"Die Welt" — Page 12. — No. 5.
(continued from page 11)
… but one note was to be heard: indignation against the counter-revolution. It was quite forgotten that the question was not only one of rights but also one of human beings. Men sought to stem the calamity out of revolutionary principle, so that we Jews were wholly left out of account as human beings and stood there only as an object of the struggle and a means of the struggle. And precisely this eternal stress upon the counter-revolution — apart from certain deeply felt utterances, such as those of Prof. Bulgakow — has materially lessened the value of the help granted us. The press of the capital even endeavoured to pass over our existence in silence, and instead of consoling sympathy for our boundless suffering, instead of horror at the hell that had opened for a whole people, we found, apart from a part of the provincial press, general reflections in which we, who had endured the most and had become outlaws as no one else, were mentioned in the last place. It was quite forgotten that perhaps three quarters of the counter-revolution in the vast Russian Empire struck the Jews, and the Jews as a unit, without distinction.
A certain satisfaction is afforded us by the circumstance, which must be emphasised, that from the most radical circles a number of non-Jews stood by our brethren in the most active form in the struggle for life and death, and that several of them, too, met their death. Blinow, the hero of Schitomir, by no means remained solitary; a number of others joined him. These fighters may indeed have fought also for their own cause, the cause of freedom; but the intensity of their power of self-sacrifice in the defence of the Jews must at the same time, beyond doubt, be set to the account of their feeling of humanity and of their sympathy for the persecuted, and has doubly hallowed their deed.
But what holds good for individuals, especially the intellectuals, cannot be transferred to the great mass of the Russian proletariat. For with few exceptions even the organised mass kept aloof from the struggles for our lives, from the struggles against our tormentors. Not everything has yet been cleared up; we should not yet wish to pass an absolute, final judgment as to how far the will, how far the power, was lacking here; but this much is certain, that the help granted us from this side was in the end equal to nothing, so far as the proletarian mass is concerned. The admission made from authoritative circles of the Social Democracy, "that the Russian working class during the massacres of the Jews "did not stand at the height of its task", is all the more serious for us, as a metamorphosis in this respect is not to be attained so quickly, in spite of all the subsequent resolutions. This element, however, is in the towns the only one whose organised help can come into consideration for us in the future too, at new outbreaks. It must be admitted, indeed, that the struggle with and for the Jews is neither easy nor simple. The Russian proletariat could have given real help to the assailed Jews only if, even at a couple of points, it had turned the pogrom into an armed rising of the people, since these tactics of the working-class circles would have frightened the Russian bureaucracy away from further dangerous experiments, or also perhaps if it had resorted to the general strike.
It is, however, a great question whether the sympathy of the organised Russian working masses for our fate can become so great. For the events that followed upon the pogroms also justify us in doubt. Various groups of organised workmen, it is true, especially from among the railwaymen, made public declarations after the excesses that they would not tolerate excesses against the Jews, that they would actively oppose them. But why, one asks with justice, did the proletariat not feel moved, after the pogroms, to proclaim the general strike as a protest against these infamies? Why did the Council of Workmen's Delegates, which for a time was feared by the Government and represented an imposing power, not resolve upon this weapon, with which it at once answered the proclamation of martial law over Poland? If the pogroms against the Jews are to be regarded merely as a counter-revolution, then this, the bloodiest and most agonising of all, ought surely in any case to have been answered by a corresponding revolutionary act. That precisely in this case even political logic failed is more than disquieting.
As regards the peasants, their role during the massacres of the Jews was not so considerable. That many thousands of them wished to enrich themselves with Jewish goods and streamed in masses with their carts into the towns to gather in their share need not first be said. On the occasion of the raids licensed by the authorities, kleptomania proved itself altogether an epidemic which the peasants, too, could not withstand. At home in their own villages, however, they in many cases protected the Jews, prevented pogroms, thrashed the inciting agents sent out by the organisation, and passed resolutions against pogroms. Other peasant communities, however, themselves organised regular pogroms, which at times degenerated into butcheries as well. The conduct of the peasants is conditioned by various circumstances. At present they are waging, as it is said, an embittered struggle against the landowners, whose soil they claim; and if in this struggle the landed proprietors or the police officials try to divert their wrath upon the Jews, they succeed but rarely. The prohibition against the purchase of land has detached the Jews from the object of the struggle. Who knows what a tempest would have broken over the Jews had the number of Jewish landowners been even ever so small. Now, however, the socialist agitators are able, as often as a pogrom against the Jews is recommended to the peasants, to make clear to them what intention lies behind it. But where the peasants in the villages do not want an anti-Jewish riot, there the will of the police or of the agents of reaction is powerless.
Even though, accordingly, the conduct of the peasants, in view of the economic struggles in many provinces, is for the moment such as to inspire confidence in the Jews, the position of the Jews is nevertheless not secure here either. Quite apart from the fact that those elements among the peasants who dispose of larger landed property, and who hate the present agrarian movement, would for the most part also like to proceed against the Jews at the same time, the Russian peasants are altogether still so ignorant and so undeveloped that one may predict nothing, the more so as the peasant rising may assume exorbitant forms and pour itself over everything like a stream of lava.
That the Jews do not feel safe in very many villages either is proved indeed by the fact that so many are fleeing into the towns; for where they are endangered in the villages, there they look forward to the future with the greatest fear, there they suffer daily the torments of hell.
In the near future, moreover, it is chiefly the towns that come into consideration, since in them the bulk of Russian Jewry is concentrated. If one now asks how the urban element, apart from the liberal or radical intellectuals and the working proletariat, of whom we have already spoken, behaved in the October days, the answer is by no means consoling. It is subject to no doubt that a very great part of the upper and lower middle classes, who after all make up the majority in most of the towns inhabited by Jews, sympathised more or less with the excesses. Where there was not sympathy, there at least indifference came to light. Even now the crosses that are to be seen on the Christian shops in the main streets of Kieff are an uncanny sign. When the Jews were attacked, all these elements were at once ready to make known their privileged standing by displaying holy pictures and crosses. Well, one cannot reason with them about that; how many of them, too, may have trembled! But what otherwise was the conduct of the ordinary Philistines? Had the entire non-Jewish population been filled with indignation at the anti-Jewish riots called forth by the Government, it would surely everywhere have been an easy matter to shelter from maltreatment and death, in Christian dwellings, the Jews, who live scattered among Christians, mostly with Christian landlords. Now, if many beyond doubt have shown compassion and some even warm, active humanity, it is nevertheless more important for the Jews that the fugitives so often met with the opposite, mostly against their expectation. I could already, from my own knowledge, bring forward a whole collection of cases which have a positively appalling effect. For it is not always ordinary Philistines who have barred the door to their Jewish fellow-citizens in the utmost fear for their lives, and so exposed them to mortal danger. Even university men have at times displayed such conduct. When it can happen that a professor protests against a Jewish family's hiding in the hotel in which he too lives, when a physician first takes into the kitchen the wife of a colleague, who in his lifetime had been on close terms with him for long years, together with her children, and then with rough words compels them to leave, when the physician of a hospital turns away a Jewish woman in childbirth during the most frightful scenes, etc., etc., it is clear that the notion of the hooligan must indeed be very much extended, at all events as far as that professor who in Odessa gave a soldier brandy and at the same time pointed to a dwelling in which a Jew had taken refuge. That there, as has been said, apart from the