Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 52 · 23 December 1904
3printed page
scan 3 of 20
Facsimile · scan 3 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 52. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…danger. In spite of it all the iron industry still exists!" That is not statesmanlike thinking. This attempt to live from hand to mouth and to wish that something one sees coming may be held off, and to do nothing instead of looking the difficulty in the face — that is a quality which my opponents, I admit, possess to perfection. In the fiscal controversy my opponents are truly happy in painting on the wall spectres which do not exist at all. They find it easier to show a bogey than to refute the arguments I have put forward. They put into my mouth words I have never said, and then fight valiantly against the creatures of their own fancy.

On alien immigration I said that my opponents ought not to take it so lightly. When it began, it was said to be so slight that it was not worth troubling about. Now it has grown with such rapidity that it has already filled whole districts with anxiety and is beginning to penetrate into other parts of the country. I have received complaints from provincial towns, from Leeds for example, and even from Scottish districts. Shall we look the question seriously in the face, or shall we wait and hope until something unforeseen comes to avert from us all that is the natural consequence of such an invasion?

Now a word about the immigrants themselves. I would indeed not say one heartless word about these poor people, who are driven from their homes by the grossest and most brutal persecution. They truly deserve the greatest pity and the most practical sympathy. Here lies a great problem: how they are to be saved from the fate which has befallen them, how they can be redeemed without the ruin of our own people and country being bound up with it. While I was still in office I did what I could. I had several conferences with the late Dr. Herzl — a man who had made the deepest impression upon me, whose honesty, patriotism and ability were so great that they could not but win him the respect even of those who are opponents of these people — and we were, I may say, in full agreement in principle that the best solution of this question would be to find a land where, either under the aegis of the British flag or under the protection of all the Great Powers, these poor people driven from the land of their birth, who have left it neither from caprice nor with the wish to trouble us, might settle in safety, where they might live freely according to their own religious customs and their own aspirations and find their livelihood without threatening that of others. (Loud applause.) That was the outcome of our discussions.

Although the cause has suffered a great loss by the death of Dr. Herzl, his plans have not perished with him but are being carried forward, and I believe that this very week a commission of exploration leaves for East Africa, where there are still thousands and hundreds of thousands of miles of uninhabited land. This commission will inquire whether an asylum for these persecuted poor might not be found there. That would be the solution of the question. Meanwhile, with our policy of the open door, we have built a bridge between the countries in which these people suffer so much and our own country, which is already over-populated as it is and cannot bear the further admission of great masses of people without great harm. I have said that I do not wish to blame this sorely tried people. Far be it from me to speak ill of them, considering the circumstances in which they have lived; but it is a fact that when these aliens come into our country they are responsible for an increase of crime, disease and hopeless poverty out of all proportion to their numbers. The people come to us — I do not blame them for it, I only show the consequences — come to us and change the whole character of a district, its language and its nationality. Whole quarters of towns have been changed. British workmen have been driven by the impetuous competition of starving men out of trades which formerly supported them. I ask you, is it good for such people themselves to be herded together like beasts in a stall, to toil for a few pence a day, to let themselves be sweated by employers who seem devoid of all fellow-feeling? I say it is an evil for you, as it is an evil for the aliens.

So far as I am concerned, I always was, and am still, in favour of entrusting the Government with the strictest control over this alien immigration."


On the Question of Organisation.

Once More: Vienna or London?

I have waited some weeks to see what impression my proposal to transfer the Inner A.-C. to London would make on the majority of Zionists. I cannot — contrary to my original intention — refrain from taking up the pen once more, and that not only because arguments worthy of consideration have been advanced against it, but also because in the letters to the official organ of the party only opponents of my proposal have had their say. This, however, by no means corresponds to the general feeling, for I have received a whole series of private, and in part very warm, declarations of agreement with my proposal, not only from Germany but also from fellow Zionists abroad.

As for my opponents, I can argue with Herr Paperin only with difficulty. His reasons rest essentially on sentiment. And to sentiment I am accessible only in private life; in my opinion it does not belong to politics. In the desperate situation in which our people finds itself, we have to uphold principles of utility alone; we have to exclude all policy of feeling.

Memories of Dr. Herzl have for me the greatest value imaginable; his grave shall and will be a hallowed place for our people. But the living have to fulfil his task, to complete his work; and if that can be done better from another place than from Vienna, we must let no stirrings of feeling whatever hinder us. Theodor Herzl would himself have been the last to recommend anything of the kind to us.

With sharper weapons a Herr Deiches, in No. 48 of "Die Welt," has combated my proposal. The weapons have, indeed, in his hand become all too sharp — personal. Herr Deiches cannot demand that I him onto