Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 50 · 9 December 1904
5printed page
scan 5 of 20
Facsimile · scan 5 of 20
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 50 — "Die Welt" — Page 5

From England.

In my previous letter I began to write about the anti-alien policy. It was a time when a grave complication of international relations was generally feared in England. At one moment it was Russia from which hostilities were expected; then attention was directed to the Indian frontier. It was a time of tension and uncertainty. But the storm has subsided. Lord Landsdowne's speech has calmed men's minds. With Russia there is to be no war after all. A treaty has been concluded with France, and Portugal has bound herself still more closely to Britain, Dom Carlos paying King Edward a ceremonial visit. And the reception of the Lusitanian royal pair was a magnificent one. A small country with a great past behind it, which was once the mightiest colonial empire and has now sunk so low, nestles against the breast of the mighty British lion — and the fierce lion strokes its feeble friend and takes it under his protection. Not, of course, wholly from humane motives. England wishes, after all, to keep the coast of the Pyrenean peninsula secure. And if Gibraltar is not quite safe — Oporto grows ever more English. Here one might indulge in historical and politico-philosophical reflections. Sidon and Jerusalem — that is Lisbon and London. London could only become strong when Lisbon grew weak. Walter Raleigh, Warren Hastings, John the Navigator could not have risen, had Vasco de Gama and Magelhaens continued to be handed down in Portuguese history, had Portugal remained as strong as she once was. But fanaticism and religious intolerance, which are always the mark of an unwise policy, have made a ruin of that flourishing land. The same is indeed the case with Spain. Had Spain not perished of the cruel amputation which Ferdinand the All-too-Catholic performed upon her by banishing the Jews and the Moors, fair Castile might perhaps have played first fiddle in the European concert.

Spain did not understand this, and has given to the whole world an enormous number of forces that might have been of service to herself. To pick one example out of many: I will not point to the well-known personalities of the political and literary world who are descended from Spanish Jews. But there is one fact, probably unknown to most readers, which I should like to bring forward. Lady Blenner-Hasset, in her newest book on the celebrated Cardinal Newman, tells us the story of this eminent man, who marks an epoch for religious England. He it was, after all, who introduced Catholicism into England! And now it turns out that this Cardinal, formerly a High Churchman of prominent position, afterwards a purple-clad Roman prelate, is of Jewish stock, and indeed a descendant of a Jewish family that fled from Spain. It is by no means a source of pride for Judaism that we furnish the Christian Church ubique terrarum with its best pillars — Neander, Franz Delitzsch, Herschell, Ratisbonne, etc. — but it is an interesting psychological contribution to the knowledge of the Jewish psyche. But... I am wandering from one thing to another. Nor do I wish to pursue dreary politics. Politics viewed from a higher standpoint — politics in connection with history, with the past and the future of the people — such politics cannot cling merely to the words of this or that "Politician", this or that "Member of Parliament". And that, indeed, is the fault of most of our Jewish politicians in England. They will not look further than their own noses.

Our friend Lucien Wolf, the "Diplomaticus" of the "Contemporary Review", is a far-ranging statesman whenever any international or English political question is concerned. The Jewish question, however, he treats like a "municipal" question — he, the historian! But then we are accustomed to contradictions. One further small reflection may be attached to the Portuguese visit to London. At the last Congress it was asserted that Uganda would be a Jewish colony, and that the metropolis would then follow. The theory may be very ingenious; it may sound fine as a paradox to assert that with the Jews, for once, the ordinary laws of sociology and politics do not hold. But it need not be true on that account. The history of Portugal teaches us this very plainly. A weak metropolis cannot have colonies, cannot keep those once taken into possession, cannot influence them culturally — all the more so when there is no metropolis at all. Then it must be regarded a fortiori, or, as we Jews say, "al achas kama ukama", that the colony will not prosper. And in fact we see from the reports from America that Mr. Zangwill's apostolate for Uganda finds no great response among the American Zionists. Indeed, the Zionists across the ocean are rather disappointed. They had expected that the great spokesman of Zionism would show somewhat more regard for the ancient Jewish ideal. To found a colony without having a metropolis is like buying a nail before one has acquired the lamp.

And now I return to internal Anglo-Jewish politics. As is known, the struggle for and against Chamberlain has again grown fierce. The Duke of Devonshire and Sir Campbell-Bannerman have made great speeches against the system of the Imperialists. Balfour wavers as ever. The Chamberlain party, too, is arming itself. A campaign of speeches and of the press is beginning. Balfour's position grows more precarious from day to day. It is still unknown which of the two parties will carry off the victory — the free-trade or the protectionist. One thing is clear: Balfour will not hold on for long. With Balfour falls also the Aliens Bill, of which he was the advocate. But let us consider what prospects the Bill will have in the event of a victory of either of England's principal parties. Should Chamberlain's party gain the upper hand — the imperialist, the exclusive party, which wishes to tear England out of the old framework of her tolerant, free, somewhat sentimentalising policy, which would set might above right — then the fate of the immigrants is indeed sealed. The Aliens Bill is wholly in the spirit of the protectionists. For once the rule is "as you do to me, so I do to you", once the principle of "Retaliation", of requital, has been made the basis of Britain's fiscal and international policy, then in the question of immigration too the rule will be: if Russia, let us say, allows the English Jews free immigration, we too shall let the Russian Jews in, or "if you thrash my Jew, I'll thrash yours". That is "Retaliation" indeed. Suppose, now, that the Liberals, the Unionists, had won — which is hardly likely either — then, even then, the Aliens Bill would be carried through. For the adherents of Lord Rosebery and Sir Campbell Bannerman, too, cannot hold quite rigidly to the old doctrines of "free-tradery".

They must make some concession to the Imperialists. And if a scapegoat is needed — then the "Alien", the poor Polish Jew, is the best object for it. Not a soul will get excited about it — not even Mr. Louis Sinclair. And even if the