Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 21.
(continued from page 1)
…our fellow Zionists everywhere so longingly awaited decision of the A.-C.: "Unanimous Resolution of the Greater A.-C. concerning East Africa.
The Zionist Actions Committee declares that, after thorough study of the report now before it of the Commission sent to East Africa, it is not in a position to recommend to the Zionist Organisation the carrying out of the East Africa project. At the same time the Actions Committee proposes to the Congress that it express to the British Government its deeply felt thanks for the goodwill shown to the Jewish people by its generous offer."
The resolution was received on all sides with great applause.
With this one of the most important points of the order of business was disposed of. As the assembly wished to await Dr. Nordau's answer, or rather the return of the three delegates, before taking points 3 and 4 of the order of business into consideration, it was resolved, after the reports on the state of the movement, to deliberate upon the statute of the National Fund and the proposed alterations of the statutes of the Jewish Colonial Trust. The reports on the state of the movement made it possible to record its gratifying progress. Even in Russia, where a falling-back had been feared on account of the war, the present political situation and the dissensions called forth by the East Africa project, nothing of the kind appeared.
The statute of the National Fund, which, for the securing of our national property, had to be drawn up with the greatest caution and with special regard to every conceivable guarantee, has now been finally drafted and submitted for legalisation. This was achieved in a manner similar to that adopted for the Jewish Colonial Trust, and with strengthened guarantees. It is gratifying that this matter, which for some years had occupied a number of eminent jurists of all countries, could be brought to a conclusion in a manner satisfying even the most far-reaching demands.
Of no less importance is it that the long-desired alterations of the statute of the Colonial Bank (J. C. T.), already provided for by the Third Congress, have at last been brought into proper form. Very thorough debates, enlarged by numerous expert legal explanations, preceded this drafting.
On Wednesday the members of the Greater A.-C., following a suggestion made by Mr. Moser at the opening session, went in corpore to the grave of our departed Leader, where they lingered for some time in silent devotion.
Meanwhile the deputation had returned from Karlsbad and rendered its report. Dr. Nordau had been informed by the deputation of the wish of the Greater A.-C. He had repeatedly, and last of all in his letter to the Greater A.-C., declined the leadership, giving weighty reasons. To the deputation, too, he declared that he could not but hold these reasons to be sound. It required special and urgent representations from all three gentlemen before he became accessible to other considerations. It did not fail to make a deep impression upon him when Dr. Katzenelsohn mentioned a conversation which he had had with our Leader a few weeks before Dr. Herzl's death. In this conversation Doctor Herzl expressly named Dr. Nordau as his successor. Nordau, so Dr. Herzl thought, would continue the work begun, not only out of devotion to our cause but also out of friendship for him. Finally the gentlemen came to an agreement with Nordau — who, in view of the wish of the Greater A.-C. and of the great pains which the three delegates had undergone, did not wish to let them depart without a definite answer — to request the Greater A.-C. to propose to the Congress a board of three men for the direction of the movement. The board was to consist of Dr. Nordau, Prof. Dr. Warburg and D. Wolffsohn. The Greater A.-C. accepted this proposal unanimously, as it did nearly all the other resolutions of this session, and will lay it before the Congress.
Only now could the deliberation of the remaining points of the order of business be entered upon. At the time of going to press the question of organisation is under discussion, on which a great number of proposals have been submitted. —r.
(Conclusion of the report in the next number.)
Open Letter to Mr. Greenberg*)
Sir!
Permit me to reply to your "Open Letter" to the A.-C., which was addressed to us all. I write in my own name, but can assure you that very many would sign this letter of mine.
For you, Sir, the moment to examine the Uganda question more closely has only now arrived, because the "Expedition" has already explored the country.
I ask you: do other parties and movements likewise proceed by first exploring a proposal practically before it has been accepted in theory? You know as well as all of us that the theoretical side of any question must precede the practical. Why, then, Mr. Greenberg, do you think that only now it is not "not too premature" to examine the Uganda project? What would your Expedition do if we all, all of us, after thorough discussion, came to the conclusion that we, as Zionists, may not concern ourselves with the Uganda project? What, then, was the use of the Expedition that cost you so much trouble? Why did you not come forward with your "Open Letter" before the Sixth Congress?
* * *
You see that a veritable fratricidal war has broken out among us, that the formerly united organisation has fallen into schism, and merely to console us you tell us that in every movement there are "opposing currents". Why, Sir, this masking behind the phrase "in every"? Turn the pages of the world's history and show us even a single movement in which there are opposing currents?
Differing views, differing currents occur even in every society — but "opposing" currents cannot exist within a movement. If one stream flows in the direction opposite to another, these streams do not belong to one and the same river. Every party, every movement has but one goal towards which it flows; all the lesser and greater streams within a party have but one direction.
Up to the Sixth Congress we too had in our movement differing currents, which, however, all had one direction: Palestine to a Jewish land
*) Dr. Wortsmann sent us this article soon after the appearance of Greenberg's open letter. As we could not print various aggressive passages of this letter which constituted personal attacks, we at length, after a lengthy correspondence with Dr. Wortsmann, obtained his consent to eliminate the offensive passages. Unfortunately the structure of the letter is such that we could not remove everything without destroying the connection. The Editors.