Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 5 · 2 February 1906
16printed page
scan 14 of 24

Page 16 — "Die Welt" — No. 5

(continued from page 15)

…ganisations are to be raised, shall also be empowered to take preparatory measures in hand independently."

Dr. Marmorek spoke as follows: "From to-day there begins, in my opinion, a new epoch in Jewish life. It is the first time that Jews of different party tendencies have found one another again for common work. It can only fill us with great satisfaction that the Jewish corporations have accepted the invitation of the Zionists, and we welcome most especially that the "Hilfsverein deutscher Juden" and the "Anglo Jewish Association" are represented here by delegates who are distinguished not only by their personal qualities but also by the importance which they hold in Jewry. Everyone knows what position Dr. Paul Natan holds in Jewry. But the remarks of Dr. Nathan move me to maintain precisely the contrary. Dr. Nathan has here marked out his standpoint, and you will not take it amiss of me if I too represent my opinion, which is the opinion of many of those present. Dr. Nathan compared the goal of our endeavours with the development of civilised humanity, and in doing so expressed the hope that the Jewish question will be solved when humanity has stepped out of barbarism. But then he added that he regards Zionism as a remote illusion which could be realised only in the most distant times. Now I believe that his goal is rather more an illusion than ours. With his view he strives far more towards utopian goals. The barbarism of mankind is age-old, and in spite of the civilising labour of 2000 years barbarism has as yet made no progress towards improvement. How should one not be convinced that it will last for centuries yet? For barbarism seems to be innate in man. Dr. Nathan said, against Mr. Motzkin, that the Jewish question is not a question of money. It seems to me that he has misunderstood our Mr. Motzkin. The Jewish question is a political question, and like all political questions, be they ever so great or small, it needs one thing, namely money, much money. And that the Jewish question is a political question, our assembly of to-day proves.

Dr. Franz Oppenheimer: One must above all occupy oneself with purely practical questions. We must keep before our eyes: here a cart is stuck in the mire, so shoulders to it, out with the cart! I too do not willingly forgo emphasising still more forcibly, before so significant an assembly, what I have so long said and written. We have a twofold task: the relief of the distress of the present and the creation of a common organisation for the future. For the present we can do nothing else than distribute the funds collected as well as possible. Under no circumstances may we encourage emigration. The non-Russian Jews, who represent only 10 per cent. of the whole of Jewry, must emphasise with insistence that they will soon have come to the end of their strength and means. A new inundation would compel us to let our hands drop. But we will and must create institutions to meet the coming calamity. And therefore we should all unanimously accept Warburg's proposal. We must study the countries which can still take in people. We must try again and again to win the Jews for agriculture. If the Jews came over as farmers, they would be welcome everywhere.

Dr. Klee-Berlin likewise supports Warburg's proposal and enlarges at some length on his own proposals (to take Jewish children from the East and educate them in Western Europe), which we published in our last number.

Attorney Jassinowsky-Warsaw warns urgently against a public discussion of the internal conditions of Russia and points out that there is no means of damming the emigration. "You will yet witness, gentlemen, quite another spectacle, a phenomenon hitherto unknown in Jewish life: emigrants of a special sort — university men, physicians, advocates, engineers will come to you. They will not beg you for bread, they will implore you for a revolver with which they may put an end to their despair. That is so dreadful that I will not speak further of it." He appeals to the assembly to unite in common action for a regulation of the emigration.

Dr. Friedeberger-London. It is impossible to solve the Jewish question between 9 and 6 o'clock. Let us not talk about Zionism and Territorialism! Let us seek out the common points, let us create an international organisation! Let us see to it that, in contrast to actions striving in different directions, a proper diagnosis is first made. The Russian Jewish question is closely bound up with the general Jewish one. I consider it inexpedient that we should enter to-day into questions of detail as to how the emigration from Russia is to be regulated. If we resolve to-day that an international organisation shall be created for the regulation, the constant supervision and the direction of the relief work, we shall have done enough. One thing more I should like to say, in contradiction to the remarks of Dr. Nathan. We cannot rely upon "historical development." Truly too much time would pass before humanity is healed of barbarism.

Mr. Spielmann-London expresses his pleasure at the moderate tone of this assembly. He gives his reasons for, and moves, the following resolution: "The Conference, which has met in view of the general situation of the Russian Jews, demands, both in the interest of the Russian Empire and in that of its Jewish subjects, the removal of all anti-Jewish laws and the granting of full civil rights to the Jews, which, in the conviction of all, they are perfectly fitted to exercise." —

Mr. Kish-London supports the Spielmann resolution and thanks the chairman and all the conveners of the Conference. He finds the remarks of the President in his opening speech regarding the non-participation of the "Ica" and the "Alliance" somewhat too sharp. He believes that solely the opinion that only Zionist matters would be discussed at this Conference had caused the two organisations to stay away. After the course of the proceedings he is convinced that these two bodies too will not withdraw from the common work.

Mr. B. J. Belisha advocates the formation of a permanent Jewish representation which shall safeguard the interests of the Jewish people. His proposal reads: This Congress declares itself for the appointment of an international Jewish commission for the obtaining of reliable and exact information about the countries which would be suitable for the founding of a home on an autonomous basis for a great number of Russian Jews. This commission shall consist of 21 members, of whom 3 from the Zionist A. C., 3 from the Ito and 15 from all the remaining Jewish organisations of the whole world.

Dr. Hirsch Hildesheimer-Berlin declared it wholly unjustified to underestimate the achievements of the relief organisations up to now. In fact, he said, the willingness to give had never before accomplished anything approaching what it accomplishes at present. It was indeed true that the sums available, although they amount to nearly fifteen million francs, are not remotely sufficient to stem effectively the immeasurable misery. But this had its cause not in the narrow-heartedness of the givers, but in the gigantic magnitude of the distress. Sad as it is that not even the most immediate demands can be satisfied, the fact must be reckoned with, above all in the question of emigration. Who in our midst would not stake his all to prepare a new home for the greatest possible number of our gravely threatened brethren, perishing in misery? But the material means for an extensive emigration are not available, nor can they be procured even by summoning the whole capacity of united Jewry, at any rate not so quickly as the moment demands. But it is by no means a mere question of money; even if the gigantic sums could be raised, the countries of immigration in which larger masses could be settled at once with some prospect of success are not yet at our disposal. That for the present an agricultural colonisation on any considerable scale must be renounced is certainly very, very painful, but a fact which we are unable to alter. For colossal means are required for it, which moreover would benefit only a relatively small fraction. That the difficulties are increasing in the countries which have hitherto formed the favoured places of refuge is well known. But these are not only legal difficulties; through the mass influx and above all through the crowding of these masses into a few places, the situation of those already settled in those countries grows worse in a terrible degree. This is shown afresh by the latest report of the United Hebrew Charities in New York. Yes, every nerve in us rises up against the brutal fact that we stand so powerless before this fearful calamity, the equal of which the history of our people's sufferings does not show, that we are unable to snatch from their perils our brethren beset by death and ruin. But hard as it comes to us, for the aforementioned