No. 8 — "Die Welt" — Page 15
(continued from page 14)
…depend, thanks to the unhappy combinations of philanthropy, almost exclusively upon the Baron Hirsch Fund.
When the first settlers were sent hither, the thought, it seems, was only of founding an agricultural colony here, and so there arose at first Jewish farms round about. But these farms failed utterly; after years of toilsome labour — which consisted for the most part in the grubbing out of climbing plants — the colonists, seeking bread, began to flee into the towns.
Then the "Ica" erected a factory, then three others, and in this manner offered to the local farmers and to the factory workers who had come thither specially for this purpose — employment. These factories, however, have a certain original exceptional position, which is precisely a consequence of philanthropy: Because the situation is in fact not suitable for factories, and at least not a single manufacturer was willing to establish himself here, the "Ica" granted subventions to the contractors. Buildings and equipment are therefore the property of the Baron Hirsch Foundation; to the contractors the use of them free of cost was conceded, on the condition that they pay out weekly a definite quota of the profit to the workers. Now so long as the work is in flow and the contractor lives in concord with the Baron Hirsch administration, the worker does not feel so greatly the "benefits" of philanthropy. But in the fact that there is room here for only 500 hands, and that there are only four contractors, lies the tolerably well-founded apprehension that these "hired" capitalists excessively exploit the worker, who is in fact wholly in their power. The whole danger of the situation came to light in the year 1904, when, after the expiry of the five years' period fixed by contract, a dispute broke out between the largest of these contractors and the administration of the Hirsch Fund. In consequence of this dispute 300 people were without work for three months, and at the gates of flourishing Woodbine Master Hunger began to knock! . . .
The contractor, who threatened a lawsuit, received this year 20 000 dollars. Who knows what the five following years will bring?!
And even if for the present we leave undecided the question whether the combination of the farm with factories is good and suited to its purpose — the fact is that after this dispute the daily wage of the workers was cut down!
And this whole atmosphere of waiting and of the apprehensions that follow from it, this artificial edifice which threatens every moment to collapse, whereby the pretty Woodbine dwelling-houses will have to stand empty (the manufacturers make bold to assert: "Those are our houses, those we built for the workers") — all this must exert an immensely sad and pernicious influence upon healthy natures that delight in work — and a heavy nightmare weighs upon the soul of a Jew when he looks on and sees how little this great Jewish philanthropy effects — because it so wills it!
I will further remark that in the Woodbine factories the ten-hour day prevails, and that the hygienic arrangements are little satisfactory, although in the great city factories it is said to be worse still. In the first weeks the worker receives 3—4 dollars weekly, later 8 dollars on the average. Little children one does not see, but many girls who professed to be 14 years old, but are so slight and thin that it appears scarcely credible. Where the head of the family and the children do not earn enough, they take work home for 2—3 dollars weekly.
The education of the children and the intellectual life in Woodbine are exemplary. The attendance at the schools leaves nothing to be desired. The school offers the children not only knowledge, but also gymnastics, music, games, children's clubs; there exist also sick-benefit societies and so-called lodges, built up on mutual insurance. The agricultural school has developed excellently from small beginnings and is an admirably equipped institution of learning, which gives to over 100 pupils instruction and material maintenance free of charge. In a word: for so young a community of Volhynian Jews an astonishing progress and a pretty American culture. And under the influence of this American culture the young generation develops and assimilates itself; there arise two circles of ideas utterly strange to one another, young and old, and in the middle stand those who came hither already at an almost mature age and are not yet "old." These know not what to do; they would gladly be Jews, but they see round about them nothing but "Americans."
The Woodbine intelligentsia exhausts its Judaism, as does the American intelligentsia in general, in this, "that they support the co-religionists oppressed by the barbarians." The Jewish children learn in the schools very exactly the history of the United States and of the rest of the world, but of Jewish history — not a syllable. And these children in Woodbine learn only later, at a riper age, that the Jews too have their history, and learn only later to feel that they belong to something of which they can no longer give themselves an account; thus do these "philanthropists" create a mighty disharmony in the soul of man. I met intelligent people who told me that they had heard a great many pretty things about Jews, and that from Christian Americans.
Woodbine has even a Talmud Torah building of its own, in which there is now a branch of the public elementary school; the inhabitants have for the moment (?!) no money for Jewish teachers, and the Baron Hirsch administration, which itself founds or supports various clubs and organisations, discreetly leaves the Talmud Torah school to the private initiative of the "well-to-do" factory workers.
Mr. Sabsovich expressly declared to me, upon my question, that what is being done in Woodbine, for example, by no means signifies the solution of the Jewish question; they do not concern themselves about it at all; he had been a Russian revolutionary and was to-day an American citizen. Beyond that nothing concerned him.
Self-help is the only way to the solution of the Jewish question, but the "Ica" has not yet learned much of it, at most as regards the outward form.
It is subject to no doubt whatever that the "Ica" does not think of this solution of the Jewish question at all; it merely makes experiments in Argentina, Woodbine, etc., repeats the old mistakes, destroys instead of founding, and in doing so throws away hundreds of thousands yearly. Woodbine alone has already cost (according to the March number, 1904, of the "New Era Magazine") 300 000 dollars.
Dr. H. Syrop.
Not uninteresting, and a little in contradiction with the above description, is the letter which six pupils of the Baron Hirsch Agricultural School in Woodbine have addressed to an American paper. As Zionists who follow with great interest the endeavours of the Zionist leaders, and are withal hardened, sturdy, courageous and self-reliant farmers, they offer themselves as pioneers for Uganda, to which step they are impelled not by their bad situation, but by their warm Jewish fellow-feeling.