Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 18
(continued from page 5)
...but from propagators of national Judaism come — since outwardly they do not stand in opposition to the principles we follow, but appear merely to be a weakening of them; and since these reproaches, which seemingly signify only a weakening, a damming-in of our allegedly too far-reaching ideas, contain within themselves, more than anything else, an eminent danger for our movement striving towards its ideal.
It is irresponsible, say the National-Jewish aesthetes, always to speak of the Golus only as of something irremediably evil, with no other aim than to win the Jewish masses for the goals of political Zionism. And an attempt is made to discredit the arguments of political Zionism by denying that harmony of soul is impossible in the Golus for the sensitively constituted cultured Jew, however great his political rights and though every economic want be taken from him; it is further thought possible to shake the effectiveness of our agitation, in order perhaps to win more quickly attainable, ephemeral successes, by denying the fact that the confinement of the Jews within a mass ethnically antagonistic to them excludes social liberation from the outset. Only because the persuasive power of our positive postulates is too weak do we, it is alleged, seek to win the Jewish masses for our aims by exaggerating the hardships of our present condition, which we declare to be immanent; and by our assertion that the full living-out of Jewish national ideals is unthinkable in the Golus without national autonomy, we fan the unattainable longing for the Jewish State in the land of the fathers.
Consistent political Zionism has also been reproached with coquetting with the theory of pauperisation. Let it remain undiscussed whether, in the beginnings of the movement, out of mistaken tactical considerations, the political and economic pauperisation of the Jewish masses was in fact regarded as a precondition of Zionist success. So much, however, is certain: that Zionism to-day pays homage in no camp to catastrophic-revolutionary theories, and that in Zionism too, as a modern movement, the principle of evolution has triumphed and is made the basis of all considerations. Without prejudice to the recognition of evolutionist principles, or perhaps precisely because a scientific method of observation has made the modern Jew a Zionist, the fundamental view had to be upheld that only flight from the Golus can bring the Jews deliverance from distress of soul. For we bow to an iron law of nature when we strive to escape the embrace of those who hate us. For we thereby acknowledge the undeniable, inwardly grounded antagonism of the races of peoples. For we thereby merely adapt our policy to the views of contemporary sociology; to Friedrich Ratzel's phrase concerning the "taking root of a population in the soil", and to the theory of Ludwig Gumplowicz, who sees in attachment to the soil and in a suitable compact territory the conditions for the existence of a nation.
Not every Jew, to be sure, always and everywhere sees and feels the distress of the Golus. Often enough misfortune lies beneath a glittering surface. Nor, further, is the distress of the Golus everywhere and always acute, or better still, actual; but the sociologically trained eye will discern the Golus element behind all social phenomena. Are the decisive marks of the Golus, then, the economic distress of the Jews in Galicia, their political and civil lack of rights in absolutist Russia or in constitutional Roumania? We have no guarantee that at a given moment class antagonisms will not assert themselves and economic distress visit our masses in an autonomous Judah as well; that, and the degree of political freedom in the future State, will depend upon whether the reactionary or the progressive elements within the movement prevail. But what is possible in the Golus will not be so in an autonomous Judah: that only the Jews suffer economic distress, that only the Jews are more or less unfree politically and socially. And even if in the Jewish State differing class interests should cause a social stratification up to the moment when we too have realised the socialist ideal, this stratification will yet not be the product of a difference in national feeling. That will fall away which is the decisive mark of the Golus: that we are economically oppressed, politically deprived of rights, and socially outlawed because of our national difference. It may well be pointed out that workers and capitalists must stand opposed to one another in battle array because of their interests, that the one and the other combine into classes on the basis of common interests — yet in spite of all community of interest, the innermost national feeling creates unbridgeable antagonisms.
The phrase "overstraining of the conception of Golus" would have no inner justification even as against such Zionist zealots as strive for the pauperisation of the Jewish masses for the sake of a speedier realisation of Zionist aims. But where are these zealots to-day, and what influence have their tendencies upon political Zionism? We see, on the contrary, to-day, that precisely where political Zionism takes hold, the slumbering cultural forces of Judaism awaken to new life. And those who to-day, as Zionists, consciously emphasise the distress of the Golus by no means thereby preach a standing-aside from general political questions, a shutting of oneself off from the general ideals of humanity. The contrary is the case. No Jewish movement has yet recognised in the same measure as modern political Zionism the necessity of furthering real, true progress. And only out of this recognition did we become conscious that the aims of Zionism will be attained only by a Jewry grown politically strong out of its own resources. But only the recognition and full understanding of the distress of the Golus in all its varieties can stretch our forces to the degree that will enable us to attain even the highest: to become masters in our own house. By systematic, sustained work in the present, with the final goal that strains our forces to their utmost ever before our eyes, we shall attain that political, economic and cultural strength which is necessary in order to find the paths leading out of the Golus into the homeland. But if we forget that in the Golus we can all attain only momentary advantages, but never raise ourselves to a full national existence, then we shall suffer that which no people without a territory of its own can in the long run escape: national death!
From Russia.
Our kinsmen in Russia are at present passing through hard times. Threatening storm-clouds have gathered over their heads, dark powers have joined together to make their impossible existence still more unspeakably difficult... What the near future will bring our brethren in the Tsar's empire cannot be foretold, but it can be foreboded. A series of facts and episodes from the life of the Jews in Russia, with which the Russian papers of the latest date teem, characterise the whole tragedy of the present situation of our kins-