Page 6 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Separate Edition No. 30
(continued from page 4)
…common solidarity with his own people before the enemy who sought to thrust the Jews out of the human community on account of their race.
He reflected upon his relation to the Jewish people and upon the relation of the Jewish people to the other nations; he came to the recognition that this relation was intolerable, and since he was a strong and resolute character, he at once formed the purpose of changing from the ground up the constitution and the situation of his people, whose fate he was bound to share and now also wished to share of his own free resolve.
No one, not even he himself, had until then suspected in him the qualities he brought to his new task. Herzl truly grew with his greater aims; he grew so mightily that his acquaintances and colleagues could no longer keep up with him by their accustomed measure, and assailed him with silly scorn or disgraceful slander because he had outgrown their short ell.
Out of the graceful causeur, the warm-hearted story-teller, the wittily trifling writer of comedies there emerged overnight a statesman of wide outlook, who strove boldly and steadfastly towards a lofty goal along almost impassable paths.
Carpers have turned up their noses and gone about saying that Herzl did not create Zionism, that he found it ready-made and appropriated the work of his predecessors without so much as naming them. I, however, state from certain knowledge of the facts that he knew absolutely nothing of predecessors. He found Zionism in his heart. He built it up systematically in his mind. Only years after he had fully settled matters with himself did he become acquainted with Pinsker and Moses Hess. They were encounters which gave him pleasure. But they came too late to teach him anything.
It was once asked in jest what would have become of Liszt and Paganini had they come into the world with their specific genius before the piano and the violin were invented. The answer to this question is given by the phenomenon of Herzl. He was in fact the Liszt or Paganini born before the invention of the instrument upon which alone his genius could reveal itself.
Herzl was a born statesman of the first rank without a state, without an organised people, without a single one of the instruments of power with which practical politics can be made. His case does not stand alone. The ancient Jewish people still brings forth from time to time talents for statesmanship for which it has no use. Some nevertheless create a field of activity for themselves, but it lies outside their people. Think of Disraeli, for whom a Jewish community would certainly have been too narrow, since the British world-empire was scarcely wide enough for him. Herzl — I say it calmly, conscious that I am not letting myself be carried away into extravagance — Herzl had the stuff of another Disraeli. He could have become one, had he done what Lord Beaconsfield did. But he would not do it, and resigned himself to the martyrdom of seeking to make great policy with empty hands, great policy for the Jewish people, whose official representatives and spokesmen denied that it was a people.
Herzl set about in cold blood to forge a people out of a human dust without common will and aims, to win a land for this people, and, without army, without fleet, without finances, to obtain concessions from governments that reckon only with these factors. It was an undertaking before which the boldest would have shrunk back. It was a completely hopeless undertaking, said the opponents of Zionism. Herzl, however, was convinced of its practicability and was not to be put off when others called a Utopia what he had before his eyes as a necessary and possible work.
It would be a great injustice to deny Herzl judgment. On the contrary, he had a keen critical sense and found out all the weaknesses of a plan sooner than others. If he nevertheless undertook without hesitation what seemed to others impossible to the point of madness, this is explained by the history of his mission.
When he conceived the thought of showing the Jewish people the way to redemption from a thousand years of ignominy, he really knew well, apart from his parents, only a single Jew — himself. With real, living Jewry he had until then had no connection. It lived in his imagination only as embodied in a Judas Maccabaeus, a Bar Kochba, a Juda Halevy, a Spinoza, a Heine. The qualities of these men, his own qualities, he assumed as a matter of course in all, or at least in most, of his kinsmen. He supposed that all or very many Jews were, like himself, resolved to endure humiliation no longer, that they had his will of steel, his moral earnestness, his ideal enthusiasm, his boundless unselfishness, his spirit of sacrifice; and he judged that these too were instruments of power with which a statesman can work, even when he has as yet no land, no army, no fleet, no finances at his disposal.
The tragedy of his life was that he erred in this fundamental calculation. His qualities were perhaps repeated virtually in all or many Jews, but at any rate they remained hidden. My heart contracts when I follow him on his nine years' path of suffering, as, caught in his fine trust in Jewry as in a mist, he groped with wounded hands through the thorns and nettles of reality. He did not doubt that the rich and the intellectual aristocracy of his people felt the same indignation at the situation of Jewry, the same longing for new and proud destinies, as he himself. He wrote his "Jewish State," showed in it with acumen and wise foresight how the exodus of the propertied Jews from the lands of persecution could be accomplished with the least harm to them and to those lands, had the book translated into several languages and printed at his own expense, sent it to the most eminent rabbis, communal heads and financiers, and waited. Now surely the great time of redemption and rebirth must begin! Some weeks of high hope and anxious foreboding passed; then he knew: most of the recipients of his book had not cut its pages, some had angrily thrown it into the waste-paper basket after the first pages, while some who had skimmed through it fell upon him in newspapers, pamphlets and pulpit sermons and called him a new Sabbatai Zevi, when they did not simply revile him as a cowardly deserter, or even as an antisemite.
Anyone else would have had enough of this first experience. Not Herzl. He was only taken aback, but he soon collected himself. His fertile brain at once brought forth a new plan. With the financial power, the intellectual forces and the manifold influence of the Jewish upper class, even a mediocre talent for organisation could realise the Zionist work of liberation without particular difficulty. Since this class remained deaf to Herzl's call, since it withheld its money from him, used its intellect to mock him, employed its influence to hamper him everywhere and his