Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 4.
Once More the "Alliance Israélite Universelle." And we take up the thread again. In our last number we brought against the "Alliance Israélite Universelle" the charge that it acts in the sense of French policy. There were sensitive souls to whom this reproach seemed unjust. The "Alliance" has done so much, after all! The "Alliance" has, after all, earned great and imperishable merit in spreading education among the Jews of the Orient! Certainly, and we do not wish to deny it. The "Alliance" has its merits, and a fine past as well. There was a time when it stood in the forefront of Jewish interests; that was the time of Isidor Loeb, Albert Cohn, Munk. But those times are past. The present administrators of the "Alliance" have other interests: whether consciously or unconsciously — they are doing politics for the Quai d'Orsay. It is nothing new and unheard-of that we are saying here. The sparrows are already twittering it from the rooftops. Both in France and outside that country attention has been drawn to this fact. The French politicians — and not those of the school of Jaurès and the Radicals, but those of Delcassé and Doumer — are laughing up their sleeves. The Jews pull the chestnuts out of the fire for them at enormous cost. And then "conspuons le juif!" Who made Algeria a French province, if not the Jews there? And what is the result? Max Régis and Eduard Drumont and the whole antisemitic movement in Algeria, which in part rolled over into France. But are the French unanimous in their praise of the "Alliance"? Let us hear some statements, which we quote from a detailed report of the "Kölnische Zeitung" (January 21st): "French writers, with a view to a possible conquest of Morocco by France, have occupied themselves with the future of the Jews in Morocco. In 'La Vérité sur l'Algérie' Jean Hess has accused the 'Alliance Israélite' of trying to unite the most diverse elements for action against Morocco — business men by pointing to the business to be done, nationalists, chauvinists and soldiers by pointing to honour and the flag. This action, he says, must be of a military kind, in order to serve the prestige of the 'Alliance.' The so-called 'peaceful' action which the anti-military party has approved is being conducted in such a way that it prepares the military intervention. With French treasure and blood France will have to pay for the emancipation of the Moroccan Jews. In the periodical 'Le Maroc Français' the Jewish question in Morocco was treated at length in a long article in the number of July 21st, 1804. The Moroccan question, it said there, is only a Jewish question. The Algerians coming to Morocco, the Algerian Spaniards and the Moroccan Spaniards would form a common society filled with the same antisemitic spirit. This group would lean upon the natives, as it did in Algeria, and, since it would form the strongest European group, would lead the authorities in the same direction. The Quai d'Orsay would be compelled to lean upon the Algerian-Spanish element and to deliver the Jews over to it. The only difference after emancipation would be that the Jew would be oppressed in European dress, whereas before he was oppressed in the caftan. The antisemitic crisis in Algeria had been taken lightly; yet the population of Algeria had emerged from it united in a separatist spirit The Algerians, however, were determined to secure Morocco for themselves as a field of colonisation. Tunis would join them, and the united Algeria-Tunis-Morocco would fall away from France. An antisemitic crisis in Morocco would complete the separatist trinity. With the Jews of Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia and France the Republic would have about a million Jews. Besides a Mohammedan policy, France therefore needed a Jewish policy. The 'Alliance Israélite' must go together with France as a political and social power and place the Jews in the service of French civilisation."
Thus is the policy of the "Alliance" interpreted and appraised from the French side. The author of the article in the "Maroc français" is no friend of the Jews, but his prognosis is not plucked out of the air. The "Alliance" ought itself to know that the Jew in European dress is oppressed just as well as the Jew in the caftan. What has the "Alliance" done in this direction?
But if the French, in whose interest it surely lies that the "Alliance" should pursue French policy, sometimes express themselves quite unfavourably about this activity, all the more so the non-French politicians, to whom the spread of French influence is a thorn in the eye. The same correspondent of the semi-official "Kölnische Zeitung" indulges in reflections on this subject and calls upon the German Jews to withdraw their support from the "Alliance" and to use their influence for the protection of German interests. And he then asks: "How, then, should the money of German Israelites be spent on the Moroccan Jew, living in bodily and spiritual misery, so that our national interests may draw the greatest possible advantage from it? Not in the manner hitherto; that, after what has been said above, is out of the question. Let the German Israelites demand the establishment of German schools of the Alliance, or the giving of German instruction in its schools, and the training in Germany of teachers for the Alliance schools of Morocco and elsewhere. Such a step might give the impulse for the German language, which has hitherto played a comparatively small part in the intercourse of the world, to win the place that is its due. In any case such demands would directly benefit our trade.
"Perhaps the 'Alliance,' by founding agricultural schools with German teachers, could through the men going forth from these schools open up new cultures in little-accessible parts of Morocco, and revive old ones (sugar-cane, cotton). It is to be remarked in this connection that Jews live not only in the towns but in the mountains (Rif, Atlas), as well as in the extreme south amid the mostly independent tribes; their position there corresponds to that of the serfs of the Middle Ages. In the region between the river Sus and the river Draa, as also in the source region of the Sus and the Draa, in the Atlas between the sources of the two rivers named, in the region between Tafilet and the Atlas, and in Tafilet itself, Jewish communities are everywhere to be found. The German Government might perhaps benevolently exert its influence with the Sultan for the alleviation of the condition of these Jews; the return service would be that the Jews should place themselves chiefly in the service of German trade. I should like to propose that, simultaneously with the Morocco Conference, a consultation on this question be arranged between eminent representatives of the German Israelites and representatives of our Government, with the participation of diplomats residing in Germany who know Moroccan conditions."
From the standpoint of the German politician the correspondent of the semi-official organ of the German Foreign Office is entirely right. If the "Alliance," as is said, lends itself to promoting French interests under the cloak of Judaism, why should German Jewry not do the same?
Do the gentlemen of the "Alliance" now understand where their policy is leading, onto what by-paths they have strayed? Do they also know that the German Jews, who in judaicis for a good part think just as they do — that is, are assimilationists — will not need to be told twice such things as the "Köln. Zeit." puts forward?