No. 38 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
…would such a vote take place after the meeting among the members in general, or would this vote be taken only among the shareholders present here? Would this vote be a general vote?
The Chairman: I really think that you are better able than I to answer this question. We shall do nothing that is unlawful. I cannot tell you that; you must know it better than I.
Mr. S. Lennox-Löwe: Mr. Chairman, I wish to ask, so that we may know it quite clearly: can the Founders' Shares be used at this meeting, or perhaps after this meeting, with the intention of influencing the decision of to-day's meeting?
The Chairman: Founders' Shares can be used only when they are in the hands of proxies of the Founders' Shareholders.
A Shareholder: May I propose that this meeting be adjourned to another day?
Mr. S. Lennox-Löwe: I second Mr. Bentwich's proposal.
Mr. Finkelstein: In view of the fact that the notice of this meeting has not been published in such a way that the majority of the shareholders have obtained knowledge of it, since they never read the "Times" and many of them are also unable to read the "Jewish World," I move the adjournment of this meeting for three months. Notice of this adjournment shall be given through the Jewish newspapers, so that all shareholders may be afforded the opportunity of casting their votes either in person or by proxy.
The Chairman: This motion is not admissible. We must either confirm or reject the resolutions; I cannot accept this proposal.
(Interruption.)
Mr. Auerbach speaks in Yiddish.
The Chairman: Mr. Auerbach, I think that before you go further into these matters you ought surely to take into consideration our position, in which we unfortunately find ourselves through the absence of Mr. Temkin, and let us make the attempt to consider what we have to do; then we may possibly occupy ourselves with the questions which you raise. Now as regards those persons who are shareholders of the Bank and who cannot be present here owing to the unsuitable hour of the meeting, I venture to remark that they can vote by proxy. We are at the moment going into matters into which we need not go. I think that everyone in this hall is anxious to remain true to the movement which created the Bank. (Hear! Hear!) I think that is the case. Instead of heated speeches and attacks from this or that person, we could surely do much better for our Bank, and for the movement, which is still far more important than the Bank, if we were to consider here how we could best help ourselves out of this painful position into which we have fallen through the illness of Mr. Temkin. Mr. Auerbach, I am sure that you, like everyone else in this hall, wish to do your utmost that nothing shall be done here which might be harmful either to the Bank or to the movement. This we can achieve only if we consider very carefully the position in which we now find ourselves.
Mr. Lozinsky: On a point of order! (Interruption and great uproar.)
The Chairman: Unfortunately I have to argue with everyone in this hall separately. You did not speak to a point of order. I shall probably soon have to argue with you too. Had Mr. Lozinsky paid attention to me, he would know that my words were addressed to Mr. Auerbach, because he really called forth these remarks, and they are, after all, really addressed to the meeting. I do not doubt that a number of those present would like to hear what I have to say at this moment. I wished particularly to tell you that, at least so far as my own person is concerned, I should wish by all means to avoid the vote becoming a chance vote. (Hear! Hear!) I should have set myself just as much against such a result if it concerned those who vote against as if it were a question of those who vote for the resolution. If we proceed to a vote at all, then let us take it only in an entirely honourable manner, and those of us who should then be in the minority would then at least have the satisfaction that the vote has been conducted fairly, that a majority was not permitted to be turned into a minority by some trifling accident. It is possible that I myself should find myself in the minority; I would ten thousand times rather be in the minority honourably than in the majority dishonourably. (Hear! Hear!) All that I now ask of you is that for the moment you occupy yourselves with no other point than how you can overcome this difficulty which the absence of Mr. Temkin has caused. In this respect the advice of Mr. Bentwich would be of the greatest value. He is a lawyer; it is possible that other lawyers are in the hall; or perhaps Mr. James H. Löwe can give us good advice. I hope he will do so; but let us keep to this point.
Mr. J. H. Löwe: You remarked that the adjournment of this meeting is attended with very great difficulties. I assure you, with all respect, that in my humble opinion you have in fact exaggerated the difficulties. In fact, we know from the result of the vote at the first meeting, which took place at Basle, that a considerable majority of the shareholders is in favour of the alterations; for this reason it is immaterial whether the meeting takes place to-day or after one, two or three months; we know that it is only a formality and that the resolutions must be adopted. Of that there is no doubt. (Interruption.) You said that if we adjourn this meeting we shall have to have Basle over again. I am of quite a different opinion. This meeting can quite calmly be adjourned in whatever way suits you best, let us say for a month or six weeks, and a meeting can be held here in this hall or in your office, and the whole proceedings would then need to last only some ten minutes to settle the entire matter. No debate need take place. The second meeting then takes place fourteen days later, and thereby nothing has been lost. If you do this, you relieve yourselves of the responsibility which now rests upon you, and we too escape all responsibility in this matter. I therefore second Mr. Bentwich's motion. I have nothing further to add, gentlemen. As soon as the motion for adjournment has been put, I shall gladly second it.
The Chairman: Before you proceed further, I should like Mr. Neumann to repeat what he has already told the meeting with regard to the question of adjournment; for I do not wish that the slightest doubt or the least uncertainty should prevail as to what we have advised you in this matter.
Mr. Bentwich: I understood that there was no written opinion.