Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 16 · 19 April 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 28

No. 16 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

…cept, and seek out consortia which could realise it. If we do not do so, if we reject it out of hand, then we commit not merely a colossal folly, which would expose us for ever before the world as politically immature pot-house politicians, but we also commit a crime against the great mass of the persecuted and enslaved Jewish multitudes. For England's offer was, after all, meant for the latter, and it turned to us merely because we are the only organised, purposeful party within Jewry. It would be presumption to believe that we Zionists embody the Jewish people in toto; we have therefore not the slightest right to reject that which might prove a blessing to the people . . . . As a small part of this people, however, we must take a lively part, to the best of our powers, in the carrying out of the project. We are Jews, and nothing Jewish may remain foreign to us. Dr. Max Mandelstamm. Kieff, March 28—April 9, 1905.

Zionism and England's Offer.

By Israel Zangwill. I.

We are approaching the day on which the pious Jew sits at the Passover meal and rejoices in his redemption from bondage, his passage from slavery to freedom. What a sublimely ludicrous picture! A few months ago one could see our Ghetto prisoners celebrating their Chanukah festival, the festival of thanksgiving, the day of independence. What irony lies therein! These trodden-down, crawling victims of the Ghetto celebrate the victories of Judas Maccabaeus! These poor, peace-loving dwellers in filthy holes, who have never known a fatherland, sing hymns of triumph in honour of the reconquest of their Holy Land and their Temple from the hands of the ancient Graeco-Syrians two thousand years ago. The Jewish world is a world of shadows. Is it not time that Rip Van Winkle should awake and take cognisance of the things around him and of himself? We have not done so for some two hundred years. Eighteen hundred and thirty-four years ago we lost our fatherland, and the time of mourning might well be over. We must either reconcile ourselves to our loss or set about regaining what was lost. But it is just this capacity of choosing between the one alternative and the other that the Jew has lost. He lost it in the Middle Ages, when in many countries, unable to make the choice between Christianity and death, between Islam and martyrdom, he became what is called a Marrano, pretending to be what his surroundings were, and in secret remaining attached to his Jewish rite. The plan of the Marrano looked very neat, but was not always satisfactory. For the double life meant a life full of terror, full of endless bribes and subterfuges, and to be caught — which was frequently the case — meant to be forfeit to the stake and the sword. When in the eighteenth century the sunlight of Emancipation began to rise in Western Europe and the Jew emerged into the general life of the world, the hunted creature could not get rid of its old feeling that its own life was something that must be hidden. The public life of the Jew became ostentatiously identical with that of his neighbours. This modern Marranism was often completed by the change of name and even by the change of faith. In Germany especially, Jews who wished to be "fashionable" had themselves baptised in masses. The Prozentum has brought about with greater success the results which persecution could not produce. Our celebrities find it fitting to hide themselves from their own flesh. The late Jules Verne was a Polish Jew, a Talmud student who once wore love-locks. At the schools and universities our young Jews are not especially concerned to emphasise their nationality. If one wishes to pay a Jew a compliment, one should tell him one would have taken him for no Jew at all. How deep is the degradation to which our people has sunk! The mediaeval Marranos at least kept their self-respect, in that they despised the people whom they imitated. We admire our neighbours and despise only ourselves.

The Jewish policy of many centuries may be summed up in the following sentence: "Duck down and hold your tongue." But if one ducks, one escapes, it is true, the attention of the enemy, but one is also usually trodden underfoot. Holding one's tongue on the one side does not yet prevent the others from saying a great deal. When my Jewish critics tell me I should keep silent about this, not make that public, hush up some other thing, I must always think of the Jew who was so delighted by the liberal sentiments of a Christian hunchback, whom he met on a steamer, that he could not resist the temptation of confessing to him that he was a Jew. "Confidence for confidence," the Christian whispered to him, "I have a hump."

Against this policy of cringing and holding one's tongue Zionism comes forth with its ringing trumpet-blast: "Fly high and say everything!" Zionism means the end of the period of the Marranos and the revival of the Maccabean age. Zionism means the political movement for the creation of a publicly and legally secured home for the Jewish people in Palestine. And a political movement needs statesmen. Hitherto we have been led by good rabbis and gentle millionaires. Look for yourselves where we have got to! No, a people does not entrust its destinies to a Cardinal Newman or a Lord Shaftesbury, but it says to a Gladstone or a Beaconsfield: "Thou art the man!" We found our Disraeli in Theodor Herzl. And since we have possessed a statesman, we have begun to regard our problem with a statesman's eye. With our dead Leader we see that Jewish charity is bankrupt, that it cannot solve the problem of our masses, who are emigrating from the lands of oppression and find themselves literally between the devil and the deep sea, since one door of asylum after another is slammed in their faces. Jewish charity in America is the most generous and the best organised. But what can the "United Hebrew Charities" (the united Jewish charitable institutions) of New York do with an annual immigration of 89,442 Jews, of whom 64,662 remain in the city of New York? How can these masses be kept in a hygienic condition when 400,000 Jews are herded together on one square mile? And then dispersal in the non-Jewish provincial towns produces another tragedy, the spiritual tragedy of starving souls that after the