Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 52 · 29 December 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 21

No. 52. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7.


(continued from page 6)

…will certainly never be able to make up their minds, a Jewish representation is in its place. Otherwise a million and a half Jews, as such, remain without effective parliamentary protection, without spokesmen, without share in legislation and in the control of administration. And yet it is precisely the Jews who would need such things most of all and most often. It is not the number of Jewish seats, nor the names of their probable holders, that gives its stamp to the question now raised of a Jewish-national curia, but the principle of national equality of rights and of national recognition. If we Jews are not to remain step-children, second-class, inferior citizens of this Empire, then a Jewish-national representation is our due, without regard to groups and interests of other nationalities, for which we have stood up long and self-sacrificingly enough.

* * *

"In recognition of the indispensable necessity that, for the purpose of realising and defending the true and complete equality of rights of the Jews, there should sit and vote, both in the Reichsrat and in the Diet, such a number of Jewish deputies as corresponds to the numbers, intelligence and taxpaying power of the Jewish population, but also in recognition of the fact that national-Jewish separatism would be ruinous both for the country and for the civic position of the Polish Jews, the Jewish deputies are charged to direct all their care to obtaining, in the electoral reform for the Chamber of Deputies and respectively for the Diet, the creation of such electoral districts as correspond to the realisation of this purpose." This resolution is the fruit of a deliberation of the Jewish deputies to the Reichsrat and the Diet, together with Jewish men of trust from Galicia, held in Lemberg on the 26th of December. Herr Dr. Byk, who presided, drummed the meeting together under the pressure of the national excitement kindled in the country, in order to work against the Zionists. The resolution is neither cold nor warm. The gentlemen content themselves with demanding a division of electoral districts that will secure them their seats; the national-Jewish demand they reject. All the same, this meeting and its crafty resolution are a noteworthy success of the Zionist propaganda hitherto. It cannot remain unnoticed in authoritative quarters. In Galicia the Ruthenians too, in all their meetings, champion the national autonomy of the Jews — for obvious egoistic reasons, it is true, but entirely in the Jewish-national sense. The Lemberg meeting is also to be set down to the account of this agitation, which dominates Eastern Galicia. Dr. Byk and his like are not authoritative arbiters of the civic position of the Polish Jews, because they deliberately and selfishly falsify their national position and their political interests, and thus endanger their moral structure. The resolution of fear of the frightened All-Polish house-Jews and of their helpers detached from the provinces will avail nothing. The struggle has begun and will be fought out.


National Autonomy and the Jews in Austria.

The excellent address on the above subject which Dr. Natan Birnbaum delivered at the mass meeting of the 12th of December, and which, as an admirable means of agitation, surely deserves to be put into print, will be capable of dispelling and removing numerous mistaken notions and prejudices with which opponents and the indifferent operate in order to make an earnest and important national cause appear ridiculous and petty. And it can only further the political action initiated by the Zionists, as the theoretical foundation for practical work of agitation, in the press and fullness of which, it is to be hoped, the great question of securing our national existence will not leave behind it merely the far smaller concern about the division of constituencies and the number of seats. We give today an extract from the speech:

After explaining the conception of national autonomy in general, Dr. Birnbaum turns to the application of the principle to the Jews. First of all he claims for those who feel themselves to be Jews by nationality "the personal right of national self-determination." In national confession, quite as in religious confession, the personality is sovereign.

For the domain of Eastern Jewry it is impossible to deny away the national differences between the Jews and the peoples among whom they dwell. The Eastern Jews do not even lack the factor of a language of their own, so that for five-sixths of the Austrian Jews not even the superficial objection of the want of a language of their own could be raised.

Passing on to Western Jewry, the speaker deals first with the development of the idea of assimilation and demonstrates its retrogression in the last decades. The Jewish national idea advances, if very slowly, yet steadily. It penetrates more and more into the middle class, the educated and those among the intellectuals. Of the latter, only those members of the Jewish race offer resistance who here in the West fight at the head or in the front ranks of the social movement, particularly of Social Democracy. "I will not here express indignation at the light manner in which they quite needlessly sacrifice the honour and welfare of the Jewish race like a quantité negligeable. I will rather try to understand these men — how this levity, how their intolerance of the conception of the Jews as a nation, so often displayed of late, accords with their social earnestness in other matters." The speaker finds the explanation in this, that these voluntary proletarians, in their predominant occupation with economic questions, neglected the dogma of assimilation which they brought with them from the middle class, just as they neglected Judaism itself.

The speaker describes it as at once the saddest and the most amusing feature of the desperate resistance of socialist Jews in particular to the recognition of Jewish nationality, that they have as yet no feeling for the contradiction in which they thereby stand to the idea of national autonomy which they themselves advocate so warmly. This contradiction reveals itself best in the argument to which they mostly appeal, the want of a contiguous territory and of a language. Since it is precisely the purpose of national autonomy to preserve scattered nationalities from senseless sufferings and the native ones from senseless deeds of violence, then the Jews, who stand most in need of the benefit of national autonomy, are the very last who may