No. 47 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5
Letters of assent had further been received from Lord Rothschild, Lord Hereford, from the Archbishops of Canterbury and Westminster, the Bishops of London and Rejon, the Chief Rabbi, the well-known champion of peace W. T. Stead, various Members of Parliament and many other eminent men of English public life. President Wolffsohn had sent the telegram already known to our readers, and the following letter from Max Nordau was read: "In England, in Germany, in France, the leaders of the communities, our profound diplomatists, have proclaimed the oracle: the problem of the Russian Jews must be solved in Russia. The Russian Government, army and police are evidently of the same opinion and have set about solving the Jewish question in Russia in their own fashion, very radically, to be sure: by the complete extermination of all the Jews they can lay hands upon, with the application of hellish tortures before the murder. What will our wise men say now? Of course, they will give money liberally for the maimed, the widows, the orphans, the ruined, for they have a kind heart and an open hand, even if they possess blind eyes. But will they do anything to make such atrocities, when they have been committed throughout Russia, impossible? After Kishineff they gave money, but this did not stop Odessa, Kieff, Ekaterinoslav, and after Odessa, Kieff and so forth they will give money without being able to prevent the periodic recurrence of such heart-rending events. I must ask pardon for quoting my own words. More than two years ago, on the 24th of August 1903, I said in a speech at the Sixth Zionist Congress at Basle: 'Until now there has been no trace of a strategic idea or of a general plan in our defence. It has always consisted only of isolated skirmishes of the cavalry of St. George: pounds, shillings, pennies to the front. That is the Jewish national policy. When Jewry lately had to answer the bloody attacks of Kishineff, £80,000 sterling were collected within a few weeks; our rich men dipped deep into their pockets. The money was sent to the sufferers, to whom it was said: "Here is money! And now stay where you are and keep quiet." And our rich men turned to our armed, devilish friends and spoke to them: "So, you murder, you destroy. Very good. Here is money to provide for the widows and orphans, to heal the wounded and the sick, and to make good the destroyed furnishings and the plundered goods. After a short pause you will destroy the renewed furnishings again, carry off the fresh goods again, murder once more, make cripples of others, rob other families of their breadwinners. We shall send fresh money. We shall see who will tire first, you of murdering or we of giving money."' These words I spoke two years ago, and today I can only repeat them. We deserve the worst ill-treatment with which antisemites have ever heaped us, if after an atrocity that stands without example in modern history we confine ourselves to an alms. Truly, we must bury our dead, heal our maimed, shelter our homeless, feed our hungry, clothe our naked. This is the first and most urgent necessity, and verily it will cost us almost superhuman exertions to meet the most pressing needs. But when this has been done, we must not stop. The dignity of our race, our honour as a people and as men, demands of us inexorably that we place the Russian Jews in such a position that they are no longer given over to ruin, to shame and to an ignominious death. Out with them from the Russian hell! Let us give them a new home, with security of life and honour, in Palestine and the neighbouring lands. They need it, they cry to Heaven for it, and it is certainly possible, even though it is very difficult. If the Jews of the free countries would devote to this just purpose only half the money they spend in vainly seeking to better what cannot be bettered, every Jew whose bloody body now lies in the streets of Odessa would have been in possession of his own vineyard, under his own fig-tree, a blessing to himself, his family and his old-new land, and a pride to those Jews in the other lands who had enabled him to be a free and happy husbandman. Jews of the Old and the New World! Do not let the terrible lesson of these last days be lost upon you once again."
Israel Zangwill wrote: "Nothing would keep me from your meeting but the strict order of my physician that, if I go to your meeting, I shall not be able to attend my own. Bound alike as I felt myself both to Zionism and to Territorialism (and indeed for me Zionism is only one form of Territorialism), I nevertheless find myself compelled to husband my strength for the meeting at which I am announced as a speaker tomorrow evening. My Zionist friends will be glad to hear that at our meeting in the Great Assembly Hall a long and important letter from Joseph Chamberlain to Max Langermann will be read, in which he once more devotes words of the highest esteem to our late leader Dr. Herzl."
Claude G. Montefiore regrets that he is prevented from appearing in person, and with the Jews of every religious or political shade deplores the cruel events in Russia. Oswald J. Simon writes that he does not stay away from today's meeting perhaps because he is not a Zionist, for at the present moment all differences must vanish, and Zionists and non-Zionists must stand up together for their poor, persecuted brethren in Russia.
Similar letters and telegrams had moreover been received from Prof. Israel Gollancz, Miss Carmel Goldsmid, the daughter of the late Colonel Goldsmid, and many others, and were greeted on their reading with lively demonstrations of applause. Nordau's letter and Wolffsohn's telegram in particular were received with enthusiasm.
The Chairman then welcomed the meeting, pointing to the sad occasion of it. The first impulse, he said, was naturally to try to relieve the unspeakable misery with money. But although contributions were coming in abundantly, it was becoming more and more generally clear that the giving of money did not suffice. As good Jews and logically thinking men, one must endeavour to do something to prevent a repetition of such terrible events. The conviction that the solution of this problem could be found in Zionism alone was spreading more and more. With a call for unity in the present grievous time the Chairman closed his address of welcome, and the floor was given to Dr. Gaster, who was greeted with loud applause.
Dr. Gaster moved the following resolution: "This meeting gives expression to its deepest horror and its indignation at the massacres and outrages which our brethren in Russia have had to endure. It pledges all present to show their sympathy in a practical manner with the victims of brutal passions, and has firm confidence that civilisation will universally condemn this latest calamity that has befallen Jewry. The meeting is firmly convinced that our people will not be secure against the repetition of such catastrophes until a legally secured and publicly recognised home in Palestine has been obtained for the Jewish people."
