Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 35 · 1 September 1905
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 35

(continued from page 5)

...rest, and I think we may well hope that, even if the Seventh Congress does not at once bring rest and peace into the ranks of the Zionists, it has nevertheless laid the foundation of agreement upon a matter which seriously disturbed the harmony of our organisation. Before I enter more closely upon this matter, however, I must here protest against the exaggerated — maliciously exaggerated — statements that have appeared in the English press concerning the proceedings during the Zionist Congress. I have always proudly held the view that the press of this great country had so high a conception of its position and dignity that it would under no circumstances sacrifice truth to the pursuit of sensation. And I am of that view still. But if this high conception is to be maintained, it is clear that the editors and conductors of newspapers must exercise the greatest care in the choice of their correspondents, especially where proceedings abroad are concerned, where it is difficult to check such reports. I am sorry to have to say that in regard to the Congress this care was evidently not exercised. The "Daily Chronicle" was, I think, the most to blame. There we were served with tales of scuffles and other excesses, of attempts to storm the platform, and of resistance offered by assembled roughs, all of which do discredit only to the reporter's imagination. Another newspaper, in its one and only report on the Congress, headed the article in question "Zionist Pandemonium." I have some experience of public political meetings in England where feeling ran very high, and I have witnessed scenes far more unbridled and far more suggestive of pandemonium than the wildest that took place at Basle — and those assembled there were not born with Anglo-Saxon coolness of blood. I need not remind you of the many excesses that have occurred in this country. I need not point to the broken-up meetings — and bloody heads — that were so frequent at the time of the Corn Law Agitation (agrarian laws), or, in more recent times, to Lary Mack, or to Mr. Lloyd George's flight under police protection by the back door of the Town Hall in Birmingham. In Parliament itself, stormier scenes have occurred in recent years than those which took place during the Zionist Congress. Quite lately the Speaker had to suspend the sitting because a Minister was persistently shouted down by the opposite party, and not so very long ago Tories who had given themselves up too unreservedly to the pleasures of the table had a skirmish in the House of Parliament. To this cause, at all events, the occurrences during the Congress could not be ascribed. There matters stood otherwise. Many of our delegates were able to reach Basle only after subjecting themselves for weeks to the utmost privations. Some, I was told, toiled many miles on foot; highly educated men did the most menial work merely to earn money enough to come to Basle. And a great number among them had escaped with their bare lives; the shadow of the "pogroms" lay over their homesteads and threatened the lives of their nearest and dearest. The minority who gave way to any excesses came to Basle with the feeling that the first opportunity to be offered our people of mitigating the living death whose daily and hourly victims they were was to be rejected. That minority came to Basle with the painful feeling that it had been made a minority by means that were not of the most just. When we take all these circumstances into consideration, when we tell ourselves that the majority cherished a lively and in many cases an almost fanatical fear that the work of their lives was to be destroyed, that their hopes, their ideals, their aspirations were to receive a blow from which they would never recover, and that this majority had carried off an overwhelming victory at the vote; when we take all these circumstances into consideration, we cannot complain of the outbursts of feeling that took place during the Congress. No correspondent who wished to offer his readers a truthful account of the proceedings would have exaggerated such excesses as may have occurred, but would have endeavoured to explain the local conditions, which were generally known. In fact the contrary has happened, and a false picture has been laid before the world, which in some cases, where there was no malice, was the result of gross and evident ignorance.

I said that I hope the Seventh Congress has at least laid the foundation for a full understanding of a question which has occupied us for two years. Perhaps I should have said: two or three questions. As regards East Africa, I see not the slightest occasion to alter the views I have often expressed in public concerning this offer. I do not doubt that, had the Congress made it possible to accept it, a benefit would have been conferred upon Jewry and an important step forward taken in the nationalisation of our people. M. Ussischkin says, in the letter read by the President, that there is neither victory nor defeat to record. I cannot agree with him. He has prepared and carried through a great victory, and has vanquished the shadow of a spectre. (Laughter.) For he and those who worked with him were under the delusion that what they had to combat was a supplanting of Zion by East Africa. I have always been opposed to this view and am so still. I deny that any such supplanting was ever contemplated or could ever have come about. Save in a few isolated cases, East Africa was never regarded as our goal, and I never shared the fear, which possessed so many, that East Africa would satisfy the national aspirations of our people. That was the spectre; now we come to the shadow. Long before the Congress — as soon as the report of the Expedition was published — it was obvious that the Congress could reasonably come to no other decision than the one recommended by the Actions Committee. For we were bound by the very wise conditions of the scheme which Herzl laid down in his letter of December 1903 to Sir Francis Montefiore. And the one condition that was lacking the whole time was public support for the scheme, either outside or inside the ranks of the Zionists. I do not think they will deny that I at least did my utmost to call this condition into being; but we were beaten not so much by opposition as by indifference. We had overestimated the Jewish spirit of the Jewish people.