Page 10. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 14.
(continued from page 9)
…should be, who would be appointed or confirmed by the English Government.*) This is the only possible guarantee, for it would surely be ridiculous to expect the English Government to approve any project "whereby the exclusion of non-Jews from a territory under the control of the Crown becomes a definite provision." In short: it is very hard, after all this, not to agree with Mr. Greenberg that this bugbear of autonomy is really by no means disquieting.
Such, then, is the relief afforded by Uganda. Decades of labour upon a territory remote from the whole civilised world, with the same danger of a competing proletariat of other nations, with the complete absence of any psychological attachment to this territory, and with the presence, on the contrary, of a mighty, ancient love — undoubted even for the Ugandists — for another land. But apart from this attachment, everything else too speaks for this other land: it lies upon a busy trade route, and the whole world foretells for it a brilliant industrial future, no longer distant, which in and of itself, even without our doing, will call for an influx of new forces. There 80,000 Jews dwell, and if we now establish schools there, then in ten years, with the increase, we shall have a population of nearly a hundred thousand souls with a self-reliant and educated youth; that is, we shall acquire strength and influence there and (as Mr. Greenberg also wishes) set up factories, workshops, colonies and offices. In Uganda, however, we cannot have even 20,000 colonists in ten years. And nevertheless Uganda can "relieve" our situation, that is, receive and shelter our enormous emigration, and Palestine cannot. Why? Because in Uganda we shall have an "autonomy," the same that is "not so disquieting" . . . .
We are of another opinion on this. Neither Uganda nor Palestine can "relieve" our situation and receive our emigration. Only the Jewish State can receive our colossal emigration — that publicly secured home for the sake of which the Zionist movement arose — and only from the moment when Palestine or Uganda becomes the Jewish State does the relief of Jewish misery begin. Not earlier. This, however, will not happen soon; it will take a very long time yet, and the emigration is in fact very great and very full of torment. But it was for this very reason that Zionism arose, and for this very reason that we must build the Jewish State. Mr. Greenberg proposes to build the Jewish State in Palestine and to found in Uganda a shelter for the emigration "which will never become the Jewish State." But these conceptions are surely identical. The Jewish State is precisely the refuge for the emigration, and there can be no other refuge. It is impossible to separate them and to set up the one in one place and the other in another, for to create the Jewish State and to set up an emigration territory we must always employ the same weapons and means: a long process of industrialising the territory marked out, that is to say, the enormous, protracted exertion of the national will of the organised Jewish people. Our emigration is the very material out of which the Jewish State must be built, and the whole process of building the latter is nothing other than the setting-up of an emigration territory; and when that has been built up, it will then become apparent that this is the Jewish State itself. Until then, however, Jewish misery is incurable, and it
*) Clement Hill's text says "ernannt" (appointed).
is remarkable that Mr. Greenberg is astonished at this only now, whereas it is the starting-point of every Zionist. Until then our emigration is no emigration at all, but a moving to and fro in a vast alien world. We are bound to ease this moving to and fro as much as possible, to protect the emigrants against the insolence of plunderers and against the enmity of the masters of this alien world; but if we wish to give them a home, then we must say to ourselves plainly: to create a home for the Jewish emigration means to create a Jewish State, and therefore this home must be begun only on that territory which can become the Jewish State.
This the pure Territorialists acknowledge too. They are for Uganda because, in their opinion, Uganda can finally become the Jewish State. But Mr. Greenberg is for Palestine, and to him it is clear that the Jewish State cannot be built in Uganda. Consequently no home for the emigration can be set up there either, for that is one and the same thing.
* * *
Two more remarks.
The Ugandists are very fond of saying that Mr. Greenberg has intimated that, for the winning of Palestine, the Jews must strengthen their international influence, and that for this purpose it would be useful to have a "commonwealth" in Uganda. We too are of the opinion that the Jews must gain international influence, but we hold that this is to be attained much more simply through the organisation of the scattered Jewish forces. If all this financial, cultural and political influence which thousands of Jews possess in thousands of separate localities were united by a Jewish world union, Jewry would represent an enormous power. But if all ten million Jews were to gather in Uganda to-morrow, we should be a quite small African realm, which would have far less influence upon world politics than even Belgium, because Belgium is, after all, in Europe. It is another question which is preferable: to be strong in the Golus, or weak in one's own land. For the Territorialist the answer is clear: Uganda satisfies him completely and he needs no further influence at all. But an adherent of Palestine, like Mr. Greenberg, who after Uganda still strives for the Land of Israel, must ever bear in mind that Uganda will support him politically in this sense exactly as much as, for example, Liberia supports the North American Negroes. For the attainment of our goal Jewry must grow strong. This strengthening, however, is to be achieved by way of organisation, of the raising of self-consciousness, and of untiring struggle at every step for our legal, economic and cultural interests.
Feeling in the depths of his soul that Uganda is the same thing, and on almost the same scale, as Argentina, and therefore no Zionist affair, Mr. Greenberg proposes "to form an association ad hoc for the exploitation of the territory" — — We can forbid no one to scatter Jewish money to the winds, but we may not support such outlays. Every Heller of Jewish money is, in our view, the national property of the Jewish people, and we must demand that this money be spent only on reasonable and useful purposes. Whether Uganda uselessly swallows the National Fund or the capital of the "Ica" is all the same to us, because the capital of the "Ica" likewise belongs to the Jewish people, and perhaps not ten years more will pass before the people organises itself and the millions of Baron Hirsch are handed over for administration to its lawfully elected representatives and leaders. So long as