Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 3 · 19 January 1906
12printed page
scan 10 of 24

"Die Welt" — Page 12 — No. 3.

(continued from page 11)

…were entirely covered. But even under the blanket of snow they went on talking: When we were still young . . . . Might it not be the same with Dr. Byk and the 70-year-old "Allg. Ztg.", that the new Jewish life is gradually covering them over without their perceiving it? — —

In Austria, meanwhile, the struggle of the Zionists and National Jews for the Jewish Curia goes on, waged with ever-growing energy. One must not conceal from oneself that even a victory or a partial success in this struggle will signify only one step forward. Nor will anyone deceive himself as to the fact that the work of a handful of Jewish deputies against an overwhelming majority, hostile or a-Semitic in temper, will demand a great and often vainly squandered outlay of courage, patience and energy. The granting of an internal Jewish autonomy, too, would set the Jews before grave problems. A people which has been systematically torn into a hundred pieces, forced into divers cultures, crammed full of all manner of alien habits and views — such a people certainly cannot easily transform its passive particularity into an active life of its own, even if one makes upon this life of its own only the relative demands of the "Golus". But wedged in among the tangle of the Austrian races, the Jews have only the choice either to duck and bend while the wheels turn, until in the end they are crushed none the less, or to fight their way through as Jews, at the risk of being set before ever new struggles, and perhaps also of losing here and there one of the crumbs which the gentlemen of "Toleration" used formerly to throw to the Jews. In return, however, even the smallest thing the National Jews win will represent a real gain, and, if not materially, then at least morally, will strengthen Judaism in a quite extraordinary manner.

This function is what the old back-stairs men call the restoration of the Ghetto — the gentlemen who now, as once their great-grandfathers or grandfathers in the Polish villages, "cry 'Trade, buy, trade' in the palace of the Polish Club". And they already feel content if in strange courtyards the dogs do not growl at them. There was a Jewish law that the slaves who in the seventh year would not take the freedom offered them, and preferred to remain at the slaves' table in their master's house, should have their ears pierced. Who does not call to mind Heinrich Heine, who once invoked Mosche Rabbenu, our "great master", to swing a giant hammer and bore through all those slaves' ears?

THE PRESENT SITUATION OF ZIONISM

Speech delivered in Glasgow by L. J. GREENBERG.

On the occasion of the annual meeting of the English Zionist Federation, which took place in Glasgow on Sunday, Mr. L. J. Greenberg, at a mass meeting held in the evening, delivered an hour's speech on the present Jewish situation, on the progress of Zionism, and on the relation of Zionism to other Jewish parties, in particular to Territorialism.

Mr. Greenberg first set forth that some had feared a decline of Zionism from the death of Theodor Herzl. They were mistaken: "The obituary of Zionism can be written only on the day of its final triumph. Even then it will not die; it will merely pass out of the realm of possibility into that of reality. 'Men may come and men may go, but I go on for ever,' so it was written of the brook, and the source of Zionism lies in a constant, never-failing stream . . . Herzl built his organisation upon a more lasting foundation than that of his own personality. That is what has never become clear to our opponents. The new leadership could not and would not enter into any comparison with Herzl, but he was of opinion that in the person of the present President a good choice had been made. Mr. Greenberg then spoke at length of the difficulties the new leadership had had to overcome and how well it had overcome them. He next made mention of the reorganisation of the Organisation and the resumption of political work. "The threads have been taken up again," he says, "and we have reason to expect that in the near future we shall see a resumption of what in the language of diplomacy is called 'relations'. So one may place the best hopes in the present leader of the movement . . . It has proved possible to refute the shameful lie which has been zealously spread in certain circles, namely, that the Zionist movement has in any case been hampered, and its original aim diminished, by the resolutions adopted at the last Congress, or the manifest folly lately uttered by Mr. Lucien Wolf — who, whenever an opportunity offers to say something grandly foolish, never lets slip the distinction of uttering it — that Zionism lies in ruins. If our movement had come out of the Congress hampered and weakened, if our courage had sunk and our perseverance diminished, the resolutions then adopted would not have been to blame. It would have been due to the fact that the petty spirit of Ghetto politics still ruled some Zionists, who, when they saw themselves beaten, when they found that their views were shared by only a small minority, set about on the spot founding a new organisation, whose activity has been confined to putting the resolutions of the Congress in a false light, to slandering the movement, to hindering our work and to paralysing our forces Was there the slightest ground for such a course of conduct, which stood in such contradiction to their assurance, so often and so loudly repeated, that they were faithful to Zionism, and to their constant assertion that they were nevertheless adherents of our movement? . . .

One particular point to which I should like to draw your attention with regard to the last Congress is that the whole Congress resolved that, should it be found necessary for our purposes to carry on active colonisation by Jews, such colonisation should be carried on either in Palestine or in the neighbouring lands. In either case the field of our activity was no narrow one, for, as Dr. Max Nordau lately pointed out in a letter to the "Times", the resolution of the Congress which designated Palestine and the neighbouring lands for purposes of colonisation referred to a territory capable of sustaining 200 millions of inhabitants, a population five times as great as that of the United Kingdom, and 200 times greater than the number which the greatest optimist has ever estimated of Jews who, under the most favourable conditions, would settle within any foreseeable time in any colony whatsoever. How dare people venture to assert that the resolutions of the last Congress have hampered and diminished the original aims of the movement, simply because a territorial limit has been set to our colonising activity. They are like the Jew who was once reproached by another Jew for having eaten pork, and who answered: "Well, a man must eat something!" . . .

The speaker then continues:

Ladies and Gentlemen, I have pointed to some of the difficulties under which the new leadership took up the duties laid upon it by the Congress. They were chiefly internal difficulties. But we had scarcely been able to do more than the ordinary routine work connected with the resolution of the Congress, when a calamity, without parallel in our days and never surpassed in the past in extent and effect, broke over our people. A fearful massacre of Jews took place in Russia, where, chiefly through the war in which fortune so greatly