No. 53 — "Die Welt" — Page 15
(continued from page 14)
…sonably judging wife of his patron and friend Laube, who at first, as Ludwig Eisenberg mentions in his biography of Sonnenthal, saw in him only the "bandy-legged, sweet Jew." More significant was the experience he had in 1889 at Riga, being by then the famous artist and chief stage-manager of the Burgtheater. After a brilliant starring engagement at St. Petersburg and Moscow, Sonnenthal came on that occasion to Riga as well. There, after three appearances, he was suddenly expelled by the chief of police. The Jew Sonnenthal, it appears, could not produce the special permission required by law for residence in Riga. It needed the intervention of the Austro-Hungarian Ambassador to have the expulsion revoked. Sonnenthal, into whose tranquil artist's life scarcely much news of the misery of his Russian fellow-Jews can have penetrated, had experienced just a very little in his own person how it fared with them. The Lueger era in Vienna and Austria later saw to it that Sonnenthal could observe rather more frequently how well-disposed people in general were toward his brethren.
Have all these experiences passed over Sonnenthal without leaving a trace? Can this gifted, clear-thinking, deep-feeling man have found pleasure in the loathsome assimilationist doings of certain Jewish circles? It is scarcely conceivable. At least none of his actions, so far as they have become known, speaks for it. When respected Jewish corporations turned to him, he never refused his help. He still holds to-day the post of a Vice-President of the Jewish Museum in Vienna. It has not become known of him that he is ashamed of his Judaism, that it is irksome to him. Indeed, he is even said to have resolutely opposed the intention of one of his sons to be baptized.
That is pretty well all that has been said and can be said of Sonnenthal's activity as a Jew. To be sure, a man such as he has already done something if he has not left his fellow-Jews in the lurch. He has passed through a time which had no inkling of the revival of Jewish thought and feeling, nay, which denied with scorn and anger every possibility of a resurrection. He has grown old in a circle of people who were and are miles removed from everything Jewish — (in their flat jargon this is still called to-day "the narrow confessional element"). He for his part, however, where it approached him in artistic, and therefore to him more intelligible, form, had friendly recognition for the Jewish Moderns. All this, to be sure, is nothing in comparison with what he might have been to the Jewish people, had it been able to offer him a ground for his activity. His "Uriel Acosta," his "Nathan" and his "de Sylva" give an idea of what the artist Sonnenthal would have become, had he not, as a child of his time, also had to play his part in the tragi-comedy of assimilation. Perhaps it will become clear to himself how matters stand with him and with his fellow-Jews when he reads that it is said of him in praise that he refused his son permission to be baptized.
Jewish newspapers have related this on the occasion of his 70th birthday with particular satisfaction. They are very modest, these narrators. Against that there would be nothing to say. That is their affair. But that they believe they thereby confirm Sonnenthal's love for Judaism seems to me very foolish. Whoever expected of Sonnenthal something indecent or stupid may be pleased at it. To me this refusal seems precisely a genuinely Sonnenthal-like act. For his inner relation to Judaism it proves precious little.
Thus Sonnenthal has become a German artist. The Jewish people may rejoice at this too, with painful pride. A great, noble man, helpful and good, has sprung from it, a glorious artist has come forth from its midst, in spite of all the misery and persecution it has to suffer. What would this people not give to mankind if it were allowed to live its own life free and happy? To this people Sonnenthal has kept faith. Would that he could have given it love as well! Ardent love, glowing enthusiasm! Would that he still could, he the ever-young! Then perhaps it might have been sung of him, not only with regard to the figure of "Fabricius":
"Eye, that pierced through the form and show of life, Figure, wherein each breath of soul rang clear, Heart, that has trembled with each earthly woe, Mind, that strove faithfully toward the highest goal, Ye, joined with loving might, have shaped From earthly dust the most moving figure. —r.
Gustav Tuch.
On his 70th Birthday. By Dr. Kalmus (Hamburg).
Gustav Tuch, who on December 21 completed his 70th year at Hamburg in the full freshness of life, is a vigorous personality, working creatively in the service of Jewry, a Jew whose name has a good ring in Jewish public life. He stands alone as one who, in the non-Zionist camp, serves the welfare of the Jewish people as a whole with political insight, fresh daring and untiring energy. He has grasped the significance of our tribal unity and on this foundation has developed a social programme which in many points agrees with the demands of our cultural Zionists. Tuch has beheld the misery of his people and, as one of the first in Germany, has sought to intervene with the remedies of modern economic science.
Tuch, already trained as a social politician, approached the Jewish question only in later years. His works on the German customs system and the importance of free ports, his advocacy of a strong German navy, his activity as editor of the "Hamburger Nachrichten," fall within the period of his unconscious Judaism. It was only the salutary effect of the anti-Jewish movement that led him, too, to work for his own people. He started from the view that the Jew is still suited to-day for his original calling as a tiller of the soil, created institutions for the cultivation of agriculture among the Jews, and thereby directed attention to colonizing endeavours. Tuch has not seen salvation in useless lamentations over antisemitism and in attempts at defence, but, boldly like a Zionist, has laid bare the injuries in the body of his own people, and has worked for years at the economic, intellectual and moral elevation of Western and Eastern Jews alike. Jewish historical societies, Toynbee Halls, children's refuges, homes for women and girls, schools of manual training, and much besides, owe their origin to him, and not only in Hamburg. Without timid misgivings he has called for open battle against the Jewish white-slave traffic, and he has taken in hand the heavy and thankless work of relief for Galicia.
And yet! Do the successes of this national-social Jew correspond to the greatness of his purpose and the strength of his personality? — Not in full measure, at all events. The circles in which he works are still rooted all too deeply in