Page 8 — "Die Welt" — No. 47
(continued from page 7)
...served separatist ideas. That is you, radical "Russ," which for a long time devoted full attention to the national questions in Russia (the Polish, the Armenian) without wasting a word on the fact that one of the most fateful national questions in Russia is the Jewish question . . . . That is the editor of the "Russ," who, on being asked why he does not write about the Jews, answered: It was he who had once written the spiteful articles against the Jews in his father's antisemitic periodical, the "Novoye Vremya," because he had believed that the Jews bore the blame for all the misfortune that had befallen Russia. Later, to be sure, he had come to the conclusion that the general political distress bore the blame for Russia's troubles, and had changed his attitude towards the Jews. But to write on the Jewish question in particular he finds unnecessary, since he holds the Jewish question to be a part of the general Russian question, etc., etc.
To blame, further, were all the radical and liberal elements who did not know their own people, who would hear nothing of what Jews foretold in fear and foreboding: that on the outbreak of a revolution in Russia the people would throw itself upon the Jews. In their agitation, in their propaganda, in their word to the Russian people they forgot the greatest, most fateful prejudice of this people: forgot the wild hatred of the Jews.
Even now, after what has already happened, the liberal "Nasha Zhizn" writes only of Russian brethren who are being murdered.
As if they feared to call the thing by its right name! Yes, there were Russians too who fell victims; many of the best sons of the Russian people have sacrificed their lives for the fatherland. But what shakes us, what has hurled us into the depths of despair, is the murdering, the slaughtering, the plundering of the Jewish masses on the part of the people, on the part of the masses, in which not only "hooligans" but (we must confess it to ourselves) workmen, burghers, merchants, peasants took part. That is the people that has sucked in the poison of hatred of the Jews, or of contempt for the Jews, from many voluntary educators of the people.
But they, the progressive elements, misjudged the scope of this danger, and stood indifferent and cold towards the organisations of the Jews which aimed at self-defence.
If there is retribution for this, the moment for it is now drawing near. The wild instincts that have been let loose against the Jews are now beginning to turn against the progressive elements in the Russian people. Only now have the Russians grasped what danger lies in the unchaining of the beast; only now have voices been raised calling for the organisation of the self-protection of the revolutionaries against the reactionary masses of the people. Only now are Christians and Jews coming together in joint committees to organise the defence. We do not wish that the great historic sin which Russian society has committed against us should avenge itself upon that society. But never shall we be able to forget that at the moment of the greatest national danger we were alone or almost alone; never (even when a better future shall one day send us its light) shall we be able to reconcile ourselves to the fact that Russia let all the shocks of its historical development pass with such devastating force through the body of our people.
The Jewish Self-Defence.
Under this title M. Sukennikow publishes in the "Voskhod," No. 42, an interesting and extremely instructive article, which we here wish to reproduce in brief. M. Sukennikow has travelled through most of the large and also the small towns of the Pale of Settlement and has everywhere studied the question of self-defence thoroughly.
The word "self-defence" was until recently still a forbidden expression, and only with the greatest caution could meetings be held at which the question of self-defence was discussed. People usually assembled at the house of a family that stood above all suspicion with the police. There they deliberated, argued and debated. On such long evenings, writes S., I often met courageous, self-sacrificing Jewish youths; I saw how their eyes glowed, how their fists clenched with rage, how they longed with their whole soul to protect their Jewish brethren.
The telegraphic reports published during the calamitous days of terror, on which Jewish blood once again flowed in streams, give us scant tidings of the part that the Jewish self-defence played in them. Nevertheless, so much is already known, that in a whole series of towns there was a Jewish self-defence which intervened actively and courageously defended Jewish houses and Jewish property. And yet, in spite of this courageous, self-sacrificing self-defence of the Jews, there were so many victims in the last massacres, called "pogrom." The cause is to be sought precisely in this, that the Jewish self-defence is as yet not sufficiently organised. Until the excesses in Zhitomir there was among the Jews in every town not merely one self-defence, but two or three, sometimes even four or five self-defence parties, according to the number of factions and parties into which the Jewish youth was divided. The Zionists had their own organisation of a self-defence, the Socialist Revolutionaries another; the same held of the Bundists and of the Social Zionists, who by no means wished to be confused with the Poale Zionists active in the same place. In a word, all the party quarrels and dissensions had been carried over into the field of Jewish self-defence. Not a single group would go hand in hand with another. The Social Democrats held it beneath their dignity to come to terms with the Zionists, and would have nothing to do even with the Social Zionists, etc.
In consequence, the organisations of the individual self-defences differed from one another, and the measures of one self-defence often damaged the strategic plans of another organisation. During the Zhitomir pogrom, however, the situation changed all at once. At that time all the parties, in the face of danger, had joined together into a single great self-defence, and the results which this self-defence achieved through its tenacity, through the courage of its members, astonished the whole world. The organisation in Zhitomir showed plainly that for systematic, successful action unity and unanimity are required above all. The Jewish self-defence might now have justified fine hopes, and these hopes would also have been fulfilled had the pogroms not set in anew with so threatening, so elemental a force, and that precisely at the time when freedom had been proclaimed and when massacres of Jews were least expected. Had even one year of quiet passed, a systematic procurement of arms for the Jewish self-defence could have been organised, and the individual members of the self-defence associations could have been instructed in shooting. But scarcely a few weeks and months had passed since in individual centres people seriously to the