Die Welt · Vol. IX, Separate Edition 4 · 1 August 1905
11printed page
scan 11 of 16

No. 4 Separate Edition — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 11

(continued from page 10)

…laborators in Palestine and outside it had had at our disposal. We hold it our duty to render special thanks at this point to the following gentlemen: the agronomist A. Aronsohn, the geologist Dr. M. Blankenhorn, the agronomist E. Kraus, Mr. E. Saphir and the engineer Treidel.


Remarks by Prof. Dr. Warburg on the Report.

Gentlemen! Now that you have received from the lips of Dr. Soskin a detailed report on the activity of the Palestine Commission, I take the liberty, by way of opening the debate, of laying before you some general and then also some programmatic points of view concerning the tasks of the Palestine Commission and of Palestine work in general, which, as I would remark at once, represent my personal views. They are, it is true, for the most part shared by the other members of the Palestine Commission as well, and certainly also by many members of the Actions Committee; yet each will doubtless find one thing or another in them to object to. All the more fruitful, however, will the debate upon them, it is to be hoped, become, whereas concerning the positive activity of the Commission hitherto there will naturally be but little to say.

This only do we hope to have achieved by our two years' activity: that even the most ardent purely political Zionist will acknowledge that such work as the Palestine Commission has taken in hand is absolutely necessary and indispensable to the party. To neglect it means nothing else than to postpone it to the time after the obtaining of the Charter; but it is clear that one will not then have much time for protracted studies. If, therefore, one does not wish to run a great risk by undertaking through the Charter tasks on a grand scale whose import one does not know and whose foundations one has not studied, one must already beforehand, that is to say now, have made oneself acquainted and familiar with the whole body of practical Palestine questions.

But the obtaining of the Charter, too, will assuredly be rather facilitated than impeded by taking in hand the economic work in Palestine that is possible even now. Zangwill's view, that the Sultan, if people are already so foolish as to work for him now, will take care not to grant them rights, suffers from a logical error. It would be correct if the question were of a small field of work — I mean, of an estate which was already being worked now quite voluntarily without a legal contract. Here, however, the question is of an entire country, and what we can begin there even now is, in proportion to what is possible, only a minimal fraction. Here the saying holds good: "Appetite comes with eating." Once the Sultan sees what we can do, and what we accomplish for the benefit of the country, he will be the more readily accessible to our wishes, and so likewise will the Powers that are to support us in obtaining the Charter. In my firm conviction, we can only expect to obtain a Charter when we shall have laid the foundations of economic work in Palestine, to which we can then point in our political work. Only positive work already accomplished can procure us the necessary credit with the various Powers. So long as we merely protest our good will without being able to point to deeds, we shall be preaching to deaf ears, and shall find neither belief on the part of Turkey nor confidence on the part of the Great Powers.

The opponents of this view seek to disparage present-day work in Palestine as petty, and put it on a level with the feeble doings of the Chowewe-Zion; they deny that it is capable of materially furthering our chief aim, the obtaining of the Charter; indeed, they say, it may perhaps even be harmful, since it deludes the Zionists with an appearance of success and so diverts them from the work directed towards the chief aim.

But is it not, then, a general truth that before beginning a thing one first studies it, and, when one has sufficiently investigated it, first tries it out on a small scale?

The title-deed that we possessed Palestine 2000 years ago is not in itself and alone effective enough with the Powers; we must create for ourselves modern titles as well, and these consist in our furnishing the proof that, if not de jure, yet de facto, Palestine is economically subject to our influence, and that all the essential major advances of the country owe their origin to our initiative and to our economic resources.

Here I must also protest energetically against the view, sometimes expressed, that without a Charter everything in Turkey is insecure, and that any work there could be wiped out by a single stroke of the pen. I have no wish whatever to sing the praises of Turkish justice; but that flagrant breaches of the law, such as the seizure of real property, the closing of factories, the dissolution of settlements, the destruction of plantations on the part of the Government, occur more frequently in Turkey than in other States, has yet to be proved; and against states of war, revolutions, civil wars, etc., a Charter is of no avail either.

That the economic penetration of the Jews into Palestine is to the advantage of the country, the Turkish Government already perceives, and will at all times favour it, so long as it does not entertain the apprehension of thereby furthering the invasion of other Great Powers or of rearing a politically separatist population there. It is our first and most important task always and everywhere to work enlighteningly in this direction, and to emphasise that the administrative autonomy which we strive for has nothing to do with political desires for separation. Equally important for us, however, is to prove not only in theory but also in practice that we are by no means abetting any one of the rival Great Powers in Palestine; and this we can easily show by, on the one hand, giving preference to the Jews of Turkish nationality in Palestine, and, on the other, in the economic undertakings in which we take part, conceding to no European Great Power a predominant position, in future as hitherto.

What has brought the work of the Chowewe Zion into discredit is not the goal of their activity, but the manner in which they sought to attain it. The principle of charity is not capable of achieving great things unless the means are quite extraordinarily vast, as for example with the J. C. A.; and all the less so when the money is frittered away without plan, as has hitherto mostly been the case with the Chowewe Zion societies. The Palestine work of the Zionists moves in quite other grooves than that of those societies. Pity, charity, personal relief are foreign conceptions here; here the question is always only of organisation, examples, experiments, the creation of foundations for private initiative, participation in large-scale