Page 8 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 38
The Chairman: Mr. Neumann will tell you exactly.
The Secretary: Mr. Armitstead and Mr. Lewis have said that, if you do not confirm to-day the resolutions which were passed on the 1st inst., you must begin this matter quite afresh. The whole proceedings are then closed; you cannot continue them on another day. You must either adopt and confirm the resolutions or, if you do not confirm them to-day, the matter is ended and you must begin anew; this fact cannot be ignored. This is the legal opinion, which is perfectly clear and plain.
Mr. Bentwich: In order to make my position in this matter clear, I venture to ask you, on a point of order, whether my resolution is now formally before the meeting for decision; for in reply to the communication just made to us by the Secretary I should now like to say that I personally am quite ready to take the risk, and probably the certainty, that the opinions which you have received orally will also be confirmed, although it is of course impossible to give a definite opinion on this matter without first having looked into the Articles. The point which I should particularly like to clear up here is this: that even if the adjournment of this meeting renders void the proceedings which have taken place hitherto, we are then still entitled to hold a new meeting at once, and if need be to convene a second meeting for the purpose of confirmation, in order to give effect to the wishes of the Basle Congress. There would be no difficulty in that.
The Chairman: Yes, certainly, I think so too.
Mr. Bentwich: I would rather run this risk than the other.
Mr. Kopolovitch: Mr. Chairman, I shall speak Yiddish, because the majority here will understand it. (Mr. Kopolovitch speaks and puts a motion in Yiddish.)
The Chairman: I cannot accept that.
Mr. Kopolovitch: Why not?
The Chairman: The reason why I cannot accept your motion is that we can here only either confirm or reject the resolutions; and your motion is neither a confirmation nor a rejection of the resolution, and I cannot allow you to bring forward here anything which is neither the one nor the other, now that we are discussing a resolution which is concerned simply with the adjournment of this meeting. You move the adjournment of the meeting; you give all the reasons mentioned and many others which you do not mention. There are perhaps many others with many other reasons; we, however, have nothing to do with these reasons; these reasons do not touch this question at all.
Mr. Levy speaks in Yiddish.
Mr. Shelovitsky also speaks in Yiddish.
The Chairman: If this meeting is adjourned, an Extraordinary General Meeting like the one at Basle, and a second for the purpose of confirmation like to-day's, must be convened once more. If this meeting is adjourned, two meetings must take place, an extraordinary one and one for the purpose of confirmation. To adjourn this meeting means, so far as legal advice is at our disposal, that the whole affair is at an end.
Mr. J. Moser: I am very anxious to keep this discussion within moderate bounds. It seems to me that a great number here do not know how we have come into this position. At the General Meeting at Basle we had a majority in the vote on the resolutions; I tell you this only in order to prove to you the fairness of it. In the vote on the second resolution we had a majority of 5360. I merely say this here; if we now reject these resolutions, what will be the consequences? I only wish to make the situation clear to you. The consequences will be that we should have to occupy ourselves with the whole matter again; we should have to begin once more; we should be compelled to do so. After all that I have heard and seen here, I am of opinion that we ought to vote. Vote, and let the vote stand; and if we find that we do not have the majority in the vote -- I must tell you that I am the only person who is entitled to demand a vote by ballot, and I shall demand it, I shall risk it; if the resolutions are rejected, we are in the same position as if we adjourn, or perhaps in a better one. In favour of adopting these resolutions are the Council of Administration, the Board of Directors and the Actions Committee; they are compelled to pursue the matter further; they must do so. Whether it will again go through all the stages and finally be laid before a General Meeting, that is another question; and now as regards the Founders' Shareholders, it is of them that I should now like to speak. They are morally bound. They are bound, further, for this reason: it is due only to an accident, an unforeseen accident, which yesterday, say an hour earlier than the present hour, was known to no one, that we do not have here to-day an overwhelming majority of votes. Do you now wish to take advantage of this accident? Do so, if it seems good to you; but I wish to enlighten you about it. And therefore I say that it would be much better that we should proceed to the vote at once, so that we may know where we stand here. It is not a question of the end of this matter. If it is rejected here to-day, it will be brought forward again. Whether it will then be adopted again is another matter; but it must come up again; therefore I should wish that those who have put the motion for adjournment would withdraw it, so that we may vote, in order to ascertain where we stand here. Let us dispute no longer, but ascertain where we stand. I am always content with a majority. I do not say that I personally count upon a majority this time, but I say that, as a responsible member, I am compelled to take the matter up again. Whether the matter will then go through is another question. (Applause.) I shall put a motion that we, without further discussion --
Dr. Max Bernstein: I second this motion.
A Shareholder: I withdraw my motion for adjournment.
A Shareholder: Mr. Lozinsky, will you obey the Chairman or not?
Amid loud interruption, the Chairman says: The motion has been made and seconded that the discussion be now closed.
Mr. Lozinsky: Do you believe that the majority of the members have understood the question put? (Cries of "Completely!")
The Chairman: That is a quite ridiculous and foolish question. Mr. Moser, I did not quite understand your motion; do you propose that the resolutions be submitted to the meeting for a vote, or the resolution concerning the adjournment of the meeting?
Mr. J. Moser: That we close the discussion and proceed to the vote on the resolution.
Dr. Max Bernstein: With regard to the motion which Mr. Moser made and I seconded, I only wished to say that this motion was that we do not adjourn but now vote.
