No. 32 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…has. It may well be made possible that from now on every volume of minutes contains such an index in an appendix.
I will not now enter upon the abundance of books which, as the publishers assert, must be missing from no Jewish table, but will only express one wish: there is still a lack of good literature for the young. I believe there is no more rewarding task for our poets and writers than to devote themselves more to this sorely neglected branch. That will be of immeasurable importance for our propaganda, for the youth of today, which grows up under every possible influence — at least with us in the West — except the Jewish, meets our endeavours from the outset as strangers and coldly. It must, as early as possible, be made acquainted, if not with our political aims, then at least with the ideals and the longing of our people, with our people's deeds and sufferings.
And now the question of the press. I believe that in general we can be content with our party press, at least from the agitational standpoint. So far as it is known to me, it is such that we can put it into anyone's hands and do ourselves credit by it. In particular our official organ, the "Welt", seems to me well edited and interesting. For the development of the "Welt" we ought to do as much as is at all possible. An illustrated supplement with topical pictures would raise the interest of wide circles. The most desirable thing would of course be if we could transform our party paper into a daily, a great and distinguished paper which would at last be our living mouthpiece and would for once regard all the events of the world from the Jewish standpoint. A truly Jewish paper, bearing witness to the life of our people, can only be such a daily, which need not draw the bounds of its sphere of interest as narrowly as a weekly journal. But before this wish, so often expressed here, is realised, much ink will doubtless flow down the pen. Excellent service is rendered us by other Jewish newspapers which, while not standing directly on the party standpoint, at least possess and spread an understanding of our national idea. Such serious and impartial newspapers often serve propaganda more than papers with a tendency. But all the more careful ought those of our party comrades to be to whom such papers stand open. A sharp, critical word may be spoken far rather in a party paper than in such a newspaper, much read by those who stand aloof. What, standing in the "Welt" or in "Altneuland", might be welcome to all serious workers in our cause, may in an impartial newspaper amount to a falsification and do our propaganda sensible harm. It is here that this propagation outside our ranks of special views legitimate within the movement — which I have already described as wholly inadmissible — works most dangerously of all. I should like to mention one more paper, which did not seek its strength in seriousness but did excellent work for the popularisation of our cause without on that account being avowedly Zionist: the "Schlemiel", now, alas, peacefully departed. I believe that such a paper for Jewish satire can never lack material, and that its existence would be of no small importance for our cause. Theodor Herzl too repeatedly gave expression to this view. May such an undertaking soon rise again on a solid foundation.
Since we are speaking of comic papers, I will quickly say a few words about a certain press calling itself Jewish, which provides as much unconscious comedy as unintended agitation. These papers, for the most part such as are published for the private use of their editors, have assailed Zionism in the most shameful manner ever since it came into being, working with coarse abuse and cowardly calumnies. They open their columns to anyone who knows how to put forward anything against us, however absurd. Such counter-agitation can only be of use, just as, according to experience, meetings convened by the opposing side have turned out most successful of all for us. Incidentally, this kind of agitation also comes cheapest to us, and if the idea that has already been mooted, of founding an "Association for Defence against Zionism", should be carried into reality, we should be spared much trouble.
Dangerous is the course which a number of other papers adopt: the tactics of killing by silence. The great mass of the world's papers of all tendencies, to be sure, regardless of their attitude to Zionism, follow our proceedings here attentively and in ever-growing numbers; they hold it their duty to keep their readers informed of the actual occurrences in our movement. And we have found that almost without exception these reports bear witness to objectivity, to understanding, and more or less also to inner sympathy. If, in connection with the reports, sharp criticism of us is exercised in many of these papers, we have nothing against it, but rather rejoice at it, since the reports themselves give every reader the opportunity of checking for himself. A number of papers, however — happily a small one — deliberately seek to cheat their readers of the knowledge of these proceedings, and violate in flagrant fashion the duty which a newspaper owes to the public that trusts it. These papers, which let no meeting of barbers' assistants, no trial for a lust-murder pass by, dare to slink past the imposing fact of our Congress; these papers, which record with fervour the most indifferent utterances of some exotic hole-and-corner diplomat, have the audacity to betray to their readers not one syllable of, for instance, the proceedings on East Africa. It is a quite definite sort of paper that is in question here. Just now we spoke of the papers which call themselves Jewish but behave as anything rather than Jewish; now it is a matter of the papers which, God help us, are called Jews' papers not only by the antisemites but by almost the whole non-Jewish public, which anxiously protest against this designation, yet by that very anxiety to be thought Jewish betray the Jewish descent of their conductors. It cannot be declared loudly and clearly enough that we, who are proud of our Jewishness and represent the interests of the Jewish community as a whole, emphatically decline all responsibility for these organs of people who have fled from Judaism, and that we can never and nowise regard these people as legitimate representatives of our people. It is perhaps understandable that the owners and conductors of these papers fall silent before the proud and free language spoken here. But the saddest thing is when papers which profess to serve the interests of Judaism pursue the same tactics of killing by silence, the same ostrich policy. Is it not absurd when in such papers the report on the Congress appears at most wedged in between the news of the award of the General Decoration of Honour to a pensioned community beadle and the silver wedding of the bellows-treader of some organ-synagogue? There our propaganda ought to set in; there is only one means of influencing this press: it must, to the public itself, clear-