Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 24.
(continued from page 1)
…lent counsel and practical help stood by. Among other things he proposed a slight deviation from the Government's offer, which is to be recommended for many reasons.
Mr. Kaiser and Mr. Wilbusch both appear, to judge from their reports, to be under the impression that the deviation proposed by Sir Harry Johnston is a modified offer of the Government; the remarks relating to such a modified offer therefore rest upon an error, and since they would have given rise to great confusion, they have been struck out of the reports. We need hardly say that the conclusions expressed in the reports are in no way affected thereby.
In accordance with the arrangements made, the reports of Messrs. Kaiser and Wilbusch were submitted to Major Gibbons, since he was the leader of the expedition. He has appended to his report a supplement containing notes on the reports of his colleagues.
It would not be fitting for me to express here any opinion which I may have formed, through a study of these reports, regarding this territory for the purposes of a Jewish settlement. The matter is surely one for the Congress, before which the proposals of the Actions Committee concerning the whole scheme are probably to be laid. I do not doubt, however, that the conditions under which alone the scheme could be acceptable have been sufficiently considered. Dr. Herzl set out these conditions in a letter to Sir Francis Montefiore, dated 14th December 1903. In this letter he says:
"Four elements are, in my opinion, necessary in order that the offer of the English Government may appear to us to lie within the bounds of practical politics:
-
The extent of the territory must be sufficient to permit immigration on such a scale that in time it will appreciably lessen the pressure which at present weighs upon the Jews in the East.
-
The territory must be capable of colonisation by a people such as ours.
-
Such autonomous rights must be granted to the concession that the Jewish character of the settlement is preserved.
-
And — what is probably the chief thing — the enthusiasm of our own people for the offer must be such that all the difficulties, so readily foreseen, which must make themselves felt in the founding of a settlement even under the most favourable conditions, can thereby be overcome."
The reports now laid before you give us the means of deciding in what degree some of these four conditions, which formerly appeared doubtful, are to be found in the territory in question.
When the right moment comes, I am convinced that the opportunity will not be neglected of thanking the Commission for the manner in which it has done its work. But it is only just to point out here that Mr. Wilbusch undertook his laborious task of assisting in the exploration of the territory and of writing a report upon it without any fee whatever, solely from the wish to serve the Zionist Movement, of which he is an earnest and zealous champion.
In conclusion I must still give expression to my feeling of the deepest gratitude to Sir Clement Hill, who until recently stood at the head of the Protectorate Department, and also to the other members of the Foreign Office, for the unfailing readiness to help and the courtesy which we have received from the English Government ever since the offer was originally made.
Yours respectfully,
LEOPOLD J. GREENBERG.
16th May 1905.
* * *
Report on the Work of the Zionist Commission in British East Africa.
By Major A. St. H. Gibbons. (Translated from the English.)
In accordance with my original instructions I have the pleasure of laying before you my report on the proceedings and investigations of the Commission which went under my leadership to East Africa for the purpose of exploring the natural and political conditions of the Guas Ngishu Plateau, the territory which has been offered to the Zionists by the British Government for the purpose of settlement.
I send herewith a map prepared by me, which shows the results of my surveys, and I also submit to your Committee my own observations, numerous compass bearings, observations of latitude, etc., which check one another and should to a certain degree guarantee the accuracy of the surveys so far as all the more important points are concerned.
It is to be regretted that my colleagues were not furnished with surveying instruments and were therefore unable to supply data as to the extent of the land surveyed. I must point out that, owing to the pathless state of the country, which for several years has had no settled population, travelling was attended with great hardship, especially along the borders of the Chipchangwane range of mountains. It was therefore a physical impossibility, in the short time at our disposal, to explore as much land as would have been desirable.
I send herewith also photographs which were taken for the purpose of illustrating this report. Before entering more closely into the prospects and possibilities of this territory from the point of view of a European settlement, I will report upon the general course of the expedition.
The Commission, which consisted of Professor Alfred Kaiser, Mr. N. Wilbusch, engineer, and myself, left Trieste on board the Austrian Lloyd steamer "Africa" on the 28th of December of last year and landed at Mombassa on the 13th of January. Through the kind assistance of Messrs. Smith, Mackenzie & Co., Mombassa, we were able to proceed by the Nairobi railway to Uganda on the following day. At Mombassa I engaged a caravan leader and various servants, and also a number of porters, since I had been warned — with good reason, as I afterwards perceived — that caravans consisting exclusively of natives from the interior of the country often prove unreliable and, through desertion and insubordination, might cause the Commission serious loss of time. In view of the short time at our disposal, I did not wish to expose myself to this. At Nairobi I engaged 35 more porters, and all preparations had been made when the time came to board the first train westward. We set out on the morning of the second day after our arrival. At Nairobi I saw Sir Donald Stewart, K. C. M. G., Commissioner of His Maje-