Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 34 · 25 August 1905
6printed page
scan 6 of 20
Facsimile · scan 6 of 20
Scan of p. 6
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 34

We must direct attention most particularly to the important exposition of Dr. Leopold Kahn on the conditions of land tenure in Turkey. This chapter is one of the most important and most difficult of our problem. We cannot enter into it more closely, the more so as the lecture has appeared in print in "Die Welt." We would only once more call the attention of our fellow Zionists to the importance of this question, and in this place request the author to arrange for an offprint as a pamphlet, since it would well be able to remove many errors and misunderstandings. Of scientific rather than practical value are the further, highly interesting lectures of Professor Bertholet on the conditions of settlement in Palestine in Old Testament times, of Professor Marti on excavations and finds from Palestine, with lantern projections, and of our fellow Zionist Dr. Alfred Nossig on the agreement of modern agrarian principles with the Mosaic laws.

All the lectures, and especially those of Professors Warburg and Furrer, made a strong impression on those present and confirmed them in the conviction that the Zionist aspirations in Palestine can be realised. To all the lecturers, who made the holding of the courses possible, our heartiest thanks are offered in this place Wz.


On Strength.

By D. Salo.

The press of a party or of a movement is a good gauge of its strength; not only of its numerical extent, but often also of the moral and material strength of its adherents. To estimate the strength of a party one must at one time count the votes, at another weigh them. The vitality of an idea can rest as well upon the number as upon the quality of its champions. And the journalistic organs of a political tendency may found their existence either upon a wide circulation, or else their survival is rooted in the active and self-sacrificing interest of a smaller circle which provides their material support.

The growth of every political party is always paralleled by the growth of its press. The founding of a daily paper is, next to the attainment of parliamentary representation, one of the most coveted of political aims; for many a party or party movement which, owing to special circumstances, cannot well think of parliamentary representation, it is even the political aim to be striven for first. Social Democracy in Austria has repeatedly furnished full proof of these generally valid propositions. And the reawakening Jewish consciousness has brought forth daily papers in the Jewish centres of Russia and a daily paper in Galicia.

About a year and a half ago the "Liberals" in Galicia found themselves obliged to defend their skins. The Liberals were in the first place the Jewish Poles, who were being attacked from two sides at once. The All-Polish movement was spreading ever wider and gave the Jewish politicians clearly to understand that they had no business within Polish nationality; and the Jewry of the country left them in no doubt that it knew better ways than the everlasting begging errands after the favour of a Polish nation which, at the bottom of its soul, is not very friendly to the Jews. The chief organ of the Poles, the "Slowo Polskie," which had hitherto shown a certain consideration for its Jewish readers, began to adopt antisemitic airs more and more conspicuously, in the knowledge that it would not harm itself thereby with its Polish readers, that the whole Jews would not be surprised at it, and that the half-Jews, proud as they are, would not after all dare to stir.

But matters did not long rest there. So long as the Polish papers fell chiefly upon the poor Jews, it troubled the spokesmen of the Kahal, the Jewish deputies to the Diet and the Reichsrat, little enough. But then the assailants went after the well-to-do as well, began to pursue an economic policy, and then of course the electors were in danger. And when at last the gentlemen representatives themselves were asked what business they had, as Jews, to be constantly putting their word into Polish affairs, the distress was at its height. Now the assimilationists set about founding a paper of their own, the "Dzien."

The tactics were, of course, those of "defence." With every good argument they tried to show that the harmfulness of Jewry in Galicia was an invention of its enemies. The "Dzien" also met with a certain goodwill on the part of the Government in this, because the sharp tone of the All-Poles could not suit it, and because it did not wish to fall out with its Jewish deputies, who play a part in the Polish Club, nor with the Jewish financial and commercial world of Galicia, as reliable political elements. In the fact that the leading personages of the country listened to the paper lay also its sole importance for Jewry. For just as little as the Jews could give credence to the attacks of the antisemitic press were the antisemites inclined to follow the "Jew paper" on to the field of proofs and facts. But in those quarters which are officially bound to an appearance of objectivity it was at least known that against the attacks of the enemies of the Jews arguments did exist after all — however little heeded they might be. The existence of the defence paper at least prevented the lies from becoming truth by remaining uncontradicted. And the antisemitic assailants, too, became somewhat less bold in their calumnies when they saw that there was someone willing to rap them over the knuckles.

If, then, the "defence paper" was not wholly without use for Jewry, and was therefore supported to some extent from the Jewish side, for those who commissioned it it was nothing less than a necessity. It was their only mouthpiece, and they themselves had, after all, to believe in the force of their own reasoning: anything else would have meant disowning their whole fundamental conception of the relation of Jewry to the surrounding nations. If they did not defend assimilation with all their might, partly as a fact, partly as a possibility, they were undermining their own vital nerve. The end of their political position would then have been the natural consequence.

And now they have nevertheless let this paper die. Some weeks ago the "Dzien," after unspeakable torments, ended its existence. The editor, in a hopeful idealism and in a sorely disappointed confidence in the goodwill and in the moral and material strength of those for whom he entered the fight, made enormous personal sacrifices. For nearly two years he worked without drawing a heller of salary. He used up a small fortune that he had earned by hard journalistic work. Indeed, he even took liabilities upon himself to secure the last few numbers. But at last the hour struck when, without the help of those who would have been bound to give it, it could go on no longer. The paper of assimilation in Galicia has ceased.

How did this come about?