Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 2 · 13 January 1905
2printed page
scan 2 of 20
Facsimile · scan 2 of 20
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 2.

(continued from page 1)

...said against the authority of the Congress, but had only believed that one must come before the Congress with definite proposals, in case the report of the Commission should prove favourable.

Director Wolffsohn expresses his opinion that above all clearness must be created as to the situation; what was needful was to convoke as quickly as possible a Congress which should have to concern itself with the organisation alone. Only when a leadership was in existence could the settlement of the East Africa question and of all other questions be proceeded with.

Dr. Tschlenow: The question whether a specially convoked Congress has to decide is, according to the interpretation of Dr. Herzl himself, not quite clear. It is possible that we shall have a Congress two or three months after the report of the expedition becomes known, and we must then also bring our East Africa matter to a final decision, because this question is at present the most burning question in Zionism. So long as this question is not decided, an election for the A.C. cannot be undertaken. He moved that the programme of the next Zionist Congress should comprise the point of organisation as well as the other points which now occupy our organisation, the work in Palestine, National Fund, etc., and also the East Africa question. For formal reasons the latter could be dealt with in a special sitting. The elections for the A.C., however, must take place only after the decision of this question.

Mr. Greenberg defends his procedure in the whole question. He was a Zionist through and through and had always been for Palestine.

In the afternoon sitting the discussion on the question of the convocation of the Congress is continued.

Dr. Scheinkin expresses his view that a division of the Congress into a Zionist and an East Africa Congress is impossible. Dr. Jasinowski concurs in this view. One would never arrive at an election before the East Africa matter had been brought to an end.

Dr. Bodenheimer asks that his motion be adopted; one could not yet know at all whether an East Africa Congress would be necessary; that depended, after all, upon the report of the expedition. A special Congress for the East Africa question was, on the strictest interpretation, to be convoked only if settlement in East Africa were in question. In that case the Congress could still resolve upon the convocation of a special Congress.

In the voting the following motions are adopted and are thus raised to resolutions:

  1. Motion of Prof. Warburg: Two Congresses one after the other in unbroken succession.

  2. Additional motion of Wolffsohn: The order shall be: first, ordinary, secondly, extraordinary Congress.

  3. Motion of Dr. Scheinkin: The Congress is to be opened, if possible, on the anniversary of the death of Dr. Herzl, i.e., on the 27th of July.

  4. Motion of Dr. Tschlenow - Bodenheimer: The motion "to elect a commission in the matter of East Africa" is referred back to the Committee of Thirteen for renewed deliberation and decision.

  5. Motion of Dr. Bodenheimer: The Congress for East Africa is to be convoked only if the Greater A.C. considers it necessary to deliberate upon the settlement of East Africa.

In this sitting the relation of the Committee of Thirteen to the Smaller A.C. was also discussed. After a lengthy debate agreement was reached upon the following resolution, submitted by Dr. Bodenheimer and Jasinowski, which was adopted unanimously: The members of the Committee of Thirteen are entitled to demand of the Smaller A.C. at any time a detailed report on important matters which come up for discussion in the sittings of the Smaller A.C., including the political ones. Furthermore, the enlarged Committee is entitled to grant special powers to individual persons for the settlement of any important matters. These have to report to the Committee of Thirteen, or, as the case may be, to the Smaller A.C.

Thursday, the 5th of January.

The discussion of the whole day was devoted to deliberation upon the new organisation and the future leadership of the movement. It found its conclusion in the adoption of a compromise motion between the Smaller A.C. and Dr. Bodenheimer: The leadership of the Zionist movement is exercised by the Greater A.C. and by a Smaller A.C. The Smaller A.C. consists of at least three members residing in one place and a number of members from elsewhere. Dr. Bodenheimer moves an additional motion, which reads: The Smaller A.C. consists in all of five members. This additional motion is adopted.

In the Friday sitting the resolutions of the Committee of Thirteen relating to the inauguration of the practical work in Palestine and the establishment of the Kishineff orphan school, upon which Dr. Soskin had reported on behalf of the Palestine Commission, were taken note of. In the afternoon sitting the legalisation of the National Fund was put up for discussion. As is known, the Annual Conference had completed a draft of statutes and had charged the Smaller A.C. to take steps for the legalisation of these statutes. The Smaller A.C. now reports on its labours in this regard. According to the opinions obtained from English lawyers, it was possible to constitute the National Fund as a company of its own, or to place it by a deed - Trust Deed - under the administration of the Jewish Colonial Trust, or, as the case may be, of its Council. Reasons of expediency spoke for the latter proposal. The report of the Smaller A.C., which was delivered by Dr. Kokesch, was followed by a lengthy debate, which closed with the adoption of the motion: It be left to the Smaller A.C., which has to delegate one or two Zionist lawyers to London, to take the final steps for the legalisation of the National Fund in England. It was further resolved to examine on this occasion also the alteration of the paragraph of the Memorandum of the Jewish Colonial Trust, the question of the lapse of the dividend coupons, the question of the voting right of the holders of bearer shares, and the relation of the holders of founders' shares to the Council itself.

To Messrs. Greenberg and Dr. Soskin the thanks of the A.C. are expressed for their efforts.

In conclusion Dr. Bodenheimer asked leave to speak and said, amid the unanimous applause of the members of the A.C.: "In the three days in which we have taken counsel together, we have the way to an inner