Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Special Edition No. 3
President Dr. Nordau: A polemic does not seem to me in place here, since Mr. Gibbons is not in a position to defend himself.
Wilbuschewitsch: I should merely like to sum up by saying that my report was misunderstood. I consider the territory very favourable, but only for nomadic peoples.
Israel Zangwill is thereupon given the floor, and was received with stormy applause. (The speech has already been published in No. 2.)
After Zangwill, Sir Francis Montefiore is given the floor.
Sir Francis Montefiore (warmly greeted). (Noise on the left, cries of: Out! Noise and tumult, on the right likewise noise, which subsides only after some time.)
Presiding Vice-President Dr. Alexander Marmorek: Gentlemen stewards! What is at stake here is the dignity of the platform. Sir Montefiore asks for the floor, and I beg you to hear him.
Sir Francis Montefiore (in English, Dr. Weitzmann translating word for word into German). I hold it a great honour to be the first who stands in absolute opposition to the resolution of Mr. Zangwill. I have also the honour to state that I am deeply devoted to the great national movement, in that I set great value upon a well-conceived scheme of colonisation, and attach the greatest value to the proposal of the British Government. At the same time my heart is turned towards the Holy Land, which will ever remain the Promised Land of the Jews. I believe that my view rests more upon feeling than upon mere considerations of reason; but I believe also that we must have both. In order to colonise a country it is necessary that the soil and the climate be favourable; but besides these things it is necessary also that there exist a love for the land which is to be colonised. (Hear! hear!) How great the love of the Jewish people for the land of its fathers is, becomes evident when we cast a glance over the course of history. From the time, from the very moment, when we lost our independence, the Jewish people has ever turned towards the land of its fathers. When hard times broke upon Jewry, it was our consolation; when good times came, love for the ancestral land was the means that held the people together. Even before East Africa was brought before the Congress, it was the love of Zion that brought the Jews of all lands hither to this Congress. In former days very many Jews had the wish to go to Palestine to die there; now the number has grown of those who have the wish to go to Palestine to live there.
You have heard so often, when East Africa has been spoken against, that I was the one who voted for the dispatch of a Commission to East Africa. But if I did so, I did it only because our late Leader asked it of me.
As the translator's voice does not suffice for the great assembly, the Chairman, Dr. Marmorek, requests Dr. Magnus to translate the speech.
Sir Francis Montefiore: I should like to point out that the value of the East Africa offer was indeed real: it was, namely, a diplomatic gain, for it showed us once for all that a great Government such as the English has recognised the Jews as a nation, and the Zionists as the principal part of that nation. As to the fruitfulness and acceptability of the East Africa offer, I think it needless to say anything here, for that question has already been decided by the Commission that was sent out. But I should like, if you will permit me, to point out once more that Palestine is a country fitted to serve commercial and agricultural purposes (Applause). As regards the constituents of its soil, Palestine is by no means barren, and the poor condition of Palestine has come about only through the neglect of agriculture. It is well known that the best authorities hold Palestine to be a country which could be developed quite well. Since I last had the honour of speaking before the Congress, I have had the satisfaction of making the acquaintance of Colonel Conder, who is the best living authority on Palestine. (Hear!) I have been informed that it is the wish of the Chairman that we should not now broach the question of Palestine. That question lies very near; but I would only say that when the East Africa question has been decided, all Zionists must work together, so that our work may succeed.
It has always seemed to me that if at bottom we have the same feelings, we can surely work together, and that we must always take the views of the parties into account. I would recall that we have a great task, and that we shall be destroyed if we do not work together. I know that there are many speakers who will speak upon this question, and I think one can render the assembly the best service by making one's own remarks as brief as possible. (Quite right.) In closing I would remark only this: that it is my hope that those who have the welfare of the people at heart will endeavour to work out a common basis for common work (Applause), and that you will not be led astray thereby by the assertion that there are different kinds of Jews and that the Jews cannot work together on a common basis. I know quite well that there are various differences among Jews, but they are only accidental differences of station and of wealth; for are we not all children of the same race and worshippers of the same faith? (Great applause.) We are one, and in the name of this unity I would wish that our work may succeed. (Loud applause.)
Chairman Dr. Marmorek: In the translation of Mr. Greenberg's speech the following passage was omitted, which reads:
Allow me to express to our noble friend the deepest thanks of the Congress for the great and unselfish help which he has rendered us by making possible the dispatch of the expedition. All the deeper is the shame that we were dependent upon non-Jews. But the deeper this shame, the greater the glory of the help. A condition, however, is attached to the offer, that the giver remain absolutely anonymous. I received permission only to name the name to two persons who are officially connected with our movement. (Applause.)
Chairman Dr. Nordau: 120 speakers have entered their names on the East Africa question. It will surely be clear to you that 120 speakers cannot have the floor. For this matter alone we should need at least 20–25 sittings. It is there-
