No. 29 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 18
(continued from page 12)
…Jewish territory see, and how it will lead to Palestine, although it is not Palestine?
The German Zionist Federation, which declares every colonisation outside Palestine and its neighbouring countries to be no part of Zionism, includes in its programme the support of all means suited to raise the Jewish national self-consciousness. Can you conceive of anything better suited to raise the Jewish self-consciousness than a Jewish national territory? The raising of the Jewish national self-consciousness forms part of the Basle Programme, which is reason enough for the creation of a Jewish territory. But we prefer Scholaum — our old mortal enemy. How often have we preferred a dishonourable peace! But is Scholaum really so necessary for the Congress? Not in the least! All that is necessary is constitutionalism! Have you ever heard of a parliament with Scholaum? If that were necessary, the world would have no further need of parliaments. What is necessary is that the minority should respect the voice of the majority. That is the political lesson which our Russian brethren have yet to repent of. I do not in the least wish to reproach them for it. They come, after all, from a country without parliaments. Had the Nay-sayers not shown themselves so hysterical, Zionist money would have been employed for our Commission, and we should not have needed to go schnorring from Christians. (Greenburg calls out: We did not schnorr, they gave of their own accord.) The Commission would then have set out in good time, and we could have struck the iron while it was still hot. In September 1903 the English press was crowded with pictures of New Zion, and the "Times" devoted a quite favourable leading article to the project; in April 1905 the "Times" again had a detailed leading article on the future of East Africa, but of the Jewish State planned there there was no longer any mention.
The East African Territory.
When the report of our Commission had at last appeared, my friend Mr. Joseph Cowen complained to me that only two copies of it had been sold. I told him then that I was the one who had bought them. The over-loud conduct of the Palestine-only party, however, had a far worse result than the delay: it unnerved our poor leader, and whereas the offer was of such a kind that the choice of the area of settlement was left free to our Commission — namely, as the "Times" declared at the time, along the Uganda Railway — Dr. Herzl, who feared to spend our scanty means upon an uncertainty, pressed the Government to make the choice itself. The result was — as may easily be understood in view of the terrible uproar — that the Government selected a territory lying very far from the railway. Sir Henry Johnston's sudden satisfaction with the territory was highly suspicious. As now appears, the territory is a pastoral and not an agricultural country. Major Gibbons, the optimist, finds room in it at best for only 1000 cattle-raising families and 15,000 to 20,000 tillers of the soil, who would be of a still more problematical nature; Engineer Wilbusch can recommend it only to a cattle-raising company; Professor Kaiser would recommend it neither to a company nor to private enterprise. The development of such a territory would bring England great profit — its mere announcement has already enabled the Uganda Railway, for the first time since its foundation, to work without a deficit — but as a centre for diverting the stream of Jewish immigration it is wholly unsuitable. It can at best support 20,000 or 30,000 souls, whereas about 100,000 Jews leave Russia every year. I would therefore appeal to the Colonial Office to freshen the offer by the prospect of another territory for the purpose of expansion, in case the experiment should succeed, and I am convinced that it will not leave the request unheeded. Our people must not be made a fool of by such an offer, so that, if they reject it, they are told that the aliens refused to accept the asylum offered them and therefore cannot complain if they are sent to the devil.
Mr. Chamberlain and Dr. Herzl.
I am convinced that Mr. Chamberlain did not originally have in mind so cramped and unsuitable a country. When he spoke at Limehoux last December, the great statesman to whose benevolent imagination we owe the offer said: "I had several interviews with the late Dr. Herzl, the man who made the greatest impression upon me, and whose sincerity, patriotism and abilities could not but compel deep veneration from everyone who came into contact with him. We were agreed in principle that the best solution of the Jewish question is to find some country which would stand under the protection of the English flag, or under that of a concert of the Powers, if they will have it so, and in which these emigrants, driven out of their native lands — which they do not leave out of any whim, or because they wish to do us harm — could live in security of their religion and their ideals ..." "That was our subject," he said, and added: "Now the cause has indeed suffered very much through the death of Dr. Herzl, but his plans are being carried on, and, if I am not mistaken, a commission will leave this very week for East Africa, where there are thousands and hundreds of thousands of miles of uninhabited land, to see whether an asylum for these persecuted people might not be founded there."
"Thousands and hundreds of thousands of miles of uninhabited land." From that you can form an idea of the space which stood at our disposal. Certainly this bargain is not one-sided. For the working and cultivation of her extensive territories England needs men. That is the bargain into which Dr. Herzl wished to enter. Zionism was to furnish the labour and create a flourishing colony for England, in return for which it was to receive only "Self-Government." And every reasonable Zionist understands that Self-Government brings us much nearer to the final goal of Zionism than all the schemes of petty colonisation under the baksheesh-ridden Government of Turkey. The soil for such an experiment must be fertile and have a future. It must in and of itself exert a power of attraction, and must not sink into a doll's house for the creatures of philanthropy. It must, to speak in the simple but eloquent words of a Roumanian appeal, "bread and a future for the