Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 5 · 2 February 1906
1scan
of 24

DIE WELT

CENTRAL ORGAN OF THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT

COLOGNE (GERMANY), UBIERRING 23

— APPEARS EVERY FRIDAY — EDITORS: BERTHOLD FEIWEL, A. CORALNIK.

10th YEAR | COLOGNE, 2nd February 1906 | ז"שבט א"תתלז לחורבן | No. 5.


THE BRUSSELS CONFERENCE

There has surely been no assembly of the representatives of Jewish public life in recent years that was called together with such great labour as the one which has just sat in Brussels. The difficulties lay in the very nature of the Conference, but also in the peculiar position of those who convened it. All the assemblies and conferences that had taken place hitherto were either party gatherings, or else they bore a philanthropic character that shrank timidly back from every political question. Such were the Zionist Congresses on the one hand, and such were the various meetings of the relief institutions of Frankfort, London, etc., on the other.

What came to pass in Brussels on the 29th of January was a novelty, a first attempt. It was to be an assembly of the parties and groups of the Jewish people; an understanding was to be brought about ad hoc between the scattered sections of Jewry in Eastern and Western Europe for the purpose of common action. And therein lay the greatest difficulty. When parties confront one another holding fundamentally different views upon one and the same question, an understanding is hard to reach. And for that reason, too, it could not be expected that the representatives of the Zionist party would be able to find common ground in matters of principle with the representatives of the other Jewish parties, whose views on the Jewish question, nay, whose whole conceptions of the world, are perhaps divided from one another by an unbridgeable gulf. It is not always true that "du choc des opinions jaillit la vérité."

Dr. Franz Oppenheimer rightly emphasised in his speech at the Conference that an understanding could be reached not in the domain of principles, but in that of practice, of the deed. The state of affairs was indeed clear. There was no problem over which one might dispute, none that admitted of being viewed from different standpoints. There was a fact which must compel everyone, even the prejudiced, to bow before it — the distress of the Russian Jews. And therefore the task was to find a practical way of stemming that distress.

Herein, however, lay the second difficulty. The conveners were Zionists. As such they had a clear, fully worked-out plan, grounded both in theory and in practice. Ought they to lay this plan before the assembly? It would have served no purpose; for were the Zionist plan so near to its realisation that it could offer an answer to the present terrible question of distress, then the Conference would have been superfluous, and we Zionists would truly not have come to the other parties to seek counsel with them. If, on the other hand, at the present stage of the movement we had wished to offer the Conference nothing but the idea, then the Conference would never have come about. It was a dilemma. For the first time the Zionists came not as stormers, not as the makers of a new future, nor yet as men drunk with an idea, but as men who, animated solely by a feeling of deep love for their people, wished to do something, anything at all, to help in the grievous distress of the day.

But of what kind was this work of relief to be? All Jewish politicians have, indeed, come to the conviction that nothing essential can be accomplished by the old means of distributing money, of petty philanthropic enterprise. A whole people, a people of six million souls, cannot be fed and maintained. "The Jewish question is not a money question" — so said a representative of Jewish philanthropy, of the modern and more large-minded kind to be sure, Dr. Paul Nathan. But this the Zionists recognised long ago, and it was out of this recognition that they drew up their programme; guided by it, they have also, at the present moment, convened the Brussels Conference.

At Brussels counsel was taken not upon how new funds were to be procured, but upon how the Russian Jews might be brought out of their hell into other conditions in which they would need no support. And there the means presented itself of its own accord, a means which reality has long since shown us — emigration.

It would perhaps earlier the business of the