Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 4 · 27 January 1905
8printed page
scan 8 of 20
Facsimile · scan 8 of 20
Scan of p. 8
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 4.

(continued from page 7)

…wholly separate communal organisation are divided from one another, there could be any talk of a rapprochement or of a union. We have nevertheless lived to see it. The sixth national district of the Hungarian Congress Jewry held its annual meeting in Budapest on the 22nd of December of last year, and elected, in place of Martin Schweiger, who had resigned, the former member of the Reichstag Moriz Mezei as President and at the same time as chairman of the Israelite National Chancery. The newly elected President pointed in his programme speech to the great difficulties which are felt in Hungarian Jewry through the lack of an autonomy. But since a dismembered Jewry can win no autonomy, every leader must, as a Jew and as a Hungarian patriot (!), strive to bring about the union of all the Jews in the country, in order that nothing may stand in the way of the autonomy upon which the flourishing of Hungarian Jewry solely and alone depends. As a matter of course Mezei had in his address to go back to the origin of this split. He had to touch the two delicate points, and nothing would have been more intelligible than if there had been sacrificed to the opposing party either the right to see the Shulchan Aruch recognised in the statutes also, or the Rabbinical Seminary. The latter would perhaps not have been demanded at all, since the institution has, ever since it has existed, proved itself "exemplary and answering to the most far-reaching demands." But why did he declare the reception of the Shulchan Aruch into the Congress statutes to be impossible, seeing that he himself declared that the Congress Jews also recognise the Shulchan Aruch and do not wish to shake it? Yes, but the statutes may not be altered! That the first Congress community of the country, in the summer of last year, in opposition to the Congress statutes, so altered its statutes that only those can be members of the community who, besides their communal tax, pay also a matriculation fee, whereas the Congress statutes prescribe that every taxpayer is at the same time also a member of the community with all active and passive rights — this they have now forgotten. That time the community had to be protected against the "invasion of certain foreign elements," and one could hear from an authentic quarter that the Congress statutes not only can be altered, but must be altered from case to case, for they had not reckoned with the development of the great Jewish community of Pest and had not kept equal pace with it.

So the Neologues do not give way and yet wish to have peace. The Orthodox, to be sure, will hear nothing of it, for they have only to lose and nothing to gain. This one-sided peace movement is to be traced to various grounds. The Ministry of Worship and Education has of late shown itself not very favourable to the Jewish communities in general. From the State they are, according to Law-Article XX of 1848, to receive a proportionately equal subvention for their purposes of worship and schooling as the other recognised confessions. Instead of this there fell to their share in the year 1903 the ridiculous sum of 44,800 K., whereas even the smallest Jewish community maintains a school. As late as the beginning of the school year the Minister restricted the activity of the Talmud Torah schools. But the heaviest blow the Jewish communities have suffered through the ministerial decree of the 23rd of November 1904, by virtue of which the Jews are directed, in the differences arising in their communal affairs, to apply, passing over the National Chancery, directly to the municipal authority, or the administrative committee, and in the highest instance to the Ministry of Worship. This state of things must be remedied by the granting of autonomy. Autonomy can be won only through inner peace; therefore come, dear brethren, let us make peace.

In this, as a matter of course, appeal must be made to the patriotism of both parties, with which they are on both sides imbued. Nor may one leave out of sight Zionism, which has at this moment crept into the country and might cast suspicion upon the patriotism of the Hungarian Jews.

When the assimilationist paper "Egyenlőség" appealed to the last-mentioned motive for peace, it could appeal to the fact that really once, at the Mizrachist congress at Pressburg, the extremest Orthodoxy and the full-blooded assimilationists did unite. But this time it will not succeed. The Orthodox resist every union and want an autonomy of their own. On the 27th of February there will be held in Budapest an assembly of all the clerical and lay delegates of the whole Orthodoxy of Hungary, in order above all to elect the new President of the Executive Commission and to discuss the matter of autonomy. Of a definite candidate there is as yet no talk. Into conjectures we will not enter. It would be very advantageous not only for us, but also for the Orthodoxy, if it were to exclude from the leadership the Chassidic elements, and those who fight vehemently against every enlightenment of the Jewish masses, for the Hungarian Orthodoxy is sick through and through and without power of resistance. There is simply a lack of such people as would be capable of uniting the national-conservative spirit and modern culture.

An improvement of the situation can be expected in Hungary only from Zionism. The movement is here indeed in its initial stage, but it is gradually advancing. We have great difficulties to overcome. On the one hand the deep-rooted Chauvinism, which is still greater and more morbid in the Jews of Hungary than in the core of Magyardom; on the other the peculiar level of education of the traditional Jewry of this place, the violent attacks of the Jewish assimilationist press and of the Judæo-Magyar newspapers, which seek to discredit our movement by artificially invented fables. In this their work an organ calling itself Zionist also came to our aid. In the year 1903 there had at last been constituted from among University students the table-society "Makkabäa," which set itself the work of purification as the first point of its programme. After this had succeeded, all labour was concentrated upon bringing the Zionist idea nearer to the Jewish population of the capital and of the country, and all preparatory steps were taken for the founding of a Hungarian organ. The "Zsidó Néplap" was called into life on the 1st of May 1904, and it has been possible to maintain it until now. The directors of the paper spare no pains to carry the struggle further; only the Hungarian Zionists — even those who do not understand the Hungarian language — must support the paper, for if the organ, after many achievements to which it can point, had to give up its existence in the midst of the struggle, they would only have increased the enemy's trophies of victory and made the movement in Hungary impossible for many a year.

The national organisation now stands headless in Hungary. The future man of the leadership must be sought in Budapest, and the national central office must be in the heart of the country. A conference to be convened hither for this purpose at the beginning of the coming month will have to decide whom the Hungarian Zionists hold suitable for this post. A man must be sought and found who may not rest until the statutes of the Zionist societies in Hungary are legalised. For, incredible as it may perhaps sound, in Hungary neither the national organisation nor the individual societies stand upon legal ground. And let no one suppose that the Government stands in the way here. We can tell of a case in which the State authority found nothing to object to in the statutes of a newly founded Zionist society, but, before sanctioning them, to the Israelite National Chancery for