"Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5 — No. 24
(continued from page 4)
…noblest foundation of Zionism is rather to be sought in education in the Jewish spirit, in the preservation and development of the ideal, historical treasures of the people, which can surely find their place more easily and more naturally in a Jewish milieu than anywhere else. Zionism, however, would thereby have fulfilled no more than an ethical task inherent in its very nature, had it undertaken to watch over that emigration to the end that it should remain national and that the settlers should not be de-Judaised.
It would have been positively salutary, and of great national gain, if in this undertaking one had employed for pioneer service a part of our youth from the learned professions — teachers, engineers, chemists, agronomists, surveyors, etc. — who are only too often in a state of superfluity; youth in whose souls an infinite sum of the joy of sacrifice and great treasures of ideal and ethical will lie stored up, which remain unused, but whom we must otherwise see, with heavy hearts, vanish from the movement at the very moment when they take their first steps into the struggle of life, and whom we wrongly accuse of faithlessness of feeling when we cannot offer them occupation and a calling within the movement.
Whether the expedition's result had been positive or negative, one could thus have countered our opponents in the Jewish as in the non-Jewish world and silenced their charges of ideology or dreaming.
But now there occurred something which others, at least, would have thought impossible precisely among the Jews. The sons of Israel, decried as realists and praised as gifted with practical sense, began to indulge in ideology and to quarrel over principles where questions of life itself were at stake.
The Eastern Zionists, especially the Russians — who, in consequence of their oppression and their surroundings, have always met the straightforward manner of the Westerners with little confidence, some of whom appear gifted with a special nose for scenting treason, and whose confidence had been but feebly won by years of honest, in part successful, but always selfless and self-sacrificing labour — showed a regrettable relapse into the mania of suspicion. Others among them were short-sighted and feared in good faith that Zionism might suffer harm. Others again, by virtue of their ideological bent and their delight in cultivating theoretical brooding and theoretical dispute, came forward as heralds in the battle for the principle. All of them together, however, were systematically incited by a certain species of professional and occasional journalists, who found here a welcome occasion for cheap declamation and easy notoriety. Even a highly meritorious and highly respected Hebrew writer, otherwise strictly logical in thought and in writing — one who, from empirical motives and by incorruptibly clear and penetrating reasoning, had in his own peculiar fashion struggled through to a kind of political Zionism at a time when no one had yet so much as dreamed of it, but who had an old account to settle with the leaders of political Zionism — found the moment ripe to come forward in the "Haschiloach" with an article in which he took as the starting point of his reflections that tragic scene in which a part of the Eastern delegates turned a conference room of the Basle Casino into the "Place before the Wailing Wall," where some hysterical ladies fainted and where a few Westerners of a certain party tendency, since gently deceased, deemed it fitting to join in the chorus of weeping and to confirm the depressed spirits in the delusion that Jerusalem had now truly fallen into the hands of the enemy for the third time.
In the said article the esteemed writer — this time travelling more along the path of sentiment than along the straight line of logic — came to the conclusion that it was only their tears that had washed the scales from the eyes of the weepers, and with them their blindness, and that only now — too late, of course — had they come to perceive that their Zionism had long since been emptied of its content . . .
That was oil on the fire, and the effect of all these concurrent events was naturally bound to be disastrous.
Not only were the leaders in the West subjected to unheard-of, groundless attacks, indeed to base calumny, but all Western Zionists without exception were stigmatised as downright traitors. Now, it was said, they have shown their true intentions; now they have revealed themselves.
In the atmosphere thus created, men then came forward in the name of the Idea against the Congress, and heavy blows were dealt against the edifice of the organisation, which was in any case not built of steel. Even generals of the movement became mutineers. They were, however, more and more encouraged in this from a certain quarter which I need not describe more closely; and when an otherwise loyal fellow Zionist turned to the public with an appeal gravely injurious to the standing of the movement, it was proclaimed to all the world that "the iron tread of the Opposition is already to be heard," which was called to bring down the judgment of God upon the Westerners and to punish their faithlessness. And so discord and distrust were sown, and a terrorism was set on foot which could not but provoke not merely contradiction but downright defiance.
Over against the ostracism of a few, who presumed to pronounce the anathema upon those who had voted "yes," and to condemn as an apostate any fellow Zionist, however deserving, who did not join in cursing the Uganda project, and to deny him as unreliable his membership in the fellowship of the cause and in Zionism, there developed — as once did Sansculottism — out of what the zealots had stamped as a term of abuse, a system: Ugandism.
This, to be sure, was still friendly to Zion, and did not put itself forward immodestly. Its adherents had no wish whatever to renounce Palestine, nor did they look for defects in the Idea and its execution; they declared rather that, obeying necessity and not their own inclination, they wished to help found a place of refuge for those who cannot wait until the final goal shall prove attainable "within a measurable time."
In the face of incessant attacks, they too were able to point to certain goods that might be won through a free homestead for Jewish nationalism. Some took up an outright so-called practical standpoint: that one could not and must not place the land above the people, since our sages too, in the hard days of old, precisely in order to preserve the people, opposed on religious grounds the continual risings, the revolts for the reconquest of the land that squandered goods and blood in vain, and in this way actually saved Judaism.
At present, they said, there is again a similar phenomenon in the history of Jewish life: the people is well-nigh on the verge of destruction. Some fall away for want of knowledge of their own people, from the craving for assimilation, others from bitter want, and those who remain must go to ruin and sink into misery, so that, if one does not
