8 — DIE WELT — No. 2
(continued from page 7)
…of new massacres of Jews. The papers no longer comment on them, people no longer protest; they are, so to speak, the order of the day. The Russian Government does its part: nothing for the Jews, nothing against the pogroms. Nor does it any longer fear the protests of the whole civilised world. The "Black Hundred" strides unswervingly towards its goal, the extermination of the whole of Jewry. Who knows what catastrophes still await Russian Jewry? Who will avert them?
NATIONAL POLITICS OR CLASS POLITICS.
by S. DUBNOW.
When a people politically dependent but inwardly free must pursue its own line in politics and strive for the most perfect possible harmony between its national interests and the general interests of the State, the question arises: "Can national politics be reconciled with class politics? By "class politics" we do not understand the struggle waged by the working classes against capitalism in defence of their legitimate economic interests. This struggle is necessary by virtue of the iron laws of life, and will not be ended until the rights of labour are recognised in their full extent. This struggle, in its normal course, is waged with success by way of trade-union organisations and strikes (England), or through the influence of the working classes upon legislation by parliamentary means, by way of universal suffrage (Germany). But the ideologists and leaders of the workers' party understand something else by "class politics." Their endeavour is to bring all the phenomena of political and national life under the category of class interests, of economics; to split the people into two hostile, irreconcilable parts: into bourgeoisie and proletariat, which would be economically divided and bound to one another by nothing. Their endeavour is to set the economic factor at the head of the historical process and to subordinate to it the whole social and intellectual development in its boundless variety. But this is not the place to prove the theoretical untenability of the doctrine of "historical materialism," which, to be sure, has found an especially large number of adherents in a people whose whole history stands in glaring contradiction to it. But however we may always have regarded such a doctrine, one thing is clear: it negates every other policy, the national included.
By "national politics" is understood a policy directed towards the preservation and development of the entire people as a whole, as a culturally and historically indivisible unity. It becomes especially intense in a people that is protected neither by an independent territory nor by a political organisation of its own, and that forms a minority among other, politically stronger nations. It becomes the highest guiding criterion in a people towards whom its stronger neighbours stand in a hostile relation, and which is oppressed and persecuted as an alien national body. The Jewish people has been in this situation for many centuries and will have to remain in it long yet, under the various degrees of oppression. In Russia this pressure and the perils bound up with it have reached the greatest tension that is possible at all in modern times, and should logically have called forth a corresponding tension of national energy, a unanimous national policy. But what do we see in reality? Instead of guiding our politics by the interests of the whole nation, which is threatened by the greatest danger, we are forced into class politics, which tear the whole asunder and set partial economic interests in its place. The battle-cry: "Proletarians of all countries, unite," is uttered by Jews at a moment when, for the rescue of the people, one ought to have cried unceasingly: "Jews of all classes and parties, unite!" Doctrinaire economic monism has destroyed the understanding of the interconnection of the people's interests, confused the inner life of men, and killed the natural feeling of brotherly solidarity among the members of a nation which has travelled its three-thousand-year historical road with an unbelievable heroism.
When class politics gains the upper hand within a strong nation enclosed by the iron ring of territory, of State organisation, or even of extensive local autonomy, one may regard this as a mistake, a one-sidedness, but not as a danger to the integrity of the nation. But when this policy of class strife is followed by the working masses of a people that is held together merely by cultural-national interests, and that at every step runs the risk of being swallowed up by the peoples surrounding it, then it is no longer a mistake and a one-sidedness, but a crime, because it brings in its train the disintegration of the people. We see, for instance, that the Poles, who are bound together by community of territory and of language and who expect a local political autonomy in the near future, pursue in the main a national policy and stand above all for the interests of the whole nation. We Jews, on the other hand, who lack territorial unity and can count at most upon a cultural, but never upon a political, autonomy, renounce national defence, even in the moment of the highest danger, and send our fighting bands into the camp of the general proletariat.
Thus class politics, even when it cloaks itself in the little mantle of a particular nationality (as, for example, with the "Bund"), cannot be national, since it necessarily sacrifices the interests of the people to the interests of the class. What platform, then, is called for at the present moment, upon which the Jews, taking part in the general work of the State in the revolutionary or the creative direction, could systematically carry through their own national policy.?
This platform is that of political democracy, or more exactly of the Constitutional-Democratic Party, which all the sound and politically mature elements of Russian society are joining. Through the association of ideas which has taken especially deep root in Russian Jewry in the course of the last quarter of a century, the conception of the old autocratic police régime is inseparably bound up with the conception of the most infamous Jew-hatred, of the shameful oppression of a people of six millions. A return to this régime means the ruin of our people; the struggle against this régime and its inheritance is the condition of our self-preservation. A Conservative-Monarchist party, which may well be possible among the "ruling nation," could not take root among the Jews; it would be minimal and must perish of exhaustion. Not merely by virtue of our dominant political temper, but also by virtue of our national interests, we must stand on the ground of constitutional democracy. This, in its ver-
