and from the Jewish communities of Ferrara, Acqui, Ancona, Modena, Venice, Reggio, Vercelli, Mantua, on whose behalf he has come to the Conference.
Dr. Bodenheimer: Polemicises against Dr. Nathan. He speaks in favour of supporting self-defence. He scourges the hypocrisy of the German press, which represents the self-defence as a revolutionary movement and could not find words enough of praise for the Russian Germans living abroad who had hastened to Russia to protect their families in the struggle against the insurgent Letts. The self-defence must, however, be organised, so that there may also be a control to ensure that the funds collected are really used only for this purpose.
Dr. Ludwig Werner—Vienna gives the grounds for the motions of the Jewish Gymnastic Association, which lie before the Conference in print and which aim at raising a strong Jewish generation in Russia. He requests that the details of the proposals be dealt with in a special commission.
Mr. Mossinsohn turns sharply against Klee's proposal. He finds it quite incomprehensible that the Russian Jews should be expected to give away their children. They would sooner prefer pogroms.
D. Jochelmann: The form which the Conference has taken spares me from entering here into any polemics. The chief concern here is to give the unhappy Jews momentary help and for this purpose to unite various philanthropic organisations which up to now have each worked alone in this sense. This I can only welcome most warmly. But two motions have also been put forward, against which I will not polemicise but which I wish to establish as a fact. There is before us the Kohan motion on emigration, which is nothing else than the dispersion of the Jews into various countries, which will have the same consequences as those that follow from the policy of the Ica, which the Zionists have always combated with determination. Now the Zionist Organisation puts forward the same motion. This I wish to establish. Then there is a motion of Prof. Warburg that a commission be elected to explore the Orient (i. e. Palestine and the neighbouring countries). Against a commission which is to concern itself with the investigation of various countries no one can have anything. But if it says expressly Palestine and the neighbouring countries, that only means that the Zionist Organisation has invited us in order to propose the Zionist programme to us. Whoever agrees with this programme, let him accept it. I have already heard that the representatives of various philanthropic institutions present here agree with these motions. I ask only: what, then, is the whole Conference for?
After some brief remarks by Dr. Gronemann, Hanover, who speaks in favour of Dr. Klee's proposals, the floor is taken by
Engineer Ussischkin-Ekaterinoslaw, who points out that the Russian Jews alone are in a position to decide what work is to be done within Russia. The answer to the question of what kind the work outside Russia must be, he had already given in Basle. The Spielmann resolution he described as purposeless. The Russian Government would pay heed to a resolution introduced here in favour of equal rights for the Russian Jews only if it were drawn up in a form which made it plain that the whole Jewish people was united in this demand and ready to uphold it with all emphasis. It was not the business of this Conference to set up demands for the generality of Russians. The Russian Jews had shed so much blood for the cause of Russia that it was surely time for once to look after Jewish interests as such.
Mr. Greenberg is entirely of Ussischkin's opinion that a resolution in this Conference for the equal rights of the Russian Jews would be purposeless. Warburg's resolution, too, he considers problematical. An immigration into the Orient would call forth the opposition of the Jews there just as much as is the case in England and America. Ussischkin's view, that the Russian Jews alone can decide what is to be done for the Jews in Russia, is calculated to destroy the whole work of relief. Russia is indeed the centre of Jewry, but we too suffer directly from the Russian Jewish question and are therefore fully entitled to have a weighty word to say in its solution. He introduces the following resolution: The Conference shall elect a permanent commission which shall safeguard the rights of the Jews and everywhere stand up for the equal rights of the Jews, regulate the migration of the Jews and give counsel to all.
Mr. Cowen-London supports Greenberg's resolution. He too is against Warburg's motion, because this motion has a Zionist tendency, and this Conference was after all expressly to discuss only proposals of a general nature.
On the motion of Dr. Bodenheimer a 9-member commission was appointed for the preliminary consideration of the resolutions introduced. The commission consisted of Messrs. Bergel, Dr. Bodenheimer, Spielmann, Dr. Kohan-Bernstein, Leo Motzkin, Dr. Leo Kohan, Professor Warburg, Dr. Jassinowsky, Engineer Temkin.
EVENING SESSION
In the evening session Mr. Temkin first emphasised that Ussischkin's utterances had been misunderstood. Naturally Ussischkin had not wished to dispense with the co-operation of the Western European Jews. He, Temkin, would like to underline that the Russian Jewish question is a general Jewish one. He too turns energetically against the Spielmann resolution. At a time when public opinion in Russia itself is ignored, such a resolution would be purposeless. Moreover, it was not the time to ask, but to demand.
Dr. Sarfatti-Milan greeted the Conference in the name of the Israelite community of Milan and declared that the Jews of Italy, where antisemitism is almost unknown, are filled with horror and shuddering at the unspeakable sufferings of their brethren in Russia. Whatever might be resolved here, the mere fact that here for the first time a gathering of Jews of all countries and of the most diverse tendencies had taken place for common Jewish work was an expression of the life of the Jewish people and of its indestructible solidarity.
Mr. S. Bergel thereupon delivered the report on the proceedings of the commission, in which the various motions had been combined into 3. Thereupon the resolutions given in the official report were adopted, the first unanimously. In the discussion of the third motion Dr Nathan and Dr Hildesheimer urgently recommended the adoption of the original Hildesheimer resolution, emphasising that it was indispensably necessary to warn emphatically from this place against an emigration of persons without means. In a lengthy debate the arguments of the gentlemen of the Hilfsverein were most vigorously combated from the Zionist side. It was declared that the emigration could not be stopped at all under present circumstances, and that even the worst sufferings abroad did not come near the dreadful torments to which the Russian Jews are exposed to-day. After a long debate, into which in particular the spirited remarks of Mr. Shire, who with sharpness against the Hildesheimer